Choosing women’s shoes without making the wrong purchase: find the right pair for every occasion

A pair of women’s shoes may look appealing online, but you’ll only know whether the fit, sole and materials really suit you once you wear them day to day. A soft insole, for example, isn’t automatically suitable for long walks. And a water-repellent outer layer doesn’t offer the same protection as a fully waterproof construction.

Use these checks to compare women’s trainers, casual shoes and walking shoes based on practical features, rather than just the brand name or appearance.

Common pitfalls when choosing women’s shoes

1. Mistaking comfort for soft cushioning

Shoes with memory foam often feel comfortable when you first put them on. However, a soft insole doesn’t tell you much about the support you’ll get after several hours of walking. Check the shape of the sole, how securely the heel fits and whether the insole is removable. A softer shoe isn’t always suitable for fitness, long walks or uneven ground.

2. Mistaking water-repellent for waterproof

A water-repellent outer layer can help keep out light rain, but it’s not the same as a waterproof membrane. When looking at hiking boots, check the product description, lining and how the tongue and seams are constructed. For muddy paths and puddles in the Netherlands, waterproof women’s hiking boots are more practical than ordinary trainers.

3. Looking only at the size

EU sizing can vary between models and brands. Width, heel shape and the amount of room around your toes also affect comfort. Measure both feet at the end of the day and compare the longer foot with the size chart. Some models may require a half size or a full size up, especially if you wear thick walking socks.

Three features you should always check

Fit, foot length and width

A good fit starts with your foot length in millimetres. Also check whether the shoe is described as a regular, narrow or wide fit. Product details can vary considerably between models:

• The Skechers Summits - Dazzling Haze is described as a regular fit and is available in sizes including 39, 40, 40.5 and 41.
• The Skechers Arch Fit-Big Appeal in size 36 is described in the product information as a generous fit, with a recommendation to size down.
• The PELLIOT women’s hiking boots use a foot-length chart from 225 to 245 mm, corresponding to EU sizes 35 to 39.
• If you’re looking for women’s shoes in sizes 36 to 45, check the available sizes for each model. Not every women’s style is available up to size 45.

Sole and intended use

Flexible soles are often enough for commuting and shopping. For fitness, grip, stability and freedom of movement matter more. On unpaved paths, look for a treaded sole, heel support and protection around the toes.

High-top women’s walking shoes generally offer more coverage around the ankle than low-cut styles. This can be useful on rocky or uneven routes, but often makes the shoe less flexible. So don’t choose a heavy trekking boot if you’ll mainly be walking on flat cycle paths.

Material and care

Textile and mesh feel lightweight and generally allow more air to circulate. Canvas, as used in some Converse styles, works well for casual wear but needs extra care in wet weather. Leather and synthetic materials can offer more protection, but each requires its own care.

Always check the care instructions. The Skechers Summits is described in the product information as machine washable, while the Skechers Hillcrest should only be cleaned with a damp cloth and mild soap. The PELLIOT hiking boots must not be put in a washing machine or tumble dryer; the recommended approach is to wipe them clean and leave them to air-dry.

Our recommendations for different types of user

Suitable for: Budget-conscious beginners

CONVERSE Women Shoes A12474C STAR PLAYER 76 OX 44.5

Why it suits this profile: The low-cut style with a canvas upper is easy to wear with jeans, dresses and everyday outfits.

How this product helps you avoid the pitfall

The product information clearly states that it has a canvas upper, textile lining and vulcanised rubber sole. So you’ll know it’s primarily a casual shoe, not a technical walking shoe.

Key benefit & features

Low-cut fit, canvas upper, padded insole and grippy rubber outsole.

Suitable for: Shoppers looking for premium quality

Skechers Arch Fit-Big Appeal 149057-BBK 36

Why it suits this profile: This style is designed for everyday wear, with an engineered mesh upper, lace-up fastening and an Air-Cooled Memory Foam insole, according to the product description.

How this product helps you avoid the pitfall

The sizing advice is clear: this style comes up generously, and the available product size is EU 36. Check your foot length before ordering.

Key benefit & features

Mesh upper, rubber sole, lace-up fastening and removable insole, according to the listed specifications.

Suitable for: Specific needs & intensive use

PELLIOT High-Top Hiking Boots for Women Camping Travel – Rock Gray (EU 38)

Why it suits this profile: According to the product information, the high-top construction, protective toe cap and treaded sole are designed for more demanding hiking routes and terrain.

How this product helps you avoid the pitfall

The product description mentions a waterproof membrane, protective toe cap and rubber treaded sole. Before buying, check the size chart and wear suitable walking socks.

Key benefit & features

High-top cut, hard-wearing synthetic upper, protective toe cap and rubber treaded sole.

Which women’s shoes are right for you?

• For everyday wear: choose women’s trainers or casual shoes with a regular fit and flexible rubber sole.
• For fitness: look for a low, stable sole, good grip and an upper that allows plenty of ventilation. A soft insole alone isn’t enough.
• For walking on paved surfaces: comfortable women’s walking shoes with light cushioning and a secure heel are often more practical than heavy boots.
• For woodland, hills and rain: choose high-top women’s walking shoes with a treaded sole, toe protection and a clearly specified waterproof membrane.
• For style and everyday outfits: Converse women’s shoes, Nike women’s trainers and Skechers women’s shoes offer different combinations of canvas, leather, textile and synthetic materials. Compare the specifications for each style, not just the logo.

Frequently asked questions about women’s shoes

How do I know what size women’s shoes to order?

Measure both feet in millimetres while standing, then use the size chart for the specific style. If there’s a difference, use the longer foot as your guide. Walking shoes may need extra room for socks and for your feet to move on descents.

How long do women’s shoes usually last?

Lifespan depends on walking distance, terrain, body weight, care and materials. A casual trainer worn around town is put under different demands from a hiking boot used on muddy paths. Replace your shoes when the sole becomes visibly smooth, the heel wears unevenly, or the lining and fastening no longer work properly.

Are memory foam shoes suitable for walking?

A memory foam insole can feel comfortable, but it doesn’t determine on its own whether a shoe is suitable for walking. Check the grip, flexibility, fit and support too. On unpaved terrain, a treaded sole and sturdy construction are usually more important than a soft insole.