Audiobook commuter on a noisy train
You want to follow the narrator without constantly turning up the volume, even when there’s background noise.
Above all, choose a fit that stays comfortable throughout your journey and lets you follow spoken content at a comfortable volume. If train noise is distracting, a well-sealing pair of over-ear or in-ear headphones with ANC may be worth considering; the Consumers’ Association assesses speech reproduction and noise cancellation as separate factors. If you want to hear announcements, compare a transparency mode or open-ear design too, and pause your story when you need to listen out for important information.
You want to follow the narrator without constantly turning up the volume, even when there’s background noise.
You wear your headphones for much of the journey and want to know whether the ear cushions, ear tips and, if you wear them, glasses will remain comfortable.
You want to pause easily or hear what’s happening around you while listening, for example when changing trains.
Choose this if: you want to follow spoken content on longer journeys and have room in your bag.
Bear in mind: they take up more space in your bag, and ANC doesn’t guarantee that announcements or conversations will disappear.
Choose this if: a compact option and a close-fitting seal matter more to you than the feel of over-ear headphones.
Bear in mind: fit varies from ear to ear. Try different tip sizes to find one that seals well without uncomfortable pressure.
Choose this if: hearing announcements and surrounding sounds matters more to you than maximum noise isolation.
Bear in mind: more outside noise will get through. Check that you can still follow the narrator without turning the volume up unnecessarily.
For listening on the train, first compare speech clarity and fit comfort; then consider how you want to switch between your story and announcements.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who should prioritise this |
|---|---|---|
| A narrator you can understand over train noise | Compare speech reproduction and noise cancellation; assess them as separate features and don’t expect complete silence. | If I don’t want to miss sentences in a noisy carriage, clear speech comes first. Around 36% of consumers give this their top priority. |
| Comfort throughout the journey | Try over-ear headphones with your glasses on, or test the available tip sizes; check for pressure and a good seal. | For long listening sessions, I want my headphones to stay comfortable. Around 29% of consumers place the greatest value on long-wearing comfort. |
| Hearing announcements and your surroundings | Check the controls for pausing and hearing ambient sound; don’t rely solely on transparency mode when listening for important information. | If I want to hear an announcement while changing trains, I need to be able to switch quickly from listening to paying attention. Around 21% of consumers prioritise announcements. |
| Battery life and space in your bag | Compare listening time per charge using the same ANC setting; don’t count time with a charging case in the same way. | When journey lengths vary, I want to know what I need to bring and whether I might need to recharge along the way. Around 14% of consumers put battery life and portability first. |
Noise cancellation and natural-sounding, intelligible speech are different features. So an ANC label alone won’t tell you how easy an audiobook will be to follow in your situation.
Compare both features and, where possible, try listening to a spoken passage at a comfortable volume.
Listening time per charge and total time including the charging case aren’t the same. The stated battery life may also depend on your listening settings.
Compare the stated time per charge in the listening mode you plan to use, and bear in mind how long your journey will be.
A Joybuy listing for a Bose QuietComfort model mentions QC45 in the description. A general model title may therefore not make it clear exactly which version is being offered.
Before buying, check the full model number, variant and product specifications on the product details page.
The WH-1000XM6 is an over-ear model to compare if you’re looking for ANC, an ambient sound mode and multipoint connectivity.
The MOMENTUM 4 Wireless is an over-ear option to consider if you want to factor in the stated battery life and a transparency mode.
The Tour One M3 is an over-ear model to consider if adaptive noise cancellation is one of your selection criteria.
AirPods Pro 3 are a compact in-ear option with ANC and a transparency mode.
QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen) are an over-ear alternative supplied with a carry case.
These Joybuy products include over-ear and sealing in-ear models with ANC. Compare the listening mode, battery life and fit listed for each model.
No image available
An over-ear option to compare if you want to use ANC and a transparency mode while travelling.
The product description lists adaptive ANC, up to 60 hours of playback, fast charging and a transparency mode; the stated battery life isn’t a measure of how long they’ll last in your use.
No image available
A compact in-ear option to compare if you want to save space in your bag.
The product description lists adaptive ANC, a transparency mode, several ear tip sizes and up to 30 hours of playback including the charging case.
No image available
An over-ear option to compare if noise cancellation and listening on a longer journey matter to you.
The product description lists active noise cancellation, leather ear cushions, up to 24 hours of battery life and the option to use an audio cable when the battery runs out.
No image available
An over-ear option to compare if you also want to consider an ambient sound mode while listening.
The product description lists ANC, an Aware mode, multipoint connectivity and up to 30 hours of listening with ANC.
No image available
An over-ear option to compare if you’re considering adjustable noise cancellation for train journeys.
The product description lists active noise cancellation with adjustable levels, up to 35 hours of battery life with noise cancellation on and fast charging.
No, not if you want to follow an announcement or conversation. Pause your story or use a suitable ambient sound mode, and check for yourself that you can hear important information; a mode like this isn’t a guarantee.
Try the available tip sizes and check for pressure and a good seal during a longer listening session. Apple supplies five sizes with AirPods Pro 3, but that doesn’t mean one of them will fit everyone.
Check the listening time per charge in the mode you plan to use. Apple claims up to 8 hours per charge with ANC for AirPods Pro 3, and up to 24 hours including the case; the manufacturer’s figure isn’t a measure of how long they’ll last in your use.
According to the Dutch government, when you buy at a distance you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period; check the terms and any exceptions that apply to your purchase. You’re also entitled to a product that meets legal requirements under the statutory guarantee, separate from any manufacturer’s warranty.
Consider not only the volume, but also how long and how often you listen to loud sounds. The World Health Organization identifies volume, listening duration and frequency of exposure as factors; the volume setting on your phone doesn’t always directly indicate how much sound reaches your ears.