Listening in a noisy carriage
You want to follow spoken stories despite the rumble of the train and the noise of fellow passengers. Consumentenbond and RTINGS.com highlight fit and seal as factors to consider for sound isolation.
In a noisy train carriage, a well-fitting pair of headphones with active noise cancelling can make spoken stories easier to follow, without having to keep turning up the volume. If you also want to hear station announcements, look for an easy-to-reach ambient sound mode. Fit, comfort and battery life will then help you choose the right model for your journey.
You want to follow spoken stories despite the rumble of the train and the noise of fellow passengers. Consumentenbond and RTINGS.com highlight fit and seal as factors to consider for sound isolation.
You want to concentrate on a story but also be able to hear what’s happening around you quickly. Check how to activate ambient sound mode; Sony describes this feature on the WH-CH720N.
You wear your headphones for longer periods and take them with you on the train. Consider pressure on your ears, how much space they take up in your bag and battery life with noise cancelling on.
Start by deciding whether you mainly want to reduce train noise or still hear announcements. Then check the fit, controls and battery life to make sure they suit your journey.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Understanding speech over train noise | Compare noise reduction and check that the ear cups fit snugly. If possible, listen to a spoken-word clip. | If I want to follow a story in a noisy carriage, I don’t want to keep turning up the volume. Around 36% of consumers say speech clarity in noisy surroundings is their top priority. |
| Hearing announcements and fellow passengers | Try switching to ambient sound mode and back again to see how easy it is. | If I want to notice my stop or hear someone speaking to me, quick access to ambient sound matters. Around 29% of consumers prioritise awareness of their surroundings. |
| Comfort during long listening sessions | Check the pressure from the headband and ear cups, and make sure the headphones will fit in your bag. | On a long journey, I want to wear a model that doesn’t press uncomfortably. Around 21% of consumers say comfort is their main consideration. |
| Cost and battery life | Compare battery life using the same ANC setting; the maximum quoted battery life may apply when noise cancelling is off. | If I listen regularly, I want to know how often I’ll need to charge the headphones in the mode I use. Around 14% of consumers prioritise cost and ease of charging. |
Quoted battery life can vary depending on the listening mode. JBL states that the Tune 770NC offers up to 70 hours with ANC off and 44 hours with ANC on.
Compare battery life using the noise-cancelling mode you plan to use on your train journey.
Ambient sound can be useful if you want to hear station announcements, but this mode also lets in more noise that could distract you from the story.
Check how to switch quickly between listening modes, and pause the story when you want to listen out for an announcement.
Over-ear models take up more room in your bag, while on-ear models can put more pressure on your ears. Fit varies from person to person.
If possible, try the headband and ear cups for longer than a brief listening session, and check that the model fits in your bag.
The WH-CH720N and WH-1000XM5 are over-ear models with noise cancelling. Sony quotes different maximum battery lives with NC on.
The Tune 770NC is a foldable over-ear model with noise cancelling and Smart Ambient.
According to Sennheiser, the MOMENTUM 4 Wireless has adaptive noise cancelling and a transparency mode.
This selection from Joybuy includes wireless headphones and earbuds for travel, with a range of designs and listed features. Check each model to see whether its features suit your needs for noise cancelling, comfort or a compact design.
No image available
A good option if you’re looking for wireless over-ear headphones with noise cancelling and a transparency mode.
Sennheiser quotes up to 60 hours of playback, although this figure isn’t linked to a specific ANC setting.
The product information lists adaptive noise cancelling, a transparency mode and fast charging.
No image available
A good option if you’re looking for wireless headphones that fold up for travel.
The product description lists Bluetooth 5.3 and a foldable design.
No image available
A good option if you’re looking for over-ear headphones with active noise cancelling.
The product title states a 24-hour battery life, but doesn’t specify the listening mode for this figure.
The product description mentions a lightweight design and soft ear cushions.
No image available
A good option if you’re looking for a compact wireless model rather than over-ear headphones.
The product description lists a half-in-ear design and Bluetooth connectivity.
No image available
A good option if you want to take wireless headphones with you and are looking for a foldable design.
The product description lists up to 16 hours of playback, Bluetooth 5.0, an AUX socket and playback via a TF card.
Before setting off, try ambient sound mode with a spoken-word clip and check how to switch it on quickly. Sony describes adjustable ambient sound for the WH-CH720N. What you hear during your journey will also depend on the surroundings and the volume you’ve set.
No. Turning up the volume isn’t a good substitute for well-fitting headphones. The World Health Organization emphasises that both sound level and listening time affect the risk to your hearing. Its example of 80 dB for up to 40 hours a week is guidance, not a level you can set on a volume slider without measuring it.
No. According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. You’re entitled to a product that works as it should, and the seller is your point of contact if there’s a problem. Online purchases from a business are also often covered by a 14-day cooling-off period. Check the terms that apply to your purchase.
NS describes the quiet carriage as a place where passengers are expected to keep quiet. Keep your listening volume low enough not to disturb others, and don’t have conversations there.