Who is this guide for?

Soundtrack listener on a noisy train

You want to follow quiet passages without constantly turning up the volume. Fit, isolation and adjustable noise cancelling may all be important. The WHO recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones to reduce the need to listen at higher volumes in noisy environments.

Long-distance traveller who cares about sound and comfort

You listen to calm and dynamic music for extended periods, so you want to weigh up sound, pressure on your ears and battery life. Which? includes sound quality, comfort and battery life in its assessment of headphones.

Traveller with limited bag space

You’d rather take compact wireless earbuds, provided they fit comfortably and last long enough. Which? points out that you can charge earbuds on the go using the charging case, but you can’t use them while they’re charging.

What should you look for in headphones for the train?

First, choose between larger over-ear headphones and compact, noise-isolating earbuds. Then decide whether quiet, sound, comfort or size matters most to you. This comparison is for people who want to listen to film music wirelessly on the train, with one main buying priority for each row.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Blocking out train noise Compare the fit and isolation, adjustable noise cancelling, and how easy it is to use ambient mode. If I want to hear quiet passages without turning up the volume, I’m looking for a good seal and effective noise cancelling. Around 36% of consumers prioritise reducing background noise.
Soundtrack quality Listen to familiar quiet and dynamic passages at a comfortable volume, and check whether you can adjust the sound. I want both instruments and dynamic passages to sound good, not just one excerpt. Around 29% of consumers choose sound quality as their top priority.
Comfort and playback time Pay attention to pressure from the headband or earbuds, and compare battery life with noise cancelling on under the same conditions. For a long journey, I want a comfortable fit that lasts and enough uninterrupted playback time. Around 21% of consumers put comfort first.
Easy to pack Check the fit and playback time per charge; don’t look only at the total usage time including the charging case. If my bag has little room, I’d prefer small earbuds, but I don’t want to have to recharge during the journey. Around 14% of consumers give size top priority.

Common mistakes when choosing

  • Assuming the maximum battery life applies with noise cancelling on

    Manufacturers sometimes quote different figures for noise cancelling on and off. With earbuds, the total including the charging case may also be longer than the earbuds’ continuous playback time on their own.

    Compare figures with the same setting, and check the playback time per charge for earbuds.

    More frequent charging could interrupt a long journey.

  • Expecting noise cancelling to make the train silent

    Noise cancelling doesn’t remove all background noise. A good fit and the ability to hear important sounds still matter.

    Try the fit and check how to use ambient mode. Don’t turn up the volume to drown out the remaining noise.

  • Confusing different generations or versions

    Different generations or updated versions are mentioned for the Bose QuietComfort Ultra and Fairbuds XL. Features and components may vary between versions.

    Before buying, check the full model name, generation, version and included components.

    A different version may have features or replacement parts that aren’t what you expect.

Brands to compare

Sony

The WH-1000XM5 is an over-ear model with noise cancelling, ambient mode and a wired connection.

  • Sony quotes up to 30 hours of music playback with noise cancelling on and up to 40 hours with it off for the WH-1000XM5.
  • These are quoted figures, not measured battery life for your journey; fit and sound preferences are personal.

JBL

The Live 770NC is an over-ear model with noise cancelling, an ambient sound feature, app settings and a video mode.

  • JBL lists 40mm drivers and up to 65 hours with Bluetooth on and noise cancelling off.
  • Don’t assume the maximum playback time applies with noise cancelling on. JBL says LE Audio will be available through a later update.

Sennheiser

The MOMENTUM 4 Wireless combines adjustable sound with adaptive noise cancelling and a transparency mode.

  • Sennheiser lists an equaliser and up to 60 hours of playback time.
  • The maximum battery life is a manufacturer’s figure. It doesn’t prove that the model will sound better to every listener or last 60 hours with every setting.

Fairphone

The Fairbuds XL may be worth considering if replaceable parts are a factor in choosing wireless noise-cancelling headphones.

  • Fairphone lists a replaceable battery and individual components. For the Fairbuds XL shown, the brand quotes up to 26 hours of playback with noise cancelling on.
  • Fairphone has also announced an updated edition. Check which version and components apply to the model; the manufacturer’s figures aren’t an independent comparison of sound or noise cancelling.

Bose

The QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen) has noise cancelling, an ambient mode and a dedicated Cinema Mode.

  • Bose says Cinema Mode is designed to make video content sound more immersive, with clearer dialogue, and quotes up to 30 hours of battery life.
  • A soundtrack without visuals or dialogue won’t automatically benefit from Cinema Mode. Judge the sound for yourself, and don’t confuse the second generation with the original QuietComfort Ultra.

Joybuy headphones for the train

These Joybuy products are over-ear noise-cancelling headphones for listening to film music on a train journey.

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless in white

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless – White

A good fit for anyone who wants to combine noise cancelling with adjustable sound and a transparency mode.

The app includes an equaliser and presets. Sennheiser quotes up to 60 hours of playback time; this is a manufacturer’s figure, not a guarantee for every setting.

View at Joybuy
Sonos Ace in black

Sonos Ace – Black

A good fit for anyone who wants to switch between noise cancelling and hearing the sounds around them.

The description mentions ANC and an Aware mode. According to the product information, the headphones offer up to 30 hours of listening with ANC on; the Sonos app includes EQ settings.

View at Joybuy
Sony WH-1000XM5 in silver

Sony WH-1000XM5 – Silver

A good fit for anyone looking for over-ear headphones with noise cancelling and the option to pause the music when they need to pay attention.

The quoted playback time is up to 30 hours with noise cancelling on. The description also mentions Speak-To-Chat, which pauses the music when you speak.

View at Joybuy
Sony WH-CH720N in blue

Sony WH-CH720N – Blue

A good fit for anyone who wants to adjust the noise-cancelling level in an app.

According to the product description, the ANC level can be adjusted in 20 steps. It also mentions a multipoint connection with two devices and compatibility with 360 Reality Audio.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones, second generation, in black

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen) – Black

A good fit for anyone looking for wireless over-ear headphones with noise cancelling and the option to listen using a cable.

The description mentions Bluetooth and a detachable cable with USB-C and 3.5mm connections. Cinema Mode is described for video content, so it won’t necessarily be useful for a soundtrack on its own.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can I hear train announcements while listening?

Use ambient mode or pause your music if needed. According to Which?, an open-ear design lets more background sound through. Check that you can actually understand announcements on your train, at your chosen volume.

How should I use wireless earbuds on a train journey?

Before you set off, check that both earbuds are charged and fit properly. The charging case can extend the total usage time, but you can’t use the earbuds while they’re charging in the case. Follow the instructions for your chosen model when cleaning the earbuds and replacing the tips.

What purchase and warranty rights apply when buying from a Dutch online shop?

When you buy from a business online, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period, according to the Dutch government. You’re also entitled to a product that is fit for purpose; the Netherlands has no fixed statutory two-year warranty period. If there’s a fault, contact the seller. Before buying, check who the seller is and which returns policy applies to your order.

Can I listen to my own music on the train?

NS house rules require silence in the quiet zone and say you must not disturb other passengers anywhere on the train with loud music. They don’t prohibit listening through headphones. Keep the sound to yourself and stay alert to your surroundings where necessary. This answer applies to NS trains and not necessarily to every train operator.

Should I turn up the volume on a noisy train?

No, turning it up isn’t the recommended solution. The WHO recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones to reduce the need for higher volume, and advises limiting both volume and listening time. The WHO gives 80 dB for up to 40 hours a week as an example of safe listening; this doesn’t guarantee a safe setting on every device’s volume slider.