Story listener in a shared space
You want to follow recorded speech while other people are talking nearby. Speech clarity, fit and how much noise the headphones actually reduce matter more than the ANC label alone.
If your main priority is following the narrator while other people are talking, compare well-fitting, noise-isolating earbuds or over-ear headphones for both speech clarity and how much they reduce conversations. An ANC label alone doesn’t prove that people talking nearby will disappear. If you want to stay approachable, choose a model that lets you pause easily or switch on ambient sound, or consider open-ear earbuds. You’ll hear more of the background conversation with these, too. The Consumers’ Association distinguishes between ANC and sound quality, and points out that ANC doesn’t deal with every type of noise in the same way.
You want to follow recorded speech while other people are talking nearby. Speech clarity, fit and how much noise the headphones actually reduce matter more than the ANC label alone.
You want to listen to a story while still being able to notice conversations, announcements or other important sounds around you. An ambient mode or open-ear design changes the trade-off.
You listen to several stories in a row, so comfort, listening time per charge and keeping the volume moderate all matter.
A good fit if: you want to follow the narrator and find over-ear headphones comfortable. Compare speech clarity and noise reduction separately, as the Consumers’ Association recommends.
Bear in mind: the larger design takes up more space, and an ANC label doesn’t tell you how much it reduces the sound of people talking.
A good fit if: you want a compact design and find a well-fitting set of eartips comfortable.
Bear in mind: fit varies from ear to ear. To hear someone clearly, you’ll need to be able to pause or switch on ambient sound.
A good fit if: staying approachable matters more than blocking out people talking nearby. An open design lets ambient sound through.
Bear in mind: you’ll still hear the background conversation, so this may not be the obvious choice if you want to focus fully on the narrator.
| What to consider | What should you look for? | Who should prioritise this? |
|---|---|---|
| Hearing the narrator clearly | Check the fit and seal; compare speech clarity and noise reduction, ideally with people talking nearby, too. | If I want to follow a story in a shared space, clear speech matters more than an ANC label alone. Around 42% of consumers prioritise speech clarity. |
| Staying approachable | Check how to pause or switch to ambient sound, and consider whether open-ear headphones suit the space where you listen. | If I want to hear or notice someone while listening to a story, easy controls matter more than maximum noise isolation. Around 25% of consumers prioritise staying approachable. |
| Comfort and volume | Consider the pressure from the earcups or eartips, listening time with your chosen ANC setting, and whether the volume controls are easy to reach. | If I listen to several stories in a row, I want a comfortable fit that doesn’t make me keep turning up the volume. Around 17% of consumers prioritise long-lasting comfort. |
| Features you’ll use | Compare the features of the exact model, such as ANC, ambient mode and listening time per charge. | If I mainly listen to short stories, I’d rather not pay for features that don’t suit the way I use my headphones. Around 16% of consumers want to choose only the features they’ll use. |
ANC alone doesn’t tell you how clearly you’ll hear a recorded story when people are talking nearby. The Consumers’ Association treats sound quality and noise reduction as separate things to consider.
Compare speech clarity and noise reduction separately and, where possible, try the headphones in a similar listening environment.
An open-ear design lets ambient sound through. That’s helpful if you want to stay approachable, but it can work against you if you’re trying to block out people talking nearby so you can focus on the narrator.
Choose this style if being able to hear your surroundings comes first. If you want more noise isolation, compare noise-isolating models first.
Total listening time, including the case, isn’t the same as listening without charging in between. So compare the stated listening time per charge using the same ANC setting.
Apple specifies up to 8 hours of listening per charge with ANC on for AirPods Pro 3. You may need to stop and recharge during a longer session.
If you’re listening for a long stretch, plan a charging break if your session is longer than the stated listening time per charge.
The WH-1000XM5 is an over-ear model with ANC and an ambient mode, for listeners who want to switch between blocking out noise and letting outside sounds in.
The Live 780NC is an over-ear model, while the Live 680NC is on-ear. The fit can help you decide which model to try and compare.
AirPods Pro 3 are noise-isolating in-ear earbuds with ANC, Transparency mode and Conversation Awareness. Check the fit and compatibility with your device before relying on these features.
OpenFit 2 is an open-ear option for anyone who wants to keep their ear canals clear and stay approachable.
The Space One is an over-ear model with ANC and adjustable transparency, for anyone weighing up these features against their listening needs.
These Joybuy picks are noise-isolating wireless over-ear headphones with ANC, worth comparing if you want to follow stories while other people are talking. Fit and speech clarity in your listening space remain important considerations.
No image available
The described closed-back over-ear design, ANC and Ambient Sound mode make these worth comparing if you want to listen in a shared space while still being able to let ambient sound in.
No image available
The described closed-back over-ear design and active noise cancellation make these worth comparing for listening to stories in a shared space. Check that the fit feels comfortable for you.
No image available
The described over-ear design with ANC and Aware mode is worth comparing if you want to block out noise while still being able to let ambient sound in.
No image available
This over-ear model with noise cancelling is worth comparing if you want to follow stories in a shared space. Check that it fits well and that the controls suit the way you use it.
No image available
This over-ear model with adaptive active noise cancellation is worth comparing for listening in a shared space. An ANC label alone doesn’t tell you how well it will reduce conversations in your surroundings.
Not necessarily. The Consumers’ Association says ANC often deals with low, constant sounds such as engine noise. When choosing headphones for stories, also compare the fit, speech clarity and noise reduction. An ANC label alone isn’t enough.
Check how to pause or switch to ambient sound on the exact model. Sony says you can switch between noise cancelling and ambient sound on the Sony WH-1000XM5. Speak-to-Chat needs to be enabled beforehand and responds to the wearer’s voice.
Turning up the volume isn’t a good substitute for a proper fit or suitable noise reduction. The World Health Organization gives the example of a maximum of 40 hours per week at an average of 80 dB; at higher sound levels, the recommended listening time decreases. Keep the volume moderate.
The police say it isn’t illegal to cycle with headphones or earbuds, but distractions can be dangerous and you must not obstruct or endanger other traffic. They also say you must not hold a phone or other electronic device while cycling. Make sure you can still hear the sounds around you.
For online purchases from a business, you usually have 14 days to change your mind, according to the Government of the Netherlands. Exceptions may apply, and who the seller is also matters. If a product is faulty, you’re also entitled to a product that works properly and should generally contact the seller. The Netherlands doesn’t have a fixed statutory warranty period of two years.