Who is this for?

Piano listeners on long journeys

If you want to follow quieter passages, you’ll benefit from sound and a fit that remain comfortable during longer listening sessions. The Dutch Consumers’ Association notes that over-ear headphones are often comfortable for long listening sessions, but relatively bulky in a bag. The piano listening test by The Classic Review covered specific models, not headphones on a moving train.

Travellers who want to hear announcements

A pause button or transparency mode can be useful when you want to listen to an announcement. NS asks passengers not to disturb others on the train with loud music.

Travellers with a small bag

If space is limited, you can weigh up the compact size of earbuds against their fit and battery life. The Dutch Consumers’ Association points out that over-ear headphones take up relatively little space.

What should you look for?

Closed-back over-ear headphones with ANC

A good choice for: long journeys when you want to follow quieter piano passages without continually turning up the volume.

Bear in mind: over-ear headphones take up more space in your bag, and ANC won’t block out every conversation or announcement.

Sealed in-ear headphones

A good choice for: limited luggage space, provided the earbuds remain comfortable with the right ear tips.

Bear in mind: fit and seal affect how well they sit in your ears; also check the battery life per charge.

Open-ear or less-sealing earbuds

A good choice for: anyone who wants to hear announcements and other surrounding sounds more directly.

Bear in mind: more outside noise will get in. Don’t try to hear piano details by turning the volume up too high.

Factor What to look for Who is this important for?
Piano sound Listen to a familiar piano piece and compare the same recording with ANC on and off. If I also want to follow quieter passages, I’ll pay attention to the piano sound rather than just a general claim about sound quality. Around 25% of consumers prioritise piano sound.
Reducing train noise Check the fit and compare both the noise reduction and the effect of ANC on the sound. On a noisy journey, I want to hear less background noise without turning up the music. Around 25% of consumers prioritise noise reduction.
Comfort Consider the pressure of on-ear headphones, the space provided by over-ear headphones and the fit of in-ear headphones. If I’m listening for a long time, I want a comfortable model, rather than choosing solely for compactness or extra noise reduction. Around 20% of consumers put comfort first.
Announcements and size Check how to pause your music or switch on transparency mode, and whether the model fits in your bag. I want to be able to hear announcements without using up too much space with my headphones. Around 15% of consumers prioritise this combination of awareness of their surroundings and compact size.
Battery life and cost Compare battery life under the same ANC conditions and check the offer price before buying. If I want to stay within budget and avoid charging during a journey, I’ll factor in battery life. Around 15% of consumers prioritise battery life and cost.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing ANC with complete silence or better piano sound

    Noise cancelling is mainly useful for constant low-frequency noise, and won’t block out every conversation or announcement. The Classic Review also noted that some background noise remained with one of the models it tested.

    Compare sound and noise reduction separately, for example by listening to a familiar piano recording with ANC on and off.

  • Continually turning up the volume to hear more piano detail

    According to the World Health Organization, well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones can help you avoid continually turning up the volume in a noisy environment.

    Focus on fit and suitable noise reduction rather than listening louder, and take breaks during long listening sessions.

  • Assuming similar model names refer to the same version

    The QuietComfort Ultra is sometimes listed with a generation number, while the listening test discussed here doesn’t specify one. The name AirPods Max alone also doesn’t tell you which version it is.

    Before buying, check the full model name, generation and version.

  • Assuming extra cover replaces your statutory rights

    ACM ConsuWijzer makes it clear that statutory rights exist alongside a manufacturer’s or seller’s warranty. An additional service plan doesn’t replace those rights.

    Compare any extra cover with the rights you already have, and read the terms and exclusions before paying for it.

Brands to compare

Bose

The QuietComfort Ultra is an over-ear model worth considering if you’re looking for closed-back headphones for longer listening sessions.

  • The Classic Review described the QuietComfort Ultra it tested as enjoyable for solo piano, with a balanced sound out of the box.
  • That assessment applies to the model tested and the recordings used. It doesn’t prove how the second generation sounds or performs on a Dutch train.

Bowers & Wilkins

The Px7 S3 is an over-ear option worth comparing if both instrument separation and noise cancelling matter to you.

  • The Classic Review noted clear separation between instruments with the Px7 S3 it tested.
  • Some background noise came through during that test with ANC on. Codec support alone doesn’t prove you’ll hear a benefit with your phone or recording.

Apple

The AirPods Max range is a useful point of comparison if you’re considering over-ear headphones and controls within the Apple ecosystem.

  • Apple lists a Transparency mode and up to 20 hours of listening with ANC enabled for AirPods Max 2.
  • Apple warns that features may be limited on devices from other manufacturers. Don’t confuse Max 2 with the AirPods Max from an earlier test that didn’t specify a generation.

Sony

The WH-1000XM5 is a pair of closed-back over-ear headphones with ANC and an ambient sound mode, making it worth comparing for train journeys.

  • Sony states that you can get up to 30 hours of music playback with noise cancelling on and 40 hours with it off.
  • These are manufacturer figures, not independent measurements of battery life or an assessment of piano playback.

Sennheiser

The MOMENTUM 4 Wireless is an over-ear option worth comparing if stated battery life and adjustable sound matter to you.

  • The manufacturer lists ANC, a transparency mode, app-based sound settings and up to 60 hours per full charge.
  • The maximum battery life and stated sound quality are manufacturer claims; assess the fit and piano sound separately.

Joybuy products

This selection includes wireless over-ear headphones with noise cancelling and compact in-ear headphones. Check whether each model’s combination of noise reduction, fit and controls suits your train journey.

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless, black wireless over-ear headphones

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless, black

Well suited to anyone who wants to switch between ANC and transparency mode on longer journeys. The product information mentions a padded headband and deep ear cushions.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Bluetooth headphones, black

Bose QuietComfort Ultra, black

These closed-back over-ear headphones with active noise cancelling are a good choice if you want to reduce train noise. The piano sound of this version shouldn’t be taken as an assessment of a different generation.

View at Joybuy
Sony WH-1000XM5 wireless noise-cancelling headphones, silver

Sony WH-1000XM5, silver

An over-ear option for anyone considering noise cancelling and long journeys. Sony states that you can get up to 30 hours of music playback with noise cancelling enabled; this is a manufacturer figure.

View at Joybuy
Soundcore by Anker Space One Pro wireless headphones with adaptive noise cancelling

Soundcore by Anker Space One Pro

A good choice if you’re looking for wireless over-ear headphones with adaptive active noise cancelling. The product name specifies a foldable design; also check for yourself whether the fit feels comfortable.

View at Joybuy
Apple AirPods 4 with active noise cancelling

Apple AirPods 4 with active noise cancelling

Compact in-ear headphones for anyone looking to save space in their bag. The product information mentions features for managing surrounding sounds and adjusting music during conversations; check that the controls suit the way you’ll use them.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I listen to a recital using headphones in the quiet carriage?

Yes, as long as other passengers can’t hear your music. NS’s rules ask passengers to remain quiet in the quiet zone and apply to NS trains; they don’t automatically apply to every rail operator.

Should ANC stay on throughout a train journey?

No. ANC can help with constant low-level vehicle noise, but switch to transparency mode or pause your music when you want to hear an announcement.

How can I listen on long train journeys without continually turning up the volume?

Choose well-fitting headphones and use noise cancelling to reduce the need to turn up the volume in a noisy environment. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones as a helpful option and advises keeping the volume down.

Can I try headphones after buying them online and return them?

Online purchases in the Netherlands generally come with a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, with some exceptions. Check the applicable conditions for unpacking and trying the headphones before you buy; any more generous return policy offered by the retailer is separate from this statutory right.

Do my rights end when the manufacturer’s warranty expires?

No. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, your statutory rights exist alongside a manufacturer’s or seller’s warranty and depend on what you could reasonably expect from the product under normal use. Contact the seller if the product is faulty.