Listener on a noisy train
You want to follow spoken passages without constantly turning up the volume. Start by finding a fit that creates a good seal.
For interviews with authors on the train, a secure fit is the first thing to consider. It means you’re less likely to turn the volume up automatically just to follow the conversation. Wired in-ears are a good fit if you don’t want to manage a battery and have a compatible connection. Wireless ANC in-ears suit you if you prefer listening without a cable and value a transparency mode. A secure fit or transparency mode doesn’t guarantee that you’ll hear every announcement.
You want to follow spoken passages without constantly turning up the volume. Start by finding a fit that creates a good seal.
You wear your in-ears for extended periods and want to check that the shape and ear tips stay comfortable.
You switch between listening and changing trains, so look for a transparency mode or the option to take one earbud out temporarily.
First, choose between a wired connection with no earbud battery to manage and wireless listening with ANC. Then consider fit, speech clarity and how easily you can hear announcements.
Choose these if: you don’t want to manage earbud batteries, can find tips that fit and have a compatible connection or adapter.
The trade-off: the cable and connection need consideration; a good seal may make announcements harder to hear.
Choose these if: you want to listen without a cable and ANC matters to you. A transparency mode may suit you if you regularly listen out for announcements.
The trade-off: you’ll need to plan for playback time per charge and recharging. ANC and transparency mode are no substitute for staying alert when changing trains.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who should pay particular attention? |
|---|---|---|
| Speech clarity | Check whether several ear tip sizes are included and whether both ears get a good seal. Try listening to a familiar spoken recording. | I want to follow an interview without turning up the volume. This is a priority for around 33% of consumers who value clear speech. |
| Fit on long journeys | Check which sizes and materials are included and whether the shape suits your ears. | I wear earbuds for long stretches and want them to stay comfortable. Around 27% of consumers put this comfort ahead of other considerations. |
| Hearing announcements | Check whether a transparency mode is available and easy to use. When wearing the earbuds, pay attention to what you can still hear in your situation. | I want to be able to notice announcements when changing trains. This is a priority for around 20% of consumers. |
| Connection and playback time | For wired earbuds, check the connection or adapter. For wireless models, compare the earbuds’ own playback time with ANC switched on. | I don’t want connection problems or a flat battery during my journey. Around 20% of consumers start by considering the connection or playback time. |
A stated isolation figure doesn’t automatically tell you how well a model will fit your ears, work with your choice of tips or seal out noise on your train journey.
Start with the fit and try a familiar spoken recording. Don’t automatically turn up the volume if the seal isn’t quite right.
You can’t use the extra playback time in the case while you’re wearing the earbuds.
Compare playback time per charge with ANC set to the mode you plan to use.
You may need to recharge during a longer journey.
A 3.5mm plug will only work with a compatible socket or adapter.
Before buying, check the connection on your phone or player and, if needed, make sure the adapter is compatible.
ACM ConsuWijzer lists an exception to the usual cooling-off period for unsealed hygiene products.
Check the terms and conditions that apply to your purchase before breaking the seal.
The wired SE215 is a passively isolating in-ear with ear tips and a detachable 3.5mm cable.
The IE 200 is a wired model with a detachable MMCX cable and silicone and foam ear tips in various sizes.
The wired ER2SE and ER2XR are options to compare if you’re looking for passive isolation. According to Etymotic, the ER2XR has extra bass compared with a flat-tuned mid and treble range.
The WF-1000XM5 represents the wireless ANC option, with a transparency mode and multipoint connectivity.
This selection mainly includes wireless in-ears with ANC, alongside a wired USB-C option. Compare the fit, how you hear your surroundings and the connection with your own listening needs.
No image available
A wireless option for listening to interviews with ANC.
Up to 6 hours of playback per charge with ANC on, according to the product description.
No image available
A wired USB-C option if you don’t want to recharge batteries in your earbuds.
The product description lists three sizes of ear tips and two sizes of stability bands. Check that USB-C is compatible with your playback device.
No image available
A wireless option if you want ANC and value replaceable parts.
The product description mentions replaceable batteries and up to 8 hours of playback per charge with ANC off.
No image available
A wireless option with ANC and an Aware mode that lets in ambient sound.
The description lists ear tips in three sizes, stability bands and up to 8.5 hours of battery life per charge.
No image available
A wireless option if you want to switch between ANC and Aware Mode.
The product information lists Bluetooth 5.3 and up to 6 hours of listening per charge. Don’t use noise cancelling when hearing your surroundings is crucial.
No, ANC isn’t equally effective against every type of sound. The Consumentenbond describes ANC as particularly suitable for deep, continuous vehicle noise; a well-fitting ear tip is still important. Check speech clarity with spoken audio, rather than comparing ANC labels alone.
Choose ear tips that feel comfortable and create a good seal. For the SE215, Shure says the tip should fully cover the nozzle and advises checking the tip and nozzle if the sound changes. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for other models.
No, the case charges the earbuds when you’re not wearing them. So compare the earbuds’ own playback time at the setting you plan to use. Sony states that the WF-1000XM5 offers up to 8 hours with noise cancelling on, under its own test conditions.
Not necessarily. ACM ConsuWijzer states that online purchases generally come with a statutory 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, but lists an exception for unsealed hygiene products. Check the terms and conditions that apply to your purchase before opening the packaging.