Listeners who want to follow speech
You want to follow spoken analysis over the noise of the train. Consider the fit and the sound you enjoy; a stated noise-isolation rating isn’t a test of how football commentary sounds on a train.
Choose a wired in-ear monitor if you don’t want to charge your earbuds and prefer a cable with a compatible connection; a good fit is still important. If you’d rather listen wirelessly and adjust how much of your surroundings you can hear, compare wireless in-ear earbuds too. Noise-isolation claims don’t tell you whether you’ll be able to follow football analysis on the train.
You want to follow spoken analysis over the noise of the train. Consider the fit and the sound you enjoy; a stated noise-isolation rating isn’t a test of how football commentary sounds on a train.
You’re looking for earbuds that feel comfortable and don’t want to keep turning up the volume to drown out background noise. The sizes and materials supplied vary by model. The World Health Organization stresses that sound level, listening time and how often you listen all matter for safe listening.
You prioritise wireless listening and adjustable ambient sound, and are happy to pair your earbuds via Bluetooth and charge them. This is an alternative to a wired in-ear monitor, not the same type of product.
A good fit if: you don’t want to charge your earbuds and your player has a compatible connection.
Bear in mind: you’ll have a cable, and the seal may reduce background noise.
A good fit if: wireless listening and adjustable ambient sound matter more to you.
Bear in mind: you’ll need to pair and charge them via Bluetooth; these features don’t prove that speech will be easier to understand.
| What to consider | What to check before buying | Who this matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Following speech over train noise | Check the ear-tip sizes and fit; assess speech at a comfortable, controlled volume. | If I want to follow football analysis without constantly turning up the volume, I’ll first consider the seal and speech clarity; around 36% of consumers prioritise following speech over train noise. |
| Fit and listening time | Check the sizes and materials of the supplied ear tips, and choose a fit that remains comfortable. | On a longer journey, I want earbuds that feel comfortable and don’t make me turn the volume up unnecessarily; around 29% of consumers prioritise fit and listening throughout the journey. |
| Connection and cable | Check that the plug fits your player and that any replacement cable has the connector for your exact model. | If I want to listen using a cable or replace it, I’ll check my player’s connection and the model; around 21% of consumers prioritise connections and cable maintenance. |
| Wireless listening | Check that the earbuds offer the ambient sound setting you want, and bear in mind that they’ll need to be paired and charged. | If I want to listen without a cable and adjust ambient sound myself, I’ll look for those features in the model; around 14% of consumers prioritise wireless use. |
Manufacturer figures describe their own model; they don’t test how it fits you or how a particular football broadcast sounds.
Start by checking the ear-tip sizes and fit. Compare speech at a comfortable, controlled volume.
The wired models covered here are described with different connections. A monitor will only work with your player if the connection is compatible.
Check your player’s audio output and the full connection before choosing.
According to Audio-Technica, the Audio-Technica ATH-E40 uses A2DC; Shure specifies MMCX for the SE215.
Search for a replacement cable using the full model name and the correct connector, not just the type of earbuds.
Wired monitors need a compatible physical connection. The Sony alternative described here uses Bluetooth and has ambient sound settings.
Decide whether you’d rather listen and charge without a cable, or use a wired setup.
The SE215 is a wired option with passive isolation, several supplied ear tips and a detachable cable.
According to Etymotic, the ER2SE is designed for a flat frequency response, while the manufacturer highlights the bass of the ER2XR.
The ATH-E40 is a wired monitor for anyone looking to compare several sizes of silicone ear tips and a detachable cable.
The IE 200 is a wired option supplied with silicone and foam ear tips, with two ear-tip positions.
The WF-1000XM5 represents the wireless option here, with noise-cancelling and ambient sound settings.
These Joybuy products include wireless in-ear earbuds for listening on the go and a wired USB-C option.
No image available
For anyone who wants to listen wirelessly on the go; bear in mind that you’ll need to pair and charge them via Bluetooth.
No image available
A wired option for anyone who doesn’t want to use Bluetooth earbuds on the go; check that the USB-C connection is compatible with your player.
No image available
For anyone who wants to listen wirelessly and adjust ambient sound; bear in mind that you’ll need to pair and charge them.
No image available
For anyone who listens wirelessly and wants to choose between noise cancellation and ambient sound mode; bear in mind that you’ll need to pair and charge them via Bluetooth.
No image available
For anyone who wants to switch between wireless listening and transparency mode; check that the supplied ear-tip sizes fit your ears, and bear in mind that you’ll need to charge them.
No. The 35–42 dB for the Etymotic ER2SE and up to 37 dB for the Shure SE215 are manufacturer figures, not measurements of how the earbuds fit you or how clearly you can hear a football broadcast. Check the ear tips too, and listen at a comfortable volume.
Check that your player can connect to the supplied 3.5mm plug. Choose an ear-tip size that feels comfortable; the Shure, Audio-Technica and Sennheiser models described here come with several ear-tip sizes or materials.
Bear in mind both the volume and how long you listen for. The World Health Organization gives listening at an average of 80 dB for up to 40 hours a week as an example within its safe-listening guidance; this isn’t a measurement of your device’s volume. A good seal isn’t a reason to listen at an unlimited volume.
The cables on the Shure SE215, Audio-Technica ATH-E40 and Sennheiser IE 200 models covered here are detachable; check which connector fits your exact model before choosing a replacement. In the Netherlands, statutory warranty applies through the seller if a product breaks sooner than you could reasonably expect during normal use. ACM ConsuWijzer and the Dutch Government explain that there isn’t one fixed warranty period for all products.
NS’s house rules ask passengers not to disturb others with loud conversations or music, and require silence in the quiet zone. Keep the sound to yourself and pay attention to announcements and travel information. If you’re travelling with another operator, check its own travel rules.