Listener behind thick walls
You want to play music from a shared library in a room where the router signal is too weak. That makes the connection to your extra Wi-Fi access point an important choice.
First, decide how the extra Wi-Fi access point will connect to your router. Ethernet can avoid a weak wireless connection through the wall, while powerline Wi-Fi is an alternative you can test using the sockets you plan to use. A wireless repeater is only suitable if it can still receive a usable signal from the router. Also check that your music source and playback devices can communicate over the local network.
You want to play music from a shared library in a room where the router signal is too weak. That makes the connection to your extra Wi-Fi access point an important choice.
You can’t run Ethernet through the wall and want to find out whether a suitable spot for a repeater or your existing electrical wiring could work instead.
You share music from a computer or NAS and want your playback devices to retain access to that source over the local network.
First, decide how the connection from your router to the extra Wi-Fi access point will get through the wall: via an intermediate spot with usable Wi-Fi, an Ethernet cable or powerline that you’ve tested. Then check that the music source and player can communicate over the local network.
| What to consider | What to look for | Who it matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Getting a connection through the wall | Check whether you can run Ethernet to the access point, or test powerline using the sockets you plan to use. | If I mainly need a usable connection in the listening room, I look at how the signal gets through the wall; around 36% of consumers have this priority. |
| Positioning without a cable | Find an intermediate spot where the repeater can still receive a usable signal from the router. | If I can’t run a network cable, I want to know whether there’s a suitable spot before the weak-signal area; around 29% of consumers prioritise this need. |
| Access to the music library | Check that the source and player are on the local network and can access the shared music folder. | If I share music from a computer or NAS, the player needs to be able to open the library; around 21% of consumers put this access first. |
| What you need for the whole setup | Count the access points and adapters you need, and check how many connection ports the setup requires. | If I want to keep the whole setup affordable, I consider how many devices and connections I’ll need; around 14% of consumers make this their top priority. |
A wireless repeater relies on the signal available where it’s placed to connect to the router. Putting it in the middle of a dead zone won’t fix that weak connection.
First, test an intermediate spot where the router signal is still usable. If there isn’t one, consider Ethernet or test powerline using the sockets you plan to use.
You may still need an extra Wi-Fi access point, a cable or a different way to connect everything.
Product specifications can’t predict how the connection will perform with your walls, placement and electrical wiring.
Test the connection in your listening spot using the music source and player you actually use.
devolo says that Magic and dLAN adapters can’t be combined. TP-Link also notes that G.hn adapters aren’t compatible with HomePlug AV/AV2 adapters.
Make a note of the models and powerline standards used by your existing adapters before adding a kit.
If your adapters can’t be combined, you may need a different kit.
This comparison includes standalone repeaters and hybrid Wi-Fi/powerline mesh systems.
The Magic 2 WiFi 6 next Starter Kit is designed to provide Wi-Fi through your electrical wiring.
The FRITZ!Repeater 1200 AX is an option if you’re looking for a repeater with a LAN connection.
The RP-AX58 is a wireless repeater with access point mode.
This selection includes powerline Wi-Fi, a wired access point and wireless repeaters. Choose the connection method that suits the cabling and signal strength where your music player will be.
No image available
According to TP-Link, the Deco PX10 uses powerline between the Deco units. Test the connection using the sockets you plan to use for your setup.
The product name specifies dual-band (2.4 GHz / 5 GHz) and Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax).
No image available
The product information describes a powerline Wi-Fi kit that uses your existing electrical wiring. Test the connection using the sockets you plan to use before relying on this option.
No image available
A wired access point is a good fit if you can run Ethernet to the spot where you need Wi-Fi. The product name specifies Wi-Fi 6, 2976 Mbit/s and Power over Ethernet (PoE).
No image available
This repeater is only suitable if there’s a spot before the weak-signal area where the router signal is still usable. The product information lists an Ethernet port; the model name specifies 300 Mbps.
No image available
A wireless repeater is only an option if it can still receive a usable signal from the router where you plan to put it. The product information specifies a 2.4 GHz signal.
Only if the repeater can still get a usable connection to the router from there. TP-Link recommends placing a wireless repeater within range of the router. If that isn’t possible, you could consider Ethernet or a powerline solution that you’ve tested on site.
Check that the music source is shared on the local network and that the player has access to it. For Sonos, the manufacturer specifies local network access; for a NAS used with the current Sonos app, Sonos specifies SMBv2 or SMBv3. These are requirements for Sonos, not for every music player.
Test the connection where you listen and check the router’s position and the Wi-Fi channel in use. The Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure points out that 5 GHz has less range than 2.4 GHz; a busy channel or poorly positioned router can also interfere with connections.
Check how many units or adapters are included in the box, whether you need Ethernet cabling, and the warranty and returns terms for the specific offer. A starter kit with two adapters doesn’t automatically mean you’ll have Wi-Fi in several distant listening spots.
According to the Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure, Wi-Fi in the Netherlands is licence-exempt, with no notification or registration required. Radio equipment placed on the market must still meet European product requirements; check for the CE marking when you buy and use the correct country settings.