If you can run an Ethernet cable to your converted loft, a Wi-Fi access point is a sensible choice. If not, a single repeater may do the job, provided it can still receive a usable signal from your router. If several rooms have weak coverage, compare mesh systems. And if the wireless connection between floors is unreliable and cabling is difficult, you could try powerline. Separately, check that your music player can access the shared computer or NAS on your local network.
Who are these Wi-Fi solutions for?
Listeners with one Wi-Fi dead spot
If your network works elsewhere in the house but doesn’t reach the loft properly, one extra Wi-Fi point may be enough. The Consumers’ Association stresses that where you place your Wi-Fi points matters. TP-Link also describes a signal indicator that helps you check whether a repeater still has a good connection to the router.
Users with a shared music library
If you want to play music from a computer or NAS in the loft, check both the network connection and access to the shared files. Sonos explains how this works with its own system, but requirements may vary between music players.
Households with several rooms with weak coverage
If coverage is poor not just in the loft but in other rooms too, a solution with several Wi-Fi points could be a good fit. The Consumers’ Association assesses Wi-Fi boosters on factors including speed, ease of use, features, energy consumption and security.
What should you consider when choosing?
One wireless repeater
A good fit if: you mainly want to get Wi-Fi to the loft, can’t run a cable and have a spot between the router and loft with a usable Wi-Fi signal.
Bear in mind: the repeater stays connected to the router wirelessly, so choosing a spot with a weak signal won’t solve the problem.
Wired access point
A good fit if: you can run Ethernet to the loft and want to provide Wi-Fi there.
Bear in mind: you’ll need a cable route and a device with access point mode.
Mesh system with several Wi-Fi points
A good fit if: other rooms need coverage too, and you can position the points so they connect well to one another.
Bear in mind: you’ll need space and power for several devices; check whether you can connect the points by cable.
Powerline with Wi-Fi
A good fit if: running a cable to the loft isn’t practical and the wireless connection between floors is unreliable.
Bear in mind: the connection runs through your home’s electrical wiring, and manufacturers’ stated speeds aren’t measurements taken in your home. The devolo Magic set included in the test doesn’t work with the older dLAN range.
| What to consider |
What to check before buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Signal to the loft |
Check that a repeater still has a usable connection to the router when placed somewhere in between. If you can connect Ethernet, also check whether the device supports access point mode. |
If I mainly want to reach one room in the loft and can’t run a cable, I’ll check the connection back to the router. Around 36% of consumers say fixing a single Wi-Fi dead spot is their main reason for buying. |
| Access to music files |
Check where the computer or NAS is, whether it will remain accessible and what network and sharing requirements your music player has. |
If I want to play a local music library, my player needs to be able to access the shared computer or NAS. Around 29% of consumers prioritise access to music files. |
| Coverage in several rooms |
Check how many Wi-Fi points are included and whether you can connect them to one another using Ethernet. |
If other rooms have weak Wi-Fi too, I’ll compare several points with adding just one extra Wi-Fi point. Around 21% of consumers prioritise coverage in more than one room. |
| Installation and energy consumption |
Check what installation involves, how many devices need to stay on and how much energy they use. |
When weighing up ease of installation and ongoing costs, I want to know how many points I’ll need to set up and use. Around 14% of consumers say this is their main buying priority. |
Common mistakes when choosing
-
Placing the repeater where the router’s signal has already dropped out
A repeater needs to be able to connect to the router itself. So a spot in the loft with little or no reception won’t automatically give you a usable connection.
First, check possible spots in between. If the wireless connection isn’t strong enough there, see whether a wired access point is an option.
If the wireless connection back to the router doesn’t work, you may need to move the repeater or run a cable after all.
-
Confusing a Wi-Fi specification with access to your music library
Even with enough Wi-Fi coverage, playback can fail if the computer or NAS can’t be reached, or if the shared folder isn’t accessible.
Test access to your library separately from Wi-Fi coverage, and follow the requirements for your own music player.
-
Choosing mesh or powerline without checking the connection between devices
With mesh, coverage depends partly on where you place the points and how they connect to one another. Powerline uses your electrical wiring, but a stated speed doesn’t tell you what performance you’ll get at home.
First, work out which rooms need coverage and whether you can run cables. If you’re considering powerline, also check that any existing adapters work with the range you’re choosing.
A set with several Wi-Fi points may be unnecessary if one well-placed, wired point is enough. Extra devices also use electricity.
Brands and solutions to consider
TP-Link
The RE705X is a standalone Wi-Fi 6 repeater with gigabit Ethernet and access point mode. The Deco X10 (2-pack) is a multi-point mesh option.
- TP-Link says OneMesh works on the RE705X when paired with a OneMesh router.
- Don’t assume that every router offers the same mesh features.
- The Consumers’ Association notes that the test score for the Deco X10 (2-pack) is based on the 3-pack version.
FRITZ!
The FRITZ!Repeater 1200 AX is an option for adding one Wi-Fi point, either wirelessly or using a LAN connection.
- FRITZ! describes using it with a FRITZ!Box via LAN, as well as with other routers.
- The FRITZ! Mesh features described require a compatible FRITZ!Box. A manufacturer’s claim about coverage isn’t a measurement taken in your home.
ASUS
The RP-AX58 is a repeater with access point mode. AiMesh is worth considering if you have a compatible ASUS router.
- ASUS says the device can also work with other routers.
- The manufacturer distinguishes between using it with other routers and connecting it to an AiMesh-compatible router.
devolo
The Magic 2 WiFi next Starter Kit combines Wi-Fi from an adapter with a connection through your home’s electrical wiring. It’s designed for situations where running cables is difficult.
- devolo specifies two extra gigabit LAN ports on the Wi-Fi adapter, and says the system can be expanded with Magic adapters.
- The Magic range isn’t compatible with the dLAN range. The stated powerline speed is a manufacturer’s figure, not a measurement taken in your home.
Products at Joybuy
These product options cover powerline via your home’s electrical wiring, mesh with several Wi-Fi points, a wireless repeater or a wired access point.
No image available
TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT Powerline Adapter Starter Kit
A good fit for a loft where you want to try powerline using your existing electrical wiring.
The connection runs through your home’s electrical wiring.
View at Joybuy
No image available
TP-Link Deco X50 (3-pack), dual-band Wi-Fi 6 (2.4 GHz/5 GHz), white
A good fit if you want to use several Wi-Fi points to provide coverage throughout your home.
3-pack; the description lists Ethernet backhaul as an option for connecting Deco units by cable.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Wi-Fi Repeater Pro, black
A good fit for one spot with weak Wi-Fi, provided the repeater can still make a usable connection to your existing network.
It connects to the router wirelessly, so check reception where you plan to place the repeater.
View at Joybuy
No image available
TP-Link TL-WA801N access point and Wi-Fi extender
A good fit for a loft where you can connect a network cable and use the device as an access point.
The title lists speeds of up to 300 Mbps, 2 antennas, WPS and Passive PoE. Using it as a wired access point requires a network connection at the installation location.
View at Joybuy
No image available
TP-Link Deco X50 (2-pack), dual-band Wi-Fi 6 (2.4 GHz/5 GHz), white
A good fit if you want to add two Wi-Fi points; check that their placement suits the rooms that need coverage.
2-pack; the description lists Ethernet backhaul as an option for connecting Deco units by cable.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Does your music library need to be online to play it in the loft?
Not necessarily. For example, Sonos explains how to play music from a shared computer or NAS on your local network. Check which music sources, folder permissions and network connection your player needs. Sonos instructions don’t automatically apply to other players.
When should you use an extender in access point mode?
Use this mode when an Ethernet connection runs from your existing network to the Wi-Fi point, and the model you’ve chosen supports access point mode. Check the installation instructions for the specific device.
Will music from a computer or NAS still be available when the computer is switched off?
That depends on where the files are stored and how your music player connects to them. For a local Sonos library, the music source needs to be accessible. Sonos says a NAS can remain online without a computer switched on. For the Sonos set-up described, the manufacturer specifies SMBv2 or SMBv3 for a NAS, with different requirements for older S1 systems.
What running costs and warranty rules should you know about?
Bear in mind the energy used by Wi-Fi points that stay switched on. According to the Government of the Netherlands, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands: if a product isn’t fit for purpose, contact the seller. A weak signal caused by the layout of your home doesn’t automatically mean the product is faulty.
Can you use a Wi-Fi booster at home in the Netherlands, and what should you check on the device?
The Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure says you can use Wi-Fi at home without a licence, provided you follow the rules for the designated frequencies and their use. The equipment must carry the correct CE marking. A mention in a product advert isn’t the same as checking the device you receive.