Housemate with a room that gets a poor signal
Wants to play music in a room where the existing Wi-Fi signal is too weak. The position of a repeater matters: it needs to be able to connect to the router from there.
For a single room with a weak signal, a repeater is only suitable if it can still get a good connection to the router where you install it. If you can run an ethernet cable to the room, an access point could be an alternative. For several rooms, mesh is an option if the router and mesh points support the same mesh feature. Extending your Wi-Fi coverage won’t automatically make a music library accessible: your storage and players need to be able to communicate over the local network. Sonos says that guest networks aren’t compatible with its system.
Wants to play music in a room where the existing Wi-Fi signal is too weak. The position of a repeater matters: it needs to be able to connect to the router from there.
Wants storage, players and control devices to be able to reach one another over the local network. It’s also worth checking access permissions for the music folder, so it isn’t accidentally open to everyone.
Needs coverage in more than one room while several devices use the network. The router, any ethernet cables and compatible mesh features all help determine which type of extension is suitable.
Choose this when: you mainly want to reach one room, can’t use an ethernet cable and have a suitable spot that gets a signal from the router.
Trade-off: the connection between the repeater and router remains wireless and shares that connection with other network traffic.
Choose this when: there’s an ethernet cable running to the room with a weak signal and your chosen extender has an access point mode.
Trade-off: you’ll need a cable and should check that you can connect it in the room you want to use.
Choose this when: several rooms need coverage and your router works with the mesh devices you’ve chosen.
Trade-off: mesh features vary between systems. Even with wireless mesh, the connection between the points is important.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage in one room | Compare the position of a repeater with the option of running a cable to an access point. If you’re using an access point, check that the model supports this mode. | If I want to play music in one room with a weak signal, coverage there comes first; around 40% of consumers prioritise coverage in one room. |
| Access to the music library | Check where the library is stored, which players and apps you use, and whether they’ll still be accessible on the right local network after installation. | If keeping your own music library available is your main concern, check the connection between storage and players; around 30% of consumers prioritise this accessibility. |
| Several rooms and devices | Check how many rooms need better coverage and whether your router is compatible with the mesh feature in the system you’ve chosen. The advertised wireless speed doesn’t tell you what speeds you’ll get in your home. | If several busy rooms need coverage, the extension and router compatibility are key; around 20% of consumers prioritise this. |
| Management and access | Agree who will manage settings and updates, and check access permissions for the music files. Also factor in power consumption and any extra equipment you may need. | If you want to manage shared access and settings carefully, check the settings and file permissions; around 10% of consumers make this their priority. |
A repeater can only extend a connection it can receive itself. A spot without a strong enough router signal won’t be suitable for installation.
First, find where the existing signal is still usable. If you have a cable available, compare this with using an access point connected by ethernet.
You may need to reposition the device, run a cable or add another Wi-Fi point.
OneMesh, FRITZ! Mesh and AiMesh each have their own compatibility requirements. Working with another router doesn’t automatically mean that mesh features will be available.
Before buying, check your exact router model and the mesh feature supported by the device you’ve chosen.
A stronger or wider Wi-Fi signal doesn’t automatically provide access to files. Sonos says guest networks aren’t compatible with its system, and your music library must also be accessible separately.
Check the network connection and file permissions with the players you actually use.
The features listed apply to specific models and compatible setups. A brand’s inclusion here doesn’t indicate that its products are available.
According to TP-Link, the RE705X offers an access point mode and gigabit ethernet, allowing you to compare wireless extension with a connection via ethernet cable.
The FRITZ!Repeater 1200 AX is an option to compare if you already have a FRITZ!Box, and it has a gigabit LAN port.
The RP-AX58 is worth considering for an AiMesh setup with a compatible ASUS router or for use in access point mode.
According to devolo, the WiFi 6 Repeater 3000 can be used as both a repeater and an access point, and has a gigabit LAN port.
The EAX15 is a dual-band Wi-Fi 6 extender with gigabit ethernet for extending an existing network.
These Joybuy products are mesh systems for extending coverage to several rooms. Check that your router works with the mesh features you’ve chosen. Also check that the specific version has the CE marking.
No image available
For anyone looking to extend Wi-Fi to several rooms with a mesh system.
Tri-band Wi-Fi 7; two units; multiple ethernet ports; wireless or wired backhaul.
No image available
For extending coverage to several rooms with a mesh system; worth considering if you use a compatible ASUS AiMesh router.
Tri-band Wi-Fi 7; AiMesh support with compatible ASUS routers; ethernet ports.
No image available
For extending Wi-Fi to several rooms with a mesh system.
Wi-Fi 6; two-piece set; optional ethernet backhaul; guest network.
No image available
For anyone looking to extend Wi-Fi to several rooms using a mesh system with three units.
Wi-Fi 6; three units; ethernet ports; mesh roaming between units.
No image available
For extending coverage to several rooms with a mesh system consisting of three units.
Tri-band Wi-Fi 6E; three gigabit ports per unit; guest access and QoS.
No. An extender expands a network connection, but your music library and playback software need to be set up separately. Sonos explains how to share a library from a computer or NAS on the local network.
Not with Sonos: according to Sonos, guest networks aren’t compatible, and devices using the Sonos app need to be on the same Wi-Fi network as Sonos. You should also restrict access to music files through the storage device’s settings.
With Sonos, a NAS can keep your library available without needing to leave a computer switched on. Sonos requires SMBv2 or SMBv3 for sharing via a NAS; check this setting if you use this system.
As well as the purchase price, include power consumption and the cost of any cables or extra Wi-Fi points in your comparison. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that if a product breaks sooner than you could reasonably expect during normal use, the retailer must put it right free of charge; this is separate from a manufacturer’s warranty.