Who is this choice relevant to?

Manager of a growing video collection

Wants to work out how much space is needed for a complete backup and avoid treating a single drive as a long-term archiving plan. The National Archives stresses that digital archiving involves more than simply making a backup.

Archive backup coordinator

Wants to organise separate copies and check that files can be restored. If recordings show identifiable people, those files also need to be managed carefully; the Dutch Data Protection Authority treats identifiable images as personal data.

Volunteer who moves recordings

Transfers video files between recording, working and storage locations, so needs to weigh up capacity, connectivity and portability.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, check how much space your files take up and allow for growth. The NCSC recommends keeping multiple versions of important files; build time for recovery tests into your processes, too.

Key consideration What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Capacity and growth Add up the files that need to be included in the copy and allow for expected growth. Compare this with the capacity of the exact model. I want to be able to copy the entire collection without overlooking room for growth. Around 36% of consumers prioritise enough capacity for their full collection.
Recoverability Decide how the drive fits into a plan with separate copies and specify who will carry out recovery tests. I don't just want to see that files have been copied; I also want to check that they can be restored and opened. Around 29% of consumers prioritise recoverability.
Portability and connectivity Check that the ports and cables are compatible with the computers you use. Also check that the file system and workflow suit Windows or macOS. I move files between locations and want to connect the drive to the computers involved. Around 21% of consumers prioritise portability and file transfers.
Access to recordings Establish whether people are identifiable in the footage and decide which security measures are appropriate for the risks involved. I manage recordings in which people may be identifiable and want to put suitable access controls and security in place. Around 14% of consumers prioritise protecting these recordings.

If the footage shows identifiable people, the Dutch Data Protection Authority considers it personal data. The security measures needed depend on the risks; a drive on its own does not make a process GDPR-compliant.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking one external drive for a complete archiving plan

    A single drive does not automatically provide multiple separate copies or a verifiable archiving process. The NCSC recommends keeping at least three versions of important files: the originals and two backups. The National Archives points out that digital archiving involves more than simply making a backup.

    First decide what role the drive will play in your copying plan, then document how the collection will be organised and managed.

    Keeping a second, separately stored copy and setting aside time for recovery tests require extra management.

  • Choosing a portable 4TB drive without measuring your collection

    The portable HDD and SSD models reviewed have 4 TB of storage, while the desktop options reviewed have 8 TB. This alone doesn't tell you how much space your collection needs.

    Measure what needs to be copied and allow for expected growth before weighing up capacity against portability or transfer needs.

  • Assuming a copy has worked because the files are visible

    Seeing files on a drive doesn't prove that they can be restored and opened later. The NCSC recommends carrying out a recovery test and checking that it succeeds.

    Build regular recovery tests into your process and assign someone to follow up on the results.

    Recovery tests take time; allow time in your process to follow up on any problems with copies, too.

Brands to compare across the options

Western Digital

Elements Desktop is a desktop HDD range worth comparing if the drive will mainly stay in one place.

  • Western Digital specifies 8 TB for model WDBWLG0080HBK-EESN.
  • That capacity doesn't tell you whether one drive is enough for a recoverable backup plan.

Seagate

Expansion Desktop is a desktop HDD range to consider alongside other fixed storage options.

  • The Expansion Desktop model reviewed is listed with 8 TB of storage.
  • Check the connectivity and power requirements of the exact model for the intended setup.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a portable HDD range for copies that need to travel between locations.

  • Toshiba lists 4 TB and USB power for model HDTB440EK3CA.
  • Toshiba lists NTFS as the file system and says reformatting is required for macOS.

Samsung

T7 Shield is a portable SSD range worth comparing if portability and file transfers are important.

  • For the 4TB model MU-PE4T0S/EU, Samsung lists sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write.
  • These are stated maximums, not measured speeds for your archive. Check that 4 TB is enough, too.

Joybuy products

This selection includes portable HDDs, an external SSD and desktop storage for backing up and moving video files.

My Passport USB-C external hard drive, 5 TB, black

My Passport USB-C 5TB, black

A portable HDD for taking a video copy between locations.

5 TB of storage and USB-C. The product description lists exFAT, hardware encryption, backup software and USB power, with support for Windows, Mac, Android and iOS, among others.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport USB-C external hard drive, 4 TB, black

Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4TB, black

A portable HDD for a video copy that travels between locations, if 4 TB is enough.

4 TB of storage and USB-C. The product description lists exFAT, password protection, AES 256-bit hardware encryption and support for Windows and macOS.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Basics external hard drive, 4 TB

Toshiba Canvio Basics 4TB

A portable HDD for moving files between locations, if the collection fits within 4 TB.

4 TB of storage, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and USB power. The product description lists a USB-A to Micro-USB-B cable. Reformatting is required for use with macOS.

Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 external SSD, 2 TB, blue

Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB, blue

A portable SSD for moving large files, if 2 TB is enough.

USB 3.2 Gen 2 and stated sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write. The product description lists AES 256-bit encryption, support for Windows, macOS and Android, among others, and USB-C to C and USB-C to A cables. The stated speeds are not a guarantee for your transfer task.

Joybuy
WD Elements Desktop external storage, 8 TB, black

WD Elements Desktop Storage 8 TB, black

Desktop storage for a larger copy in a fixed location, if 8 TB suits the collection and expected growth.

8 TB of storage. The product description lists USB 3.0, USB 2.0 compatibility and plug-and-play use with Windows 10 or later.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do you work out how much storage your video archive needs?

Add up the files that actually need to be included in the copy and allow for expected growth. Compare the total with the capacity of the exact model: the desktop models reviewed have 8 TB, while the portable models reviewed have 4 TB. Without knowing the size of your collection, it's impossible to tell whether either capacity will be enough.

How do you check that a backup works?

Carry out a recovery test and open files from the backup. The NCSC recommends testing recovery; a message saying the copy was successful doesn't show whether the files will be usable later.

What costs and terms should you check besides the drive itself?

Allow for separate copies, possible storage in another location and time for recovery tests. Also check the terms and conditions for the specific purchase. ACM ConsuWijzer distinguishes between predominantly private and predominantly business use, so don't assume that consumer protection applies when making a purchase on behalf of the archive.

Which rules are relevant if people are identifiable in the videos?

The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers images of identifiable people to be personal data; when an organisation processes them, the GDPR applies. The organisation must decide on appropriate security based on the risks. The Dutch Data Protection Authority lists access controls, backups and encryption as possible measures, not as fixed product specifications for every drive.

Can the archive copy or make public every film it receives?

Don't assume there is a general archiving exception. The Government of the Netherlands states that permission from the creator is needed to use films protected by copyright, and that a private copy for personal use must not be distributed or made public. Check the rights for each item and its intended use separately.