Who are these setups suitable for?

Pianist using two microphones

Wants to record an acoustic piano in stereo and send the recording to a computer in a straightforward way. Shure describes using microphones by the bass and treble strings; their positioning affects the stereo balance and can cause phase issues during mono playback.

Recorder who wants separate tracks

Wants to be able to adjust microphones or other sources separately after the recital. Allen & Heath’s ZEDi-10 specifications distinguish between its four USB inputs and the number of analogue inputs.

Pianist who wants to record without a laptop

Wants to record the performance directly to a memory card and is therefore looking for a mixer with a built-in recorder. Zoom and Tascam describe SD recording on their respective recorder-mixers.

What should you consider when choosing?

First decide whether you’re recording an acoustic piano with microphones or a digital piano via its line outputs. Then choose between a single stereo mix, separate tracks on a computer and standalone recording to an SD card.

What to consider What should you look for? Who is this important for?
Stereo sound Check for two usable microphone inputs, the required microphone power and left-right routing. Make a test recording in the booth. If I want to record an acoustic piano in stereo with two microphones, I want to be able to assess the balance while recording. Around 36% of consumers give stereo sound top priority.
Separate tracks Compare the number of USB channels or SD tracks that can be recorded simultaneously with the number of sources you want to adjust separately later. If I want to adjust the microphones separately after the recital, separate recording tracks are more useful than just a stereo mix. Around 29% of consumers prioritise separate post-production.
Recording without a laptop Check whether the device can record on its own, which storage medium it needs and which features are available in the mode you’ve chosen. If I don’t want to connect a computer during the recital, I’m looking for a built-in recorder and a suitable storage card. Around 21% of consumers give laptop-free recording top priority.
Connecting a digital piano Check whether the piano has left and right line outputs and whether the mixer offers suitable stereo line inputs. If I want to record the direct sound of a digital piano, suitable stereo connections matter more than extra microphone inputs. Around 14% of consumers prioritise a direct line connection.

Common pitfalls

  • Confusing inputs with separate recording channels

    A mixer can have several microphone/line inputs without sending each signal to the computer as a separate USB track. Yamaha specifies four mono microphone/line inputs and 2-in/2-out USB for the MG10XU; Allen & Heath specifies 4-in/4-out USB for the ZEDi-10.

    Count the USB recording channels or SD tracks, not just the inputs on the front panel.

  • Assuming USB means you can record independently

    A USB connection on its own doesn’t prove that a mixer can record without a computer. Zoom and Tascam also describe an SD card recorder function for their respective models.

    Look specifically for a built-in recorder and check which storage medium is required.

  • Expecting a more advanced mixer to solve problems in the booth

    Shure explains that microphone placement affects the balance, attack and recorded ambient sound; it can also cause phase issues during mono playback.

    Make test recordings using different microphone positions and listen back before choosing extra mixing features.

  • Assuming a maximum sample rate means every feature is available

    According to Zoom, effects, EQ and the audio interface are among the features unavailable on the LiveTrak L-8 in 96kHz mode.

    Check which features work at the same time in the recording mode you actually want to use.

Brands to compare

Yamaha

The MG10XU is worth considering if you want to send a stereo mix of a piano recital to a computer via USB.

  • Yamaha specifies four mono microphone/line inputs, +48 V phantom power and 2-in/2-out USB for the MG10XU.
  • The USB specification doesn’t mean that all four analogue inputs are recorded as four separate USB tracks. Yamaha specifies a power adaptor.

Allen & Heath

The ZEDi-10 is an option to consider if you want to combine hands-on mixer controls, multichannel USB and stereo line inputs.

  • Allen & Heath specifies four microphone/line inputs, 4-in/4-out USB and stereo line inputs, including inputs for keyboards.
  • Check the manual for the channel routing that suits your recording. Don’t assume it has a built-in SD recorder if you need standalone recording.

Zoom

According to Zoom, the LiveTrak L-8 combines a mixer with separate-track recording to an SD card and a USB interface.

  • Zoom describes simultaneous recording to a computer and an SD card.
  • According to Zoom, effects, EQ and the audio interface are unavailable in 96kHz mode. Check the features available in each mode.

Tascam

The Model 12 is designed for anyone looking to combine standalone multitrack recording and computer recording in one mixer-recorder.

  • Tascam specifies recording up to 12 tracks to SD in WAV at up to 24-bit/48 kHz, and a 12-in/10-out USB interface.
  • The additional recording and storage features require more management than a simple stereo mix; this difference in features isn’t an independent sound quality test.

Behringer

The XENYX Q1002USB is a compact USB mixer to compare if two microphone inputs are enough for you.

  • Behringer lists two microphone inputs, four stereo inputs and a built-in USB audio interface.
  • If you want to record independently, check specifically whether your chosen setup has a recorder function. Behringer’s claims about sound and preamps are manufacturer claims, not independent measurements.

Related products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Should I record an acoustic piano in a small booth with one microphone or two?

It depends on the sound you want and the space available. Shure describes both placing one microphone by an upright piano and using two microphones above the bass and treble strings for stereo; phase issues can occur during mono playback. Make test recordings and listen to them in mono too, as a mixer can’t determine the right placement.

Do condenser microphones need extra power?

Check the requirements of your own microphones. Yamaha specifies +48 V phantom power for the MG10XU, as does Allen & Heath for the ZEDi-10. Follow the microphone and mixer manuals when connecting and powering them on.

Can I record a piano recital without a computer?

Only if the setup you choose can record on its own. Tascam describes a built-in SD recorder in the Model 12, and Zoom describes separate SD tracks for the LiveTrak L-8. A USB connection on its own doesn’t mean a mixer can record without a computer.

What can I do if the booth sound is too prominent in the recording?

Start with a test recording and change the microphone placement before trying to correct the sound with the mixer. Shure explains that positioning affects the balance, attack and recorded ambient sound; the right position depends on the piano and the room.

Can I publish a recording of the recital?

Not automatically: private use and distributing copyrighted music are different things. The Dutch government states that a private copy for personal use can’t be distributed or made available to the public without the necessary permission. If a company or organisation records identifiable people at an event, privacy rules also apply, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority. The exact situation depends on the work, the performers and the intended use.