Who is this guide for?

Acoustic pianist recording in a noisy room

You want to record a performance on a real piano and weigh up how much background noise you pick up against the piano sound you want. Sound On Sound discusses how microphone distance can affect how much other sound gets into a recording.

Pianist who wants to mix later

You’re recording several microphones, or a piano and another source, at the same time and want to adjust the recorded channels separately afterwards. Check the number of USB recording channels, not just the number of mixer channels.

Pianist with a digital piano

You want to find out whether you can record the piano through a direct audio connection, without using microphones in the room to capture its sound. Focusrite explains that a stereo output needs two inputs.

What should you look for?

First decide whether you’re recording an acoustic or digital piano. Then choose between a fixed stereo mix, separate tracks or recording independently.

Consideration What to check before buying Who should consider this?
Background noise and piano sound Count the microphone inputs you need and check whether your microphones require phantom power. Make a test recording with your planned microphone placement. If I’m recording an acoustic piano in a noisy room, I want to limit background noise without losing sight of the piano’s sound. Around 36% of consumers put this balance at the top of their wish list.
Stereo mix or separate tracks Check how many USB channels or separate memory card tracks the exact model records, and how its channels are routed. If I want to adjust the balance between microphones or other sources after the performance, I need separate recording tracks. Around 29% of consumers make post-production their top priority.
Recording a digital piano directly Check which audio outputs your piano has and whether two suitable line inputs are available for stereo. When I want to record the internal sound of a digital piano without room microphones, I check my instrument’s outputs first. Around 21% of consumers prioritise direct digital recording.
A simple recording setup Check whether the device can record independently, which storage medium it uses and how many microphone inputs you actually need. If I want a straightforward workflow and don’t need features or equipment I won’t use, I compare the connections and storage I need. Around 14% of consumers prioritise simplicity and keeping extra equipment to a minimum.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing the number of mixer channels with the number of USB tracks

    A mixer can have more physical inputs than separate USB recording channels. Yamaha specifies four microphone/line inputs for the MG10XU, but 2-in/2-out USB audio.

    Before buying, check the number of USB channels that can be recorded at the same time and the routing on the exact model.

    If you later find that you need separate tracks, you may need a different mixer or recording interface.

  • Expecting a mixer to fix a noisy room

    Noise already picked up by the microphones won’t disappear when you connect the mixer via USB. Close-miking may pick up less background noise, but it also affects the piano’s tonal balance.

    Test the microphone placement and listen for both background noise and the balance between low and high notes.

  • Choosing a memory card recorder without counting the microphone inputs

    According to Zoom, the Zoom LiveTrak L6 has two XLR/TRS combo inputs; the other instrument inputs aren’t additional microphone inputs.

    Count how many microphones you want to connect directly at the same time and check that the inputs are suitable.

Brands to consider

Yamaha

The MG10XU is worth considering if you want to control several sources on a physical mixer and a combined USB recording is enough.

  • Yamaha specifies four microphone/line inputs and 2-in/2-out USB audio for this model.
  • Four physical inputs don’t mean you can record four separate USB tracks.

Allen & Heath

The ZEDi-10FX is an option if separate USB channels and hands-on mixer controls are important to you.

  • Allen & Heath specifies four mono inputs with XLR and a 4-in/4-out USB interface.
  • Check the USB source selection and don’t confuse the ZEDi-10FX with the differently routed ZED-10FX.

Zoom

The LiveTrak L6 suits a compact setup with microSD recording.

  • Zoom specifies ten separate tracks plus a stereo mix on microSD, and a 12-in/4-out USB interface.
  • The model has two XLR/TRS combo inputs; the other instrument inputs aren’t additional microphone inputs.

Mackie

According to Mackie, the ProFX10v3+ lets you choose between a complete mix and an unprocessed signal from channels 1 and 2.

  • Mackie says Standard mode records the mix, including processing, while Interface mode sends the unprocessed signals from channels 1 and 2.
  • The stated 2x4 USB interface doesn’t record all ten mixer channels separately.

Tascam

The Model 12 is an alternative for a larger setup combining a mixer, USB interface and standalone SD multitrack recorder.

  • Tascam specifies a 12-track recorder, ten mixer inputs and a 12-in/10-out USB interface.
  • The extra recording features may not be necessary if you only want to save a final stereo mix.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can a USB mixer remove neighbours’ noise from an acoustic piano recording?

No. Recording via USB won’t do that: any background noise picked up by the microphones will be part of the signal. Sound On Sound explains that placing microphones closer to the piano may pick up less other noise, but can also change the tonal balance, so make a test recording first.

How do I connect a digital piano for stereo recording?

If your piano has suitable left and right audio outputs, connect them to two suitable line inputs and check that both channels are being recorded. Focusrite describes this two-channel connection for a stereo signal; check your piano’s manual to confirm its actual outputs.

How can I tell if I can edit separate tracks later?

Check how many USB recording channels or separate memory card tracks the exact model records, and how the signals are routed. The number of physical mixer channels doesn’t automatically equal the number of separate recording tracks.

Do I need a computer during the performance?

Not if the mixer-recorder can record independently to a memory card. Zoom lists microSD recording for the LiveTrak L6, and Tascam lists SD recording for the Model 12. Check which storage medium you need and test your recording workflow in advance.

Who should I contact about a faulty mixer I bought as a consumer in the Netherlands?

Report the fault to the retailer. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that your statutory guarantee applies in addition to any manufacturer’s guarantee. If a product breaks sooner than you could reasonably expect under normal use, the retailer must resolve the issue in line with the applicable terms.