Which type is right for you?

Pianist recording a stereo recital

You want a recording that’s ready to use, so you’re mainly concerned with microphone placement, the stereo image and the mix sent to your computer. Shure explains how microphone position affects the stereo image and the sense of space, while Yamaha describes the MG10XU’s USB connection.

Recording engineer who wants to mix later

You want to be able to adjust microphone signals separately after the performance. Check which signals each model sends to your recording software via USB, as Allen & Heath explains for the ZEDi-10FX.

Recording without a laptop in the venue

You want to record the performance straight to a memory card, so look for a model with standalone recording. Zoom and Tascam describe SD recording options on the LiveTrak L-8 and Model 12 respectively.

What should you look for?

Stereo mix via USB

Best for: mixing the microphones into a final mix during the recital. Yamaha specifies 2-in/2-out USB audio for the MG10XU.

Trade-off: this USB specification doesn’t mean that every mixer input is recorded separately.

Separate USB tracks

Best for: editing signals separately after the performance. Allen & Heath specifies four channels to recording software for the ZEDi-10FX.

Trade-off: the selected USB mode determines which signals are recorded, so set up the routing in advance.

Standalone recording to SD

Best for: recording during the performance without a laptop. Zoom and Tascam describe SD recording functions for the LiveTrak L-8 and Model 12.

Trade-off: check the compatible storage media, power supply and recording settings for the exact model in advance.

Key consideration Check before buying Who is this important for?
Stereo image and room sound Check that the mixer has the microphone inputs you need and that it sends your chosen stereo mix to the computer. If possible, make a test recording with different microphone positions. If I mainly want to capture a balanced piano mix and the sound of the room, I’ll consider both the microphone setup and the USB stereo routing. Around 36% of consumers prioritise stereo sound.
Separate tracks Check the number of USB recording channels that can be used simultaneously and which inputs the selected USB mode sends to the software. If I want to adjust the microphones separately afterwards, I’ll check the channel assignment for each model. Around 29% of consumers prioritise being able to process signals separately.
Recording without a computer Look for a built-in SD recorder and check the compatible card and power options for the exact model. If I don’t want to record with a laptop during the recital, a standalone recorder is important. Around 21% of consumers prioritise recording without a laptop.
Simple setup Work out how many sources you really need to record and whether a stereo mix will do; check the USB output and headphone monitoring in advance. If I want to focus on recording during a recital rather than managing complex routing, a straightforward signal path is more suited to my needs. Around 14% of consumers prioritise simplicity.

Common mistakes

  • Confusing the number of mixer channels with separate USB tracks

    A mixer may have more physical inputs than USB recording channels. Yamaha specifies 2-in/2-out USB for the MG10XU; on the ZEDi-10FX, the USB mode determines which four signals go to the recording software.

    Make a note of which sources need their own track, then compare your list with the USB routing on the exact model.

  • Assuming a USB mixer records on its own

    A USB interface and a built-in SD recorder are different features. According to their manufacturers, the LiveTrak L-8 and Model 12 have a separate SD recording function.

    If you want to record without a laptop, check that the model records directly to SD, then test the card and recording settings in advance.

  • Waiting until the recital to assess microphone placement

    Shure explains that microphone position affects the tone, stereo image and amount of audible room sound.

    Plan a test recording in the rehearsal space and listen back using the setup you intend to use.

Brands to consider

Yamaha

The MG10XU is an option if you want to record a mix made during the recital on a computer via USB.

  • Yamaha specifies +48 V phantom power and 2-in/2-out USB audio for the MG10XU.
  • This USB specification doesn’t mean that every mixer input is recorded separately.

Allen & Heath

The ZEDi-10FX is worth considering if you want to send different microphone signals to separate tracks.

  • Allen & Heath specifies four mic/line inputs, global 48 V phantom power and a 4-in/4-out USB interface for this model.
  • Which signals are recorded depends on the USB mode selected.

Zoom

The LiveTrak L-8 is an option if you want to record separate tracks to SD, possibly alongside recording on a computer.

  • Zoom says the model can record separate tracks to SD.
  • Zoom gives a maximum run time of around an hour and a half using four AA batteries; the run time for a specific recital setup may vary.

Tascam

According to Tascam, the Model 12 combines a mixer, USB interface and standalone multitrack recorder.

  • Tascam says the internal recorder can save up to 12 tracks as WAV files to SD, at up to 24-bit/48 kHz.
  • This SD specification applies to the Model 12’s described recording function; check the recording settings for the model you choose.

Mackie

The Onyx8 is another option to compare for multitrack recording via USB or SD.

  • Mackie specifies multitrack recording via USB or SD at up to 24-bit/96 kHz for the Onyx8.
  • The recording format alone doesn’t determine which microphone signals are captured separately in the mode you choose.

Products related to this topic

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I automatically need a mixer with four USB tracks for two piano microphones?

No. Two USB recording channels may be enough for a final stereo mix. If you want to edit the microphones or additional sources separately later, check how many signals the model can send simultaneously and which inputs the USB mode selects.

How do I start positioning microphones for a grand piano?

Make test recordings in the rehearsal space using different positions, then listen for the stereo image, the attack and the sense of space. Shure describes Blumlein and spaced microphone setups for a grand piano, among others. These are starting points, not guaranteed solutions for every room or for an upright piano.

How can I avoid a failed SD recording?

Check in advance that the exact device recognises the card, which tracks are being recorded and how the device is powered. Play back a test recording too. Tascam publishes a list of tested storage media for the Model 12; it applies specifically to that model.

What are my rights if the mixer doesn’t work properly after I buy it?

For a consumer purchase, the seller must provide an appropriate solution if a product becomes faulty too soon under normal use. The Dutch government (Rijksoverheid) states that there is no fixed statutory warranty period for every product in the Netherlands. A cooling-off period for an online purchase is different from a remedy for a faulty product: ACM ConsuWijzer generally gives a period of up to 14 days after delivery, subject to legal exceptions.

Can I publish a recording of a piano recital?

That depends on the performance, the musical work and what can be recognised in the recording. Auteursrecht.nl describes the rights performers have in recordings of their performances; you may need permission from a rights holder to make protected music available to the public. The Dutch Data Protection Authority (Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens) notes that recognisable audio recordings may constitute personal data. These conditions do not amount to general permission or a general ban on every private recording or publication.