Choose based on what you want to be able to adjust after the rehearsal: a stereo mix is ideal for listening back to the choir as a whole, while separate tracks are needed if you want to adjust individual microphones. Yamaha states that the MG10XU sends only the stereo bus over USB, so check how many separate recording channels are available and make a test recording in the space you plan to use. Shure recommends using as few microphones as necessary when recording a choir, and giving careful thought to the setup itself.
Who is this relevant to?
Choir leader who wants to listen back
Wants to listen back to the entire rehearsal as one usable recording and set the balance while recording. Shure recommends limiting the number of microphones used for choir recordings, while Yamaha explains that the MG10XU sends only the stereo bus over USB.
Creator who wants to edit sections separately
Wants to be able to adjust microphones individually afterwards, which means having separate recording tracks. According to their manufacturers, the Tascam Model 12 and Zoom LiveTrak L-8 offer recording functions for separate tracks.
Recorder who moves between venues
Wants to take the recording equipment along and check that SD recording and the available power supply suit different rehearsal spaces. Tascam and Zoom describe SD recording for the Model 12 and LiveTrak L-8 respectively; Zoom also states that the L-8 can be powered by batteries or USB.
What should you look for when choosing?
Stereo mix over USB
Choose this option if: you want to listen back to one mixed recording and can set the balance during the rehearsal.
Bear in mind: you can’t retrieve individual microphone signals from the stereo mix afterwards. Yamaha states that the MG10XU sends only the stereo bus over USB.
Separate tracks
Choose this option if: you want to adjust choir sections or an accompanying instrument separately later, for example. Tascam specifies a 12-in/10-out USB interface and an internal 12-track recorder for the Model 12; Zoom states that the LiveTrak L-8 records separate tracks to SD.
Bear in mind: you’ll need to manage channel assignment, storage and files. Separate tracks won’t fix unsuitable microphone placement or distracting noise in the room.
When recording a choir, your choice of equipment and the quality of the recording also depend on microphone placement. Shure recommends limiting the number of microphones used to what’s necessary, so test the setup in the space where you’ll be recording.
| What to consider |
What to look for |
Who is this important for? |
| The overall choir sound |
Make a test recording from the planned microphone positions and listen to how well the voices blend in the room. |
I mainly want to assess how the whole choir sounds in the room; around 33% of consumers prioritise this overall impression when choosing what to buy. |
| Separate microphone tracks |
Check how many separate USB recording channels are available or whether there’s an internal multitrack recorder. |
If I want to adjust microphones individually afterwards, I need separate tracks; around 25% of consumers prioritise this option. |
| Recording in different locations |
Check whether the model records directly to an SD card and whether its power supply suits the location. |
I want to record in different rooms without relying on a laptop during the rehearsal; around 25% of consumers see this flexibility as a priority. |
| Connections and equipment |
Count the microphones you’ll use at the same time and check for suitable inputs and, if needed, phantom power. |
If you want to connect your existing microphones and equipment, the setup as a whole is key; around 17% of consumers start with these practical connection requirements. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Confusing the number of mixer channels with the number of USB recording tracks
A mixer can have several inputs and still send only a stereo mix over USB. Yamaha states that this is the case with the MG10XU.
First decide whether you need a final mix or separate microphone signals, then check the recording outputs specifically.
-
Expecting more tracks to fix an unsuitable choir setup
Separate tracks let you adjust sources individually afterwards, but they don’t change what the microphones picked up in their original positions.
Make a short test recording with the planned microphone placement before comparing models by track count. Shure recommends using as few microphones as necessary when recording a choir.
-
Focusing only on the mixer when planning your setup
How well the setup works also depends on the microphones, stands, cables and any storage media you actually need.
Make a list of your existing equipment in advance and compare it with the connections and recording features of the model you’re considering.
-
Treating an old multitrack specification as proof that a product is currently available
Soundcraft marks the Signature 12 MTK as discontinued. The product specifications alone don’t tell you whether the model is currently available or still supported.
Use this model as a technical comparison at most, and check current availability and support separately.
Relevant brands to consider
Yamaha
The MG10XU is an example of a mixer for anyone who wants to record a single stereo mix on a computer over USB.
- Yamaha lists four microphone/line inputs, +48 V phantom power and 2-in/2-out USB for the MG10XU.
- According to Yamaha, this MG-USB series sends only the stereo bus over USB, so it isn’t suitable if you need to record separate microphone tracks over USB.
Tascam
The Model 12 combines a mixing desk, multichannel USB interface and internal SD recording.
- Tascam specifies a 12-in/10-out USB interface and an internal 12-track recorder for the Model 12.
- The extra features are most useful if you’ll use them; check that the controls, power supply and inputs you need suit your classroom setup.
Zoom
The LiveTrak L-8 is worth considering for mobile rehearsal recordings where separate SD tracks are needed.
- Zoom lists six microphone preamps, separate SD tracks and battery or USB power for the L-8.
- The battery life quoted by Zoom depends on the conditions of use, so check the power supply and storage for your planned rehearsal.
Mackie
The Onyx12 is an option to compare if you’re looking for hands-on analogue controls and multitrack recording over USB or SD.
- Mackie states that the Onyx12 supports multitrack recording via USB or SD card.
- Check which recording features and microphone connections you need for each channel. The manufacturer’s claims about preamp quality aren’t an independent performance assessment.
Soundcraft
The Signature 12 MTK illustrates the difference between stereo USB and multitrack USB, but it isn’t an obvious choice for a new purchase.
- Soundcraft lists 14-in/12-out USB for the Signature 12 MTK.
- Soundcraft marks this model as discontinued. Historical specifications don’t prove current availability or support in the Netherlands.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Does USB on a mixing desk mean I can record each choir microphone separately?
No, it depends on the recording outputs of the specific model. Yamaha states that the MG-USB series sends only the stereo bus over USB, and specifies 2-in/2-out USB for the MG10XU. If you need separate tracks, look for explicitly listed multichannel recording channels or an internal multitrack recorder.
How can I check the microphone setup in a classroom?
Make a test recording from the choir’s usual position and listen to whether the different vocal sections come through clearly enough. Shure recommends using only as many microphones as necessary for choir recordings; adjust their exact placement to suit the room.
Can I record during the rehearsal without a laptop?
Yes, with specific models that record directly to storage media. Tascam lists internal SD recording for the Model 12, while Zoom lists separate SD tracks for the LiveTrak L-8. Check the power supply and storage media in advance; a USB connection alone doesn’t mean a mixer can record independently.
Can I record and share a choir rehearsal in a classroom?
This depends, among other things, on whether people can be recognised, the purpose of the recording and who it’s shared with. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers recognisable audio recordings to be personal data; if the GDPR applies, you’ll need an appropriate legal basis for processing them. For primary and secondary schools, the Dutch Data Protection Authority also notes that pupils and parents must be informed. For cover versions of songs in the repertoire represented by BumaStemra, BumaStemra states that a licence may be needed to record or perform them.