First, decide whether you need a combined stereo mix or separate tracks. A stereo mix is enough for a quick review of a rehearsal, while separate USB or SD tracks give you more flexibility to adjust microphone positions individually afterwards. Then check how many suitable microphone inputs there are, how the signal is routed and whether you want to record without a computer. A mixer won’t automatically remove background noise already picked up by the microphones, so make a test recording at your rehearsal venue.
Who is this guide for?
Recording in a noisy room
You mainly want to check whether the choir comes through clearly above ventilation, traffic or other room noise. Try different microphone positions before choosing extra mixer features: Shure explains that microphones placed further away can pick up more background noise.
Editing choir tracks
You want to be able to adjust microphone positions individually afterwards. Check how many inputs are actually recorded independently, not just how many channels the mixer has.
Quick rehearsal archivist
You want an easy way to listen back to a combined recording, and need to choose between a computer-based stereo mix and recording without a computer. Decide in advance which workflow you need for the rehearsal.
What should you look for?
USB mixer for a stereo mix
A good fit if: you want to make a combined recording on a computer using up to two suitable microphones.
Trade-off: a stereo mix gives you less flexibility to adjust microphones individually afterwards.
USB mixer with separate tracks
A good fit if: you want to record several microphone positions separately in software and don’t need a built-in SD recorder.
Trade-off: check the USB routing on the exact model. The number of mixer channels alone doesn’t tell you how many separate tracks it records.
Mixer-recorder with SD recording
A good fit if: you want to record without a computer connected, or use SD recording alongside computer recording.
Trade-off: extra recording features may involve more controls than you need just to listen back quickly.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Choir and background noise |
Test your intended microphone positions at the rehearsal venue and listen back to the recording. |
If I’m recording in a noisy room, I want to hear whether the singing comes through clearly. Around 36% of consumers put this balance first. |
| Separate recording tracks |
Check how many signals the exact model records at once and how the inputs are routed to USB or SD. |
If I want to adjust microphone positions individually afterwards, I look at the tracks actually recorded. Around 29% of consumers give this top priority. |
| Quick playback |
Check whether the USB output records the combined mix you want and whether there are enough suitable microphone inputs. |
For a quick review of the overall performance, I may not need an extensive multitrack workflow. Around 21% of consumers mainly want simple playback. |
| Recording without a computer |
Check whether the model records to SD, which storage medium it needs and how to transfer files. |
If I want to record during rehearsal without a computer, I look for a mixer with a recorder and check the storage it requires. Around 14% of consumers prioritise recording without a computer. |
The percentages show a possible breakdown of the priorities mentioned in this choir rehearsal scenario; they are not measured purchasing figures.
Avoiding common buying mistakes
-
Expecting a USB mixer to solve a noisy-room problem
Background noise picked up by the microphone is already part of the recording signal. Extra mixer features won’t make it disappear automatically.
Test the microphone setup where you rehearse and listen back to a test recording before choosing extra recording features.
-
Assuming mixer channels are the same as USB tracks
The Yamaha AG06MK2 has six mixer channels, but Yamaha specifies a 2-in/2-out USB connection. The USB specifications for the Allen & Heath ZEDi-10 and ZED-10 also differ.
For the exact model, check both the number of USB recording channels and how the signals are routed.
-
Planning your setup around the mixer alone
The mixer alone won’t ensure that your planned microphones can be connected or that the recording is saved correctly.
Beforehand, make a list of the microphones, connections, power requirements and storage you’ll need for your recording setup.
You may need suitable microphones and cables for your setup. SD recording also requires a suitable storage medium.
Brands to compare
Yamaha
The AG06MK2 is a compact option for a planned computer recording with two microphones.
- Yamaha specifies two microphone inputs with phantom power and 2-in/2-out USB audio.
- That USB connection doesn’t mean you can record six separate USB tracks, and it won’t suppress room noise picked up by the microphones.
Allen & Heath
The ZEDi-10 is designed for a setup with more microphone inputs and a four-channel USB interface.
- Allen & Heath specifies four microphone/line inputs, global 48 V phantom power and 4-in/4-out USB audio.
- Check the routing for your recording. According to Allen & Heath, the ZEDi-10 has different USB specifications from the ZED-10.
Zoom
The LiveTrak L-8 combines mixing with SD card recording and USB audio.
- Zoom specifies six microphone preamps with phantom power and separate SD recording tracks.
- Having more recording options won’t remove background noise already picked up by the microphones.
Mackie
The Onyx8 is an option if you’re looking for USB and SD multitrack recording in one mixer.
- Mackie specifies multitrack recording via USB or SD.
- Check that the number of inputs and the routing suit your setup. The stated specification alone isn’t a comparison of sound quality.
Tascam
The Model 12 combines a mixer, SD multitrack recorder and USB interface.
- Tascam specifies a 12-track recorder and a 12-in/10-out USB interface.
- Tascam lists the Model 12 as a discontinued product on its European downloads page. So check the availability and support for the unit you’re considering.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Can a USB mixer remove ventilation or traffic noise from a choir recording?
Don’t count on it: background noise picked up by a microphone can end up in the recording. Shure explains that a microphone placed further away can pick up more background noise, so try different positions and listen to a short test recording.
What should I check when connecting condenser microphones?
Compare the number of microphones you plan to use with the number of microphone inputs, and check the power requirements of the specific microphones. Yamaha specifies two inputs with phantom power for the AG06MK2; Allen & Heath specifies four microphone/line inputs and global 48 V phantom power for the ZEDi-10.
What should I look for in an SD card mixer-recorder?
Before the rehearsal, check the recording source, storage medium and a short test recording. Consult the documentation for the exact model to check supported cards and software. Tascam publishes information about storage media and manuals for the Model 12.
Can I record identifiable choir members and share the recording?
It depends on who is recording, the purpose and how the recording will be shared. The Dutch Data Protection Authority classifies identifiable audio recordings as personal data. An organisation needs a lawful basis under the GDPR to process them. The exception for purely personal or household use is limited and doesn’t automatically apply to a choir society or public publication. Before recording or sharing, establish which lawful basis applies and inform the people concerned.
Does consent from the singers also cover the rights to the recorded music?
Not necessarily: consent from the singers and rights to the music are separate matters. BumaStemra describes a licence for using music during rehearsals and performances by amateur music societies and choirs. You’ll need to establish separately which rights apply to the specific repertoire and the intended distribution.