First, consider whether your journal can stay open without straining the binding. An overhead scanner captures bound pages from above, while with a flatbed you need to position the book on the glass. A flatbed may suit you if the journal can rest on it safely and you also want to scan loose photos or documents. For a fragile or stiff binding, overhead scanning is an alternative. Then check how much space the scanner takes up when in use, whether its software works with your computer and whether the scan will preserve your handwriting and illustrations clearly enough.
Which scanner is right for you?
If you want to protect your journal’s binding
If your journal doesn’t open flat easily, compare an overhead scanner with a flatbed. With a flatbed, you need to position the page on the glass, so check that you can do this without straining the spine.
If you want to preserve handwriting and images
If you want to preserve drawings or pasted-in photos as well as text, assess the image scan separately from any text recognition. A searchable PDF doesn’t automatically mean your handwriting will be converted accurately.
If you share a small desk
Measure not just the space you have to store the scanner, but also the room needed with your journal open and the scanner in use. Even a compact device may need a generous work surface while you’re scanning.
What should you look for when choosing?
Start by considering the binding and the space you have available. Then compare image and text output, and check that the software is compatible with your computer.
Overhead book scanner
Choose this option: if you want to scan bound pages from above without pressing them against glass.
Bear in mind: an open book and the scanning setup need space; check that your journal fits within the capture area.
Book-friendly flatbed
Choose this option: if your journal can rest on the glass without straining the binding, and you also want to scan loose pages or photos.
Bear in mind: you’ll need to position the book for each page; a book edge on the scanner doesn’t make the process contactless.
Standard A4 flatbed
Choose this option: if your journal opens easily and you also want to digitise loose documents or photos.
Bear in mind: check the page size and don’t force a stiff or fragile binding flat.
| What to consider |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important for? |
| Protecting the binding |
Measure your open journal and check whether the binding can rest on the glass without being forced; compare this with the capture area of an overhead scanner. |
If your journal has a stiff or fragile binding, you’ll want to avoid putting strain on the spine. Around 33% of consumers put preserving the binding first. |
| Handwriting and images |
Check the available image formats and, if possible, scan a test page with small writing, colour and details near the spine. |
If you want to preserve handwritten notes, drawings or pasted-in photos, assess the image scan separately from text recognition. Around 27% of consumers make this their top priority. |
| Working and storage space |
Measure both the space needed for the open book and scanner while in use, and the space where you plan to store the device. |
If you share a desk or have limited storage, you’ll want to know how much room the whole scanning process takes up. Around 20% of consumers put space first. |
| Cost and software |
Compare the right version, the software included and the operating systems supported. First decide whether you need a flatbed or an overhead scanner. |
If you want to avoid paying for a device or feature that isn’t right for your computer or journal, check these requirements in advance. Around 20% of consumers put cost and software compatibility first. |
Common scanning pitfalls
-
Assuming a searchable PDF can recognise handwriting
The term ‘searchable PDF’ doesn’t tell you whether the software can recognise the handwriting in your journal.
Keep an image version too, and test text recognition with a representative sample page.
Allow time to check and correct recognised text, or to find notes manually.
-
Looking only at the scanner’s storage dimensions
An open journal and the scanning setup take up space while in use, even if you can put the scanner away compactly afterwards.
Measure your desk with the journal open before choosing an overhead model or flatbed.
-
Assuming a book-friendly flatbed is contactless
Even with the Plustek OpticBook 4800, you need to position the book on the glass; its 2 mm book edge doesn’t prevent the binding from being put under strain.
Choose a flatbed only if your journal can rest on it without strain. Otherwise, compare overhead scanners.
Brands to consider
IRIS
The IRIScan Desk 6 Pro is an overhead option for bound pages, with several digital output formats.
- IRIS lists A3 capture and output to formats including image files and searchable PDFs.
- These features don’t show how accurately it will recognise handwriting in your journal. Also check that the software works on your computer.
CZUR
The Shine Ultra and Shine Ultra Pro are overhead models for bound books that you can put away after use.
- CZUR lists curvature correction; its own specifications state 13 megapixels for the Shine Ultra and 24 megapixels for the Shine Ultra Pro.
- Check the specifications for the exact model and make sure the setup fits on your desk while in use.
Plustek
The OpticBook 4800 is a book-focused flatbed option for pages that can safely be positioned on the glass.
- Plustek lists a 2 mm book edge and output to searchable PDFs.
- You still need to hold the book against the glass. For the eBookScan version, Plustek lists Windows software.
Epson
The Perfection V39II is a standard A4 flatbed for people who also scan loose photos and documents and want to store the device upright.
- Epson lists a stand for upright storage and a resolution of 4800 dpi.
- That doesn’t make it a contactless scanner, or mean that every stiffly bound journal will lie flat on the glass.
VIISAN
The DL8 is an overhead document camera that VIISAN also markets for bound books.
- VIISAN lists A3 capture, OfficeCam, curvature correction and output to searchable PDFs.
- Test how the features work with your handwriting, and measure how much room the setup needs.
Joybuy models for bound journals
This Joybuy selection features flatbed scanners whose product information mentions books or bound documents. With both models, you’ll need to position the journal on the glass; don’t force a stiff binding flat.
No image available
Canon imageFORMULA DR-F120 Flatbed & ADF Scanner, 600 × 600 dpi, A4, Black
This may suit you if you want to scan books and fragile materials, as well as process loose documents using the automatic document feeder. Only position a bound journal on the flatbed if you can do so without straining it.
The product name lists 600 × 600 dpi, A4 and a combination of flatbed and automatic document feeder.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Epson WorkForce DS-1660W Flatbed Scanner, 1200 × 1200 dpi, A4, Black, White
This may suit you if you’re looking for a flatbed that the product information says is suitable for books and bound documents. Your journal must be able to rest on the glass without strain.
The product information lists 1200 × 1200 dpi and describes the design as compact. Check that the software works with your operating system, and measure how much space you’ll need while scanning.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can a scanner automatically make my handwritten travel journal searchable?
A scanner can save a page as an image, but text recognition also depends on the software and the handwriting. ABBYY describes dedicated handwriting recognition settings in a separate FineReader Engine product; this doesn’t confirm that the feature is included with a particular scanner bundle. Save an image scan and check a sample page before relying on searchability.
What should I get ready before I start scanning?
Measure your open journal and the available work surface, check that the software works with your operating system, and scan a page containing both text and images first. With a flatbed, you need to position the book on the glass; don’t force a stiff binding to make the page lie flatter.
What are my rights when I buy a scanner online?
According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online consumer purchases generally come with a cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, with some exceptions. You’re also covered by the statutory guarantee if a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect under normal use; this is separate from the length of any manufacturer’s warranty.
Can I scan travel journals and share the files?
For copyright-protected works, the Dutch government allows you to make a private copy for your own use, but not to distribute or publish it. Sharing other people’s personal data publicly may also be subject to privacy rules; the Dutch Data Protection Authority describes a limited exception for purely personal or household use. Scanning for your own use doesn’t mean you have to share the files publicly.