Who is this choice relevant to?

A class with bound journals

You want to keep the bound pages intact, so prioritise a flatbed that’s large enough. The ADF only matters for any loose inserts. Brother Netherlands describes the flatbed as suitable for large or bound documents, such as books.

A class with lots of loose travel pages

You also handle stacks of loose pages, so a document feeder is useful alongside a flatbed for bound material. Models from Epson Netherlands and Canon Netherlands have an ADF that holds up to 35 sheets.

A class that also prints scans

You’re weighing up colour printing, how often you’ll use it and the cost of consumables. If a scan contains identifiable pupil information, you’ll also need to decide how the school will store those files and manage access to them.

What should you consider when buying?

Start with the type of pages you have: use the flatbed for bound journals, then decide whether loose stacks make an ADF necessary. Next, consider how much you’ll print and where scans containing identifiable information will be stored.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Bound pages Check that the flatbed is large enough for the pages and that you can scan them flat without putting strain on the binding. If I want to keep the journals bound, I’ll prioritise a suitable flatbed. Around 33% of consumers prioritise scanning bound pages without damaging them.
Stacks of loose pages Check whether the model has an ADF and which paper sizes and quantities it can handle. If I also handle stacks of loose travel pages, I want to avoid placing each page individually. Around 27% of consumers prioritise scanning stacks of loose pages.
Printing needs Compare the appropriate ink or toner with your expected usage, and bear in mind that inkjet ink may dry out if you print infrequently. If the class prints scans and worksheets, I’ll take colour requirements and printing frequency into account. Around 20% of consumers focus mainly on printing needs and running costs.
Pupil information Decide where scans will be stored, who will have access and whether an external service will process data on the school’s behalf. If scans could contain identifiable pupil information, I’ll want to know in advance who can view and manage them. Around 20% of consumers prioritise data protection.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming a large-capacity ADF can handle bound journals

    An ADF handles loose sheets; you use the flatbed for a bound journal. So the feeder’s capacity doesn’t tell you whether the journal pages will fit on the scanning surface.

    Work out which parts of your collection are bound, then check the scanning surface and supported size first. Only then decide what ADF capacity you need.

  • Looking only at the printer’s purchase price

    Running costs also depend on the type of consumables and how much you print. If you don’t print often, inkjet ink can dry out in the printhead; the Consumentenbond describes this risk for inkjet printers.

    Compare the appropriate ink or toner based on your own printing volume, rather than relying only on the stated page yield.

  • Assuming OCR guarantees accurate recognition

    A scan is an image; text recognition doesn’t automatically turn it into a reliable transcription. Microsoft warns that handwritten or highly stylised text doesn’t work well with the OneNote OCR described.

    Keep the page images and check any recognised text manually if you want to make the content searchable.

    Checking and correcting recognised text takes extra time.

  • Assuming a cloud feature means the storage is approved

    A scan destination in an app doesn’t automatically mean its use complies with the school’s policies. If an external provider processes personal data on the school’s behalf, there are additional considerations.

    Before use, ask the school to assess the storage destination, access permissions and any data processing agreement.

Brands to consider

Epson

EcoTank ink-tank models are worth comparing if you want to combine scanning with regular colour printing.

  • Epson lists a flatbed and a 35-sheet ADF for the EcoTank ET-5150.
  • Inkjet ink can dry out if the printer is used infrequently. You’ll also need to compare models against your own printing volume.

Canon

The MAXIFY MegaTank GX4050 is an ink-tank model to include in a comparison for colour printing and loose sheets.

  • Canon lists a refillable ink-tank system, Ethernet and a 35-sheet ADF for the GX4050.
  • Check that the flatbed is suitable for your journals and compare running costs based on your own printing habits.

Brother

The DCP-L8410CDW is a colour laser printer worth comparing if text printing and handling loose sheets are important to you.

  • Brother lists a 50-sheet ADF and scan destinations including OCR.
  • Check whether this model’s flatbed is suitable for bound journals and whether its printing technology meets your colour or photo-printing needs.

HP

The Smart Tank 7605 is an ink-tank model worth comparing if you’re looking for colour printing and an ADF.

  • For the 7605, HP lists scanning to PDF, a 35-sheet feeder and automatic double-sided printing.
  • Check that the flatbed suits your journals and compare the stated yields with your own usage.

Joybuy product picks

These all-in-one printers combine scanning with printing features for classroom documents. Check the feeder and printing options for each model to see which suit your journals and the prints you need.

HP Smart Tank 7305 wireless all-in-one colour printer with double-sided printing, copier and scanner

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One Colour Printer

An option for combining scanning and colour printing in one device.

The product information lists a flatbed, a 35-page ADF and automatic double-sided printing.

View at Joybuy
Canon PIXMA MG2556S inkjet printer, A4, 4800 × 600 dpi

Canon PIXMA MG2556S Inkjet A4 4800 × 600 DPI

An all-in-one option for anyone who wants to combine printing, scanning and copying.

The product name lists inkjet, A4 and 4800 × 600 dpi.

View at Joybuy
Epson EcoTank ET-M16680 all-in-one inkjet printer, A3, Wi-Fi

Epson EcoTank ET-M16680 Inkjet A3 Wi-Fi

A model to consider if your work involves stacks of loose pages and larger paper sizes.

The product information lists A3 support and an automatic document feeder. The stated printing function is black and white, so choose this only if you don’t need colour printing.

View at Joybuy
Epson EcoTank ET-5185 inkjet printer, A4, Wi-Fi, 37 ppm

Epson EcoTank ET-5185 Inkjet A4 Wi-Fi

An option for printing, scanning and copying when you can place loose pages in the feeder individually.

The product name lists A4, Wi-Fi and 37 ppm. The product information describes a flatbed; check whether placing loose sheets manually suits the quantity you need to handle.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I feed a bound travel journal through the automatic document feeder?

Use the flatbed for bound pages; the ADF is designed for suitable loose documents. Before buying, check that the page fits on the flatbed.

Will handwritten text become searchable automatically after scanning?

No. A scan of an image doesn’t make the text searchable on its own. You’ll need OCR software, and any recognised text should be checked. Microsoft warns that handwritten or highly stylised text doesn’t work well with the OneNote OCR described; this doesn’t tell us how other software or printer models perform.

What maintenance does an ink-tank printer need if we print very little during the holidays?

With inkjet printers, ink can dry out in the printhead and cause blockages, as the Consumentenbond explains. Compare how often you expect to print with a toner-based option, and follow the maintenance instructions for the model you choose.

Can we store or publish scans containing identifiable pupil information in an external app without taking any precautions?

No. The school must assess how personal data is processed and protected. If an external provider processes that data on the school’s behalf, the Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that an agreement with the processor is required. Publishing identifiable images is subject to a separate consent rule: for pupils under 16, parental consent is required. This rule for images is not a general consent requirement for every internal text scan.

How long can scans containing personal data be kept?

The GDPR doesn’t set a single standard retention period. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, personal data should not be kept for longer than necessary for its purpose. The school must decide and document an appropriate period for each specific type of processing.