Listener on a noisy train
You want to follow spoken history stories without constantly turning up the volume. A good fit and noise cancellation are important considerations.
If train noise drowns out the narrator, a well-fitting pair of over-ear noise-cancelling headphones is an obvious choice. If you want to keep hearing announcements and what’s happening around you, consider open-ear earbuds or a model with an awareness mode. VeiligheidNL and the WHO recommend a good fit and noise cancellation to help you avoid turning the volume up in noisy places. Neither listening style guarantees that you’ll hear every announcement, so check the controls and keep the volume moderate.
You want to follow spoken history stories without constantly turning up the volume. A good fit and noise cancellation are important considerations.
You want to stay aware of your surroundings while listening, and are weighing up an awareness mode or open-ear design against the isolation of closed-back headphones.
Consider how comfortable the fit feels during longer listening sessions, and how often the headphones need charging or maintenance.
First decide whether you mainly want to block out noise and focus on the narrator, or keep hearing your surroundings. Then check the fit, controls and battery life.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Hearing speech clearly over train noise | Check how the ear cups fit and try ANC with a spoken recording at a moderate volume. | If I want to follow the narrator without constantly turning the volume up, clear speech is my top priority. Around 36% of consumers rank this as their most important purchase priority. |
| Hearing announcements and your surroundings | Try how quickly you can pause or switch on an awareness mode; open-ear headphones also let train noise in. | If I want to notice announcements or what’s happening nearby while listening to a story, I weigh that against noise isolation. Around 29% of consumers prioritise awareness of their surroundings. |
| Fit and controls | If possible, try the model with your glasses on and check that pausing and switching listening modes is easy. | On longer journeys, I want a comfortable fit that stays comfortable and controls that are easy to use. Around 21% of consumers choose primarily based on wearing comfort and controls. |
| Battery and maintenance | Compare battery life using the same ANC setting and check that replacement parts are compatible with the exact version. | If I want to avoid interruptions for charging or be able to replace parts, I pay particular attention to the battery and maintenance. Around 14% of consumers prioritise these factors. |
An open design lets in the sounds around you, but also noise that can drown out the narrator.
Choose open-ear if staying aware of your surroundings matters more to you, and try to see if speech remains clear at a moderate volume.
Advertised maximums may be based on different settings. Sony states that the WH-CH720N lasts up to 35 hours with NC on and 50 hours with NC off; JBL links its maximum of 70 hours to ANC being off and also lists 44 hours.
Check which setting applies to the advertised battery life, and don’t treat a manufacturer’s maximum as guaranteed listening time on your journey.
The Dutch government states that the retailer is responsible for resolving issues with a faulty product, and that there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands.
Check what cover you already have and exactly what the terms of any additional warranty product offer.
The WH-CH720N is an over-ear model with noise cancellation and an ambient sound mode.
According to JBL, the Tune 770NC features adaptive ANC, Ambient Aware and TalkThru, so you can switch between listening and hearing your surroundings.
The Space One is an over-ear model with adjustable transparency.
The OpenFit Air is an open-ear option for anyone who wants to stay aware of the sounds around them.
According to Fairphone, the Fairbuds XL combines ANC with a modular design for anyone who values easy maintenance.
This Joybuy selection includes in-ear and over-ear noise-cancelling headphones for listening to spoken audio on a noisy train.
No image available
In-ear earbuds with active noise cancellation for listening to spoken audio on a noisy train.
Up to 6 hours of playback with ANC on and up to 26 hours with the charging case; the description lists 6 microphones and an adjustable equaliser.
No image available
Closed-back over-ear headphones with active noise cancellation for listening to spoken stories over train noise.
The product description lists up to 24 hours of battery life and an audio cable for listening without battery power.
No image available
Over-ear Bluetooth headphones with noise cancellation for listening to spoken stories on the go.
The product description lists up to 30 hours of battery life with noise cancellation on and the ability to connect to two devices at once. It also says Speak-To-Chat pauses playback when you start talking.
No image available
Over-ear headphones with noise cancellation and an ambient sound mode, so you can switch between listening to stories and hearing your surroundings.
Sony lists a weight of around 192 g and up to 35 hours with NC on. Battery life depends on the settings used.
No image available
Over-ear headphones with adaptive ANC for listening to spoken audio on a noisy train.
The product description lists up to 40 hours of playback with ANC on.
Start at a low, comfortable volume and try a spoken recording. Compare ANC with the awareness mode and check that you can pause quickly. A good fit can help you avoid constantly turning the volume up over train noise.
The WHO recommends using well-fitting or noise-cancelling headphones in noisy places to help reduce the temptation to turn up the volume. Keep the volume moderate; the volume setting alone doesn’t tell you how much sound reaches your ears.
First check the advertised battery life for the ANC setting you use, and contact the retailer if there’s a problem. According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. For the Fairbuds XL, Fairphone offers a replaceable battery that is compatible only with that model.
The house rules published by NS require passengers to keep quiet in the quiet zone and not disturb others with audible sound. So listen privately and without disturbing anyone; this does not mean there is a general ban on wearing headphones. Other transport operators have their own rules.
According to the Dutch government, in many cases you have 14 days to change your mind when buying online from a business. Check the retailer’s information and any applicable exceptions; this cooling-off period is separate from your statutory rights if a product is faulty.