Who is this choice relevant to?

Collectors with bound booklets

If you want to digitise covers and pages without putting strain on the spine, take care of the original before prioritising feed speed. Brother advises against closing or pressing down hard on the scanner lid when scanning books and thick documents.

Archivists of loose programmes

If you have lots of suitable loose sheets, an automatic document feeder can make feeding them easier. After scanning, check that every page is there and in the right order; The National Archives includes checks like these in its digitisation process.

People working from home who also print

If the same device will also be used for everyday printing, your colour needs and how often you print will help determine which printing technology is right for you. The Consumers’ Association notes that ink can dry out if a printer is used infrequently, so how often you print is worth considering when comparing inkjet and laser options.

What should you look for when choosing?

Compact A4 colour inkjet with cartridges

Best for: mainly scanning loose programmes up to A4, occasional colour printing and a compact all-in-one solution.

Bear in mind: Canon specifies that the PIXMA TS7750i has a single-sided ADF for up to 35 sheets; automatic duplex printing doesn’t automatically mean duplex scanning.

A4 colour ink tank printer

Best for: regular colour printing and considering an ink tank model, taking your own print volume into account.

Bear in mind: Epson says the EcoTank ET-3950 has a duplex ADF; check that its scanning workflow and size suit your originals. It’s still an inkjet printer if you use it infrequently.

A4 mono laser all-in-one printer

Best for: mainly printing black-and-white text, with no need for colour prints.

Bear in mind: Brother lists a 50-sheet ADF for the DCP-L2660DW; black-and-white printing alone tells you nothing about colour scanning or supported file formats.

A3 all-in-one printer

Best for: scanning larger originals that won’t fit on A4; Epson says the WorkForce WF-7840DTWF can scan up to A3.

Bear in mind: an A3 scan specification doesn’t confirm that a bound programme will fit on the flatbed. Check the flatbed size for the exact model.

What to considerWhat should you check?Who should pay particular attention?
Bound or delicate originals Check the flatbed size and the space around the hinge; don’t force the lid. If I’m scanning a bound or delicate booklet, I want to be able to place it carefully on the flatbed. Around 31% of consumers put preserving the original first.
Lots of loose pages Check the ADF capacity and separately whether duplex scanning is available; also check the page order. When I have a stack of suitable loose sheets, I want to avoid feeding pages one by one and make sure none are missed. Around 25% of consumers prioritise handling loose sheets above all else.
Colour and digital files Check colour scanning, file formats and OCR for the exact model and software you’ll use. If colour and being able to find information later matter to me, I want a legible file and, if needed, searchable text. Around 19% of consumers put this kind of usability first.
Larger originals Measure your largest original and compare it with the stated maximum scan area; don’t rely on an A3 specification alone. When my programme is larger than A4, I want to know whether the original will fit on the scanner in one go. Around 13% of consumers make scan size their main purchasing concern.
Printing needs Compare the printing technology with how often you print and the proportion of colour and black-and-white pages. If I print regularly as well as archiving, I want to choose a technology that suits how I actually use it, not just the purchase price. Around 12% of consumers base their choice mainly on their own print volume.

Common purchasing mistakes

  • Choosing an ADF without considering the binding

    An automatic document feeder is designed for suitable loose sheets; a bound or delicate booklet needs a different approach. Prioritising feed speed over the condition of the original can put it under strain.

    Sort bound, delicate and loose items before choosing a scanning method. Place bound material carefully on the flatbed and follow the model’s instructions.

  • Assuming ‘duplex’ means duplex scanning

    A printer may print automatically on both sides but still have a single-sided ADF. According to Canon, the PIXMA TS7750i is a specific example.

    Look for duplex scanning separately in the specifications for the exact model.

  • Comparing only the printing technology or a single running-cost claim

    Whether you print infrequently or regularly can change the balance between cartridge, tank and laser printers. The Consumers’ Association notes that inkjet ink can dry out if used infrequently; manufacturers’ savings claims don’t tell you what you’ll save personally.

    Compare the options based on how often you print and how many colour and black-and-white pages you produce.

  • Assuming A3 means any booklet will fit on the flatbed

    An A3 scanning specification doesn’t automatically tell you the size of the flatbed or whether it’s suitable for a bound original.

    Measure your largest programme and check the scan area and feeding method for the exact model.

Brands to compare

Canon

Canon’s PIXMA colour inkjets for home use include models for A4 scanning and loose sheets.

  • Canon specifies an ADF for up to 35 single-sided sheets on the PIXMA TS7750i.
  • Automatic duplex printing is listed separately.
  • The ADF specification doesn’t confirm automatic duplex scanning; check the scanning function separately.

Epson

EcoTank models offer an ink tank option; WorkForce models may serve a different purpose, including scanning up to A3 with the WF-7840DTWF.

  • Epson specifies a duplex ADF for the EcoTank ET-3950.
  • Epson says the WorkForce WF-7840DTWF can scan up to A3.
  • These features apply to specific models; check that the scan area and workflow suit your originals.
  • Epson’s savings claims are manufacturer claims and don’t necessarily reflect what you’ll save with your printing habits.

Brother

Brother offers both colour inkjet models and a mono laser all-in-one printer here.

  • Brother lists a 20-sheet ADF for the MFC-J4350DW and a 50-sheet ADF for the DCP-L2660DW.
  • The DCP-L2660DW prints in black and white only; check the scanning features you need for each model.

HP

The HP OfficeJet Pro 9120 series is designed for document handling, with a duplex ADF.

  • HP lists a 35-page duplex ADF for the 9120 series.
  • HP notes that the 9120e has cartridge restrictions due to dynamic security; check the terms for the exact model.

Joybuy products for archiving at home

This selection includes all-in-one printers for colour printing and home archiving, with A4 models and one model listed as A3. For your chosen model, check the maximum scan area separately, as well as its suitability for loose or bound originals.

HP Smart Tank 7305 wireless all-in-one colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7305

Could suit colour printing and scanning suitable loose sheets in a home office.

HP lists a flatbed scanner, colour scanning and a scan area of 216 × 297 mm. The ADF holds 35 sheets. The title mentions duplex printing; check separately whether duplex scanning is supported.

View at Joybuy
Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer

Canon PIXMA MG2556S

Could suit an A4 home archive with occasional colour printing.

The product information lists printing, scanning and copying, with colour printing and an A4 specification. Before buying, check that it has the scanning features you need.

View at Joybuy
Epson EcoTank ET-M16680 A3 inkjet printer

Epson EcoTank ET-M16680

Could suit you if you want to print in black and white as well as archive documents, and are considering a model listed as A3.

The product information lists A3, scanning and an automatic document feeder. This model prints in black and white; the A3 specification alone doesn’t confirm the maximum scan area for every original.

View at Joybuy
Epson EcoTank ET-5185 A4 inkjet printer

Epson EcoTank ET-5185

Could suit an A4 home office where you want to print in colour and feed suitable loose sheets.

The product information lists an A4 EcoTank model with colour printing, scanning and copying, plus an automatic document feeder. Check separately whether the scanning function supports the duplex workflow you need.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 wireless all-in-one colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7005

Could suit colour scanning from the flatbed, for example if you want to scan bound programmes carefully, one at a time.

The product information lists a flatbed scanner and a scan area of 216 × 297 mm. This model doesn’t have an automatic document feeder, so loose sheets must be placed on the scanner one at a time.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I feed a bound programme booklet through the automatic document feeder?

Use the ADF for suitable loose sheets, not to feed an intact booklet through the machine. Check the condition of the paper and place bound material carefully on a suitable flatbed; don’t force the lid. Also follow the instructions for your chosen model.

Is automatic duplex printing the same as duplex scanning?

No. Canon lists automatic duplex printing for the PIXMA TS7750i, but specifies that its ADF is single-sided. So check duplex scanning as a separate feature.

How can I keep my digital archive useful?

After scanning, check that every page is there, legible and in the right order. Use recognisable file names or keywords, and check OCR separately if you want to search the text in your scans. The National Archives describes quality control and keywords as parts of its own digitisation process, not requirements for private archives.

What should I consider when it comes to maintenance and running costs?

If you print infrequently, inkjet ink can dry out or the printer may use ink for cleaning. The Consumers’ Association describes this risk for inkjet printers. So compare printing technologies against how often you print and the proportion of colour and black-and-white pages.

Can I share scanned theatre programmes online?

The Dutch Government says you can make a private copy of a protected work for your own use, but you can’t distribute or publish it. Different permissions and reprographic rights conditions may apply to copying and sharing for business or institutional purposes; having a private archive doesn’t automatically give you permission to publish material.