Who is this choice relevant to?

Manager of a growing film archive

You want to keep the film, raw footage and project files locally, and your main priority is having enough space for backups.

Filmmaker who takes files on the go

You move large files between locations and are weighing up storage capacity against portability and ease of transfer.

Volunteer responsible for backups

You want to check which files have been copied and whether you can actually open them later. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends testing a backup by opening files from it.

What should you consider when choosing?

External desktop HDD

Choose this when: the film, raw footage and project files need plenty of space, and the drive will usually stay in one place.

Trade-off: a desktop model may need a power adapter and is less suited to being carried around.

Portable external SSD

Choose this when: you often move the copy between locations or regularly transfer large files.

Trade-off: check that the capacity is sufficient and that the connection works with your computer and cable. Advertised speeds do not guarantee the speed of your workflow.

Portable HDD with a protective case

Choose this when: you want a portable HDD and protection while travelling is a consideration.

Trade-off: a protective case is no substitute for an extra copy or a restore test; check the exact model.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most important for?
Capacity for the whole project Add together the film, source files and versions you want to keep, then compare the total with the drive's usable space. If I also want to keep raw footage and project files, I need enough space for the whole archive and the copies I plan to keep. Around 31% of consumers rank capacity as their top priority.
Recoverable, separate copies Keep a record of which files are copied, store the original separately and test by opening files from the backup. I want to know that my copy can be opened, not just that I have one, if something goes wrong. Around 31% of consumers prioritise recoverability and separate copies.
Portability and transfer Check that the capacity, connection and cable are suitable for the computers you want to transfer the files to. If I regularly take the film between locations, portability and easy transfers matter. This matches the top priority of around 23% of consumers.
Computer and file system Check the ports and backup software on the computers you use, and make sure the file system can handle large film exports. I want to be able to save and access the files on the computers I use, so I check the connection and file system in advance. Around 15% of consumers prioritise this compatibility.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming one external drive is a complete backup strategy

    The drive could fail or be lost along with the original. And making a copy does not prove that the files will still open later.

    Keep the original and backup separate, consider an extra local copy in another location, and test recovery by opening files from the backup.

    An extra local copy requires a second storage device and time to manage the copies.

  • Focusing only on the advertised maximum SSD speed

    The speed quoted for one SSD model does not, by itself, tell you how quickly files will copy using your computer and cable.

    Check the connection on both the drive and computer, and allow for the capacity you need for your entire backup plan.

  • Saving a large film export on FAT32 without checking the file size

    Microsoft Learn states that FAT32 has a maximum file size of 4 GB. A film file larger than this will not fit on that file system, even if the drive has space available.

    Check the export size and whether the file system you choose works with your computers and backup software. Before reformatting, make a safe copy of any existing files elsewhere.

Brands to compare

Seagate

Expansion Desktop is a desktop HDD range to consider if a fixed location and plenty of storage space for a film archive are important.

  • For model STKP8000400, the EMEA specification sheet lists 8 TB and a power adapter included.
  • These details apply to that model; check that its capacity and power supply suit your setup.

Samsung

The portable T7 Shield is an SSD range to compare if you regularly take your film work with you.

  • For MU-PE4T0S/EU, Samsung lists 4 TB, USB 3.2 Gen 2 and sequential speeds of up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s.
  • These are speeds quoted by Samsung, not a guarantee of transfer speeds with your computer and cable; also check whether 4 TB is enough.

LaCie

Rugged Mini is a portable HDD range for anyone who wants protection while travelling.

  • Seagate describes the casing as protective; product support includes the 5TB model STJJ5000400, among others.
  • A protective casing does not mean a backup is automatically recoverable; keep an extra copy and test your files.

Western Digital

WD Elements Desktop is a desktop HDD range to include when comparing options for a fixed workstation.

  • For a specific model, compare the capacity and connection, and check whether it needs a power adapter for your backup setup.

Products for a local film backup

This selection includes portable external drives and a desktop HDD for local film and project files. Check in advance that the capacity and connection suit your files and computers.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD for a local copy you want to take between locations.

Capacity: 1 TB. Advertised read speed: up to 800 MB/s. Actual transfer speeds also depend on the computer and cable you use.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C, Graphite Black

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C, Graphite Black

A portable HDD for a local copy with more capacity than the 1TB model above.

Capacity: 5 TB. The product description lists USB-C, a portable 2.5-inch design weighing 240 g, and compatibility with Windows and Mac. Protect the drive from knocks and always eject it safely.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Desktop 6TB USB 3.0

WD Elements Desktop 6TB USB 3.0

A desktop HDD for a backup you usually create and store in one fixed location.

Capacity: 6 TB. The product description lists USB 3.0, a power adapter and NTFS for Windows. For use with Mac, the description says the drive needs reformatting, which erases existing data; make a copy elsewhere first and check the file system.

View at Joybuy
My Passport USB-C 2TB, Black

My Passport USB-C 2TB, Black

A portable HDD for a local copy that you can connect without a separate mains power supply.

Capacity: 2 TB. The product description lists USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and hardware encryption. Check that it has enough space for all the film and project files you want to keep.

View at Joybuy
My Passport 6TB White, portable hard drive

My Passport 6TB White

A portable HDD for anyone who wants to take a local copy with 6 TB of capacity.

The product description lists USB 3.0, 256-bit AES hardware encryption, password protection and software for scheduled backups. Handle the drive with care and always eject it safely.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can I check that a film backup is usable?

After copying, open a few files from the backup and check that the files you expect are there. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends opening files as a way to test a file backup.

Can I make automatic backups on a Mac without using the cloud?

Yes. Apple explains how Time Machine can use an external drive connected directly to your Mac. For a full Mac backup, Apple recommends a drive with at least twice the Mac's storage capacity; that is not automatically the minimum capacity needed for individual film files only.

Can a theatre organisation always copy and keep a film?

Not without considering the rights and intended use. The Government of the Netherlands states that copyrighted films may be used with the creator's permission; the private copying exception for personal use cannot automatically be applied to a theatre organisation.

Do privacy rules apply if people are recognisable in the footage?

Yes. Recognisable people in film footage are personal data, so privacy rules apply. The Dutch Data Protection Authority points out that the GDPR applies to recognisable images; check which lawful basis and retention period apply to your project.

Can a film export larger than 4 GB be stored on a FAT32 drive?

No. According to Microsoft Learn, FAT32 has a maximum file size of 4 GB. Before copying, check that the file system you choose is suitable for the film export and the computers you want to use it with.