Essay editor working with Word comments
You need to send back comments or tracked changes in a .docx file. Microsoft documents these features in Word for iPad; check that they work with your document and workflow.
Start by considering the file you need to send back. For comments and tracked changes in Word, how well the document app works matters more than screen specifications alone. For handwritten PDF notes, pen support and a usable export file are key. Then test your own essay for readability and check that the tablet, stand and, if needed, keyboard will fit on your desk. A larger screen gives you more room, but takes up more space too. This is practical buying advice, not an independent performance test of the models mentioned.
You need to send back comments or tracked changes in a .docx file. Microsoft documents these features in Word for iPad; check that they work with your document and workflow.
You mark up text and architectural images, and want your annotations to remain visible in the shared file. So test exporting and reopening one of your own PDFs too.
You switch between reading and typing in a limited workspace. Allow for the space needed by the tablet, stand and keyboard as well as the screen size.
A good fit if: you want to review Word documents with comments or tracked changes and have tested these features with your own file.
The trade-off: Apple lists support for Apple Pencil (USB-C) and Magic Keyboard Folio for the iPad (A16), but neither the pen nor the keyboard is listed in the stated box contents. Check the configuration you choose.
A good fit if: you mainly want to mark up PDFs and view text alongside images or floor plans.
The trade-off: Samsung lists S Pen support for the Galaxy Tab S10 FE, while Xiaomi lists the Focus Pen as compatible with the Pad 7. Check whether the pen is included with your configuration and test the document app.
A good fit if: you need a specific Windows desktop app or workflow for your studies.
The trade-off: Microsoft lists the keyboard and Slim Pen as optional accessories. Also check that your apps and peripherals work with Windows on Arm on the Surface Pro with Snapdragon you are considering.
A good fit if: you mainly read PDFs and want to send handwritten comments back as a PDF.
The trade-off: reMarkable says Convert to Notebook requires a Connect subscription and does not preserve elements such as tables, columns and margins. Bear this in mind when working with essays that have complex formatting.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Document revisions | Open one of your own .docx files, add a comment, review tracked changes and check the returned file on another device. | If I need to submit an essay with comments, I want to be able to see my revisions in the required file. Around 36% of consumers put accurate document revision first. |
| PDF mark-ups | Check pen compatibility and box contents; annotate one of your own PDFs, export it and reopen the file. | When I add comments to a shared PDF, I want them to be visible in the version I receive too. Around 29% of consumers prioritise PDF annotation and export. |
| Image detail | View the same PDF on the screen you plan to use and check captions, legends and lines from your usual viewing distance. | When I review floor plans and illustrations, I want to assess fine details without constantly zooming in. Around 21% of consumers prioritise how drawings and images are displayed. |
| Desk space | Measure the available desk space and compare it with the full setup, including a stand and any accessories. | At a small desk, I want to read and type without the setup taking up too much room. Around 14% of consumers give the available space and overall setup the most weight. |
Pen compatibility and box contents are two different things, and may vary by configuration or bundle.
Check the contents of the configuration you have chosen and make sure the pen is compatible with the exact model.
A PDF mark-up is not automatically the same as an editable Word comment or tracked change. reMarkable also says that some formatting is lost with Convert to Notebook.
Check which file you need to send back and test the full round trip with an essay similar to the one you will be working on.
A larger screen takes up more space, and a stand and keyboard need extra room too.
Measure your desk and try viewing one of your own pages at the screen size you are considering.
Microsoft warns that software and peripherals may behave differently on Arm-based Surface devices.
Check that the specific study apps and devices you need work with the configuration you choose.
The 11-inch iPad (A16) is worth considering if you want to use Word for iPad and are looking for a tablet around 11 inches.
The Galaxy Tab S10 FE is a 10.9-inch Android option to compare for PDF mark-ups and colour images.
The Pad 7 is an Android option if screen proportions and document detail are important points of comparison.
The Tab M11 Power Bundle is worth comparing if you are looking for a tablet and pen sold as one specified package.
The Surface Pro 12 inch is worth considering if you need specific Windows software for your reviewing work.
The Paper Pro is a paper-like option for reading and handwritten PDF revisions, but not necessarily for editable Word revisions.
This selection includes iPad, Android and paper-like models for assessing text revisions, PDF notes and screen space. Check the features and accessories of the exact configuration against your own files and workspace.
No image available
A compact iPad option for testing Word revisions with your own essay.
11 inches; Wi-Fi; 256 GB. Apple Pencil Pro and Magic Keyboard sold separately.
No image available
A paper-like option for reading PDFs and adding notes to documents; test whether the export works for the way you share essays.
The product information lists an 8.2-inch E Ink screen, a stylus and a weight of 230 g.
No image available
An Android option with a pen for annotating documents; bear in mind how much space a larger screen takes up.
12.1-inch 2.5K screen; 8 GB RAM; 256 GB storage. The product information lists a Lenovo Pen as included.
No image available
The larger screen is useful for viewing essays and images, but takes up more room on a compact desk.
13 inches; Wi-Fi; 128 GB. Apple Pencil Pro and Magic Keyboard sold separately.
No image available
An Android tablet with a pen for notes on study materials; consider whether the larger size will fit on your desk.
12.7-inch screen; Android 15; 256 GB storage. The product information lists a T-Pen for notes and sketches.
Yes. Microsoft documents how to view and add comments and changes in Word for iPad. Test the features with the document, account and submission method you actually use.
Test it with a sample file: add a comment or mark-up, export or share it, then reopen the version you receive. Adobe says that signing in with an Adobe ID is required to add and edit annotations using its mobile PDF workflow.
It depends on the exact configuration. Apple lists only the tablet and USB-C cable in the box contents for the iPad (A16), while Lenovo lists a tablet with a pen and charger for the Tab M11 Power Bundle reviewed. Check the box contents and model compatibility before choosing your complete setup.
According to the Dutch government, in many cases you have a 14-day cooling-off period when buying at a distance; check whether these rules apply to your transaction. For a faulty product, contact the seller. The Dutch government says there is no fixed statutory warranty period for this.