Who is this guide for?

iPad user working with scans

You already have an iPad and are looking for a Pencil or compatible alternative that suits your tablet model and drawing style.

Galaxy or Xiaomi artist

You want to draw on your existing Android tablet and need a pen designed for that specific tablet model.

Artist creating varied outlines

You want to vary your lines or shading by pressing harder or more lightly, so you’re also checking whether your drawing app supports pressure input.

What should you consider when choosing?

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Compatibility Compare your exact tablet model and pen version with the compatibility list, and check for any software requirements. If you want to keep drawing on your current tablet, you’ll want to make sure the pen is compatible with that model. Around 33% of consumers put compatibility first.
Line weight and shading Check that both the pen and your drawing app support pressure sensitivity. Tilt control is a separate feature. If you want to vary outlines by pressing harder or more lightly, the pen, tablet and app must all support pressure input. Around 27% of consumers prioritise this pressure-sensitive control.
Working with a scan Check whether your app can import the scan file and manage separate layers. If you want to keep the original intact while drawing over it, you’ll need an app that supports layers. Around 27% of consumers start by checking whether they can work with scans and layers.
Charging and accessories Check how the pen charges and where it can be stored, and find out which cables, adapters or replacement tips you’ll need. If you mainly want to draw with ease, charging, maintenance and the accessories you need could make all the difference. Around 13% of consumers look at these first.

On iPad, Procreate lets you add a scan as a separate layer using supported image formats. Procreate’s documentation also explains how to adjust layer opacity.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing a pen based only on the tablet brand

    Compatibility varies between pen and tablet models. A pen designed for one generation won’t necessarily work with another.

    Make a note of your exact tablet model and compare it with the compatibility list for the specific pen.

    If the pen and tablet aren’t compatible, you may need to replace the pen.

  • Confusing tilt sensitivity with pressure sensitivity

    Tilt control doesn’t automatically mean that pressing harder will change the line. For pressure-sensitive outlines, both the pen and drawing app must support the feature.

    Check that pressure sensitivity is supported by the exact pen model and the app you want to use.

  • Focusing only on the pen and overlooking how you’ll work with scans

    Your app also determines whether you can import a scan and trace over it on a separate layer.

    Try your scan file to check that the app you have in mind supports importing images and working with layers.

  • Assuming magnetic attachment means magnetic charging

    The Apple Pencil (USB-C) attaches magnetically, but pairing and charging are done using a USB-C cable. Apple says the Pencil Pro pairs and charges magnetically.

    Check storage and charging separately for the model that’s compatible with your tablet.

    Remember that the Apple Pencil (USB-C) needs a charging cable.

Brands and models to consider

Apple

Pencil models for specific iPads; compatibility and the required iPadOS version vary by model.

  • Apple describes the Pencil (USB-C) as tilt-sensitive and says it pairs and charges using a USB-C cable. According to Apple, the Pencil Pro pairs and charges magnetically.
  • Tilt sensitivity doesn’t mean pressure sensitivity. Check that your exact iPad is compatible with the Pencil you choose.

Samsung

S Pen models for specific Galaxy Tab models.

  • Samsung says the S Pen for Tab S10 Lite has a replaceable tip, and lists pressure detection for the S Pen for Tab S11.
  • The name S Pen alone doesn’t tell you which tablets it works with. Check the exact pen and tablet models.

Xiaomi

Focus Pen Pro for the Xiaomi Pad models specified by Xiaomi.

  • Xiaomi specifies 16,384 pressure levels for this pen.
  • The stated response time is based on internal laboratory data and may vary in real-world use. Check which Pad models are supported.

Adonit

The Note⁺ 2 is an active pen for specific iPads.

  • Adonit lists pressure sensitivity, palm rejection and customisable buttons.
  • According to Adonit, pressure sensitivity and the buttons only work after pairing with specific apps. Magnetic attachment also varies by model.

Logitech

Crayon for drawing and writing on supported iPads.

  • Logitech lists compatibility with iPads from 2018 onwards and says you can adjust the line by tilting the pen.
  • Tilt control alone doesn’t mean the pen supports pressure-sensitive lines. Check the exact Crayon model too.

Styluses for drawing on your tablet

These Joybuy products are designed for drawing and tracing scans on compatible tablets. Before buying, check that the pen works with your exact tablet model.

Logitech Crayon stylus, USB-C, silver

Logitech Crayon, USB-C, silver

An option for drawing on a compatible iPad. Check whether tilt control suits the way you want to create lines.

The product information lists compatibility with iPads from 2018 onwards and iOS 12.2 or later.

View at Joybuy
Apple Pencil Pro

Apple Pencil Pro

Ideal for artists who want to use pressure-sensitive strokes on a supported iPad. Check compatibility with your exact model.

The product information lists pressure and tilt sensitivity, as well as magnetic pairing and charging.

View at Joybuy
Samsung EJ-PX510 S Pen, beige

Samsung EJ-PX510 S Pen, beige

A model-specific option for drawing on a Galaxy Tab S9 FE or Tab S9 FE+. Check that your tablet is one of these models.

The product name lists a weight of 8.7 g.

View at Joybuy
Apple Pencil (2nd generation)

Apple Pencil (2nd generation)

An option for drawing on iPad models compatible with this version. Check that the generations listed match your tablet.

The product name lists the 12.9-inch iPad Pro (3rd, 4th, 5th and 6th generations), 11-inch iPad Pro, iPad Air (4th and 5th generations) and iPad mini (6th generation). The product information lists magnetic attachment, pairing and charging.

View at Joybuy
Apple Pencil (USB-C), white

Apple Pencil (USB-C), white

May suit tracing scans with smooth, consistent lines on a supported iPad. Tilt sensitivity isn’t the same as pressure sensitivity.

Pairing and charging are done via USB-C; with this model, magnetic attachment doesn’t mean magnetic charging.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can I trace a scanned drawing without drawing on the scan itself?

In an app that supports it, add the scan as a separate layer and draw on a new layer above it. In Procreate on iPad, you can add supported images and adjust a layer’s opacity. Check that your chosen app can open your scan file.

Is a tilt-sensitive pen also pressure-sensitive?

No, these are different features. Apple describes the Pencil (USB-C) as tilt-sensitive. For pressure-sensitive lines, check separately that both the pen and drawing app support pressure input.

What should I do if the pen tip wears down or the stylus stops working early?

Check whether a replacement tip is available for your pen model. For example, Samsung says the S Pen for Tab S10 Lite has a replaceable tip. If a product is faulty, under Dutch statutory warranty law the seller must offer an appropriate solution, depending on what you could reasonably expect from the product under normal use.

Can I publish a traced scan of someone else’s drawing?

Not necessarily. According to Dutch government information, original drawings may be protected by copyright. Before publishing or using one in another way, check that you have the rights or permission, or that a relevant legal exception applies.

Do I have a cooling-off period for a stylus bought online?

For online purchases made by consumers, there is generally a statutory 14-day cooling-off period from the day the product is delivered. ACM ConsuWijzer lists exceptions; check these and the returns information for your order.