Which option is right for you?

Tablet owners who want to trace directly on screen

You already have an iPad or Galaxy Tab and want to trace a scan on screen. Check which pen is compatible with your exact tablet model; Apple and Samsung publish information about compatible versions.

Computer artists with a small desk

You want to use the computer you already own and are considering a screenless graphics tablet. Check that its active area and working style—looking at a separate screen as you draw—suit your desk. Wacom and XPPen describe this type of graphics tablet.

Artists who want to vary their lines

You want to control your lines with pen pressure while tracing. Check the specifications of the specific pen and whether your drawing app supports the input you need. Procreate describes brushes that respond to pressure, tilt and rotation.

What should you look for when choosing?

A pen for a compatible iPad

Choose this option: if you already have a compatible iPad and want to draw directly on the scan. Procreate supports importing images and working with layers.

Bear in mind: Apple Pencil versions differ in compatibility and features, so check your iPad model and software version.

An S Pen for a compatible Galaxy Tab

Choose this option: if you already have a Galaxy Tab that Samsung lists as compatible with your chosen S Pen, and you want to draw on the tablet screen.

Bear in mind: features vary by version. Samsung states that the S Pen for models including the Tab S9 FE and Tab S10 FE doesn’t support Bluetooth.

A screenless graphics tablet for a computer

Choose this option: if you want to draw on your existing computer and have room to use the pen surface beside your screen.

Bear in mind: you draw on a separate surface while looking at another screen. Check the connection, driver and drawing app too.

What to consider What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Compatibility Note the full tablet model and software version, or check the connection and driver requirements for a graphics tablet. If I already own a tablet, I want to be sure the pen is the right fit for my device. Around 33% of consumers give compatibility with their own device top priority.
Scan and drawing app Try one of your own scans to check whether the app can import the file and let you draw on a separate layer. If I want to use my scan as a guide, I need to be able to open it in my app and edit the new lines separately. Around 27% of consumers prioritise this scan workflow.
Line variation Check whether the specific pen is pressure-sensitive and try the brush settings you want to use in your app. If I want to vary line thickness while tracing, I look at how the pen and brush respond to pressure. Around 20% of consumers give variable lines top priority.
Desk setup Compare the active area with the space available on your desk, and decide whether you want to draw directly on the image. If I work in a quiet study, I want a setup that fits my desk and suits the way I look at my drawing. Around 20% of consumers prioritise their desk setup.

Buying pitfalls

  • Buying a pen without checking your exact tablet model

    Apple publishes separate compatibility lists for Apple Pencil Pro and Apple Pencil (USB-C). A pen that isn’t compatible with your iPad won’t work for the way you want to use it.

    Compare your full iPad model and software version with the compatibility information for the specific pen.

    Choosing the wrong one could mean you need a different version.

  • Assuming all S Pens have the same features

    S Pen versions vary in compatibility and features. Samsung states that S Pens for models including the Tab S9 FE and Tab S10 FE don’t support Bluetooth.

    Check Samsung’s information for the exact pen and tablet models. Don’t assume they have features found on a different version.

  • Confusing a screenless graphics tablet with a tablet that has a screen

    With a screenless graphics tablet, you move the pen over a separate surface and view the image on another screen.

    Choose this way of working only if it suits your desk and drawing habits; otherwise, consider a pen for the screen tablet you already own.

Brands to consider

Apple

Apple Pencil versions are designed for supported iPads and may suit you if you want to trace directly over a scan.

  • Apple publishes compatibility information for each version. Apple says Pencil Pro includes features such as squeeze and barrel roll.
  • Pencil Pro doesn’t work with every iPad. Apple describes the USB-C version as tilt-sensitive and rechargeable via USB-C; check which features apply to the one you’re considering.

Samsung

S Pen versions are worth considering if you already have a Galaxy Tab that supports your chosen pen.

  • Samsung provides information about the compatibility and features of different S Pen versions.
  • Samsung states that S Pens for models including the Tab S9 FE and Tab S10 FE don’t support Bluetooth. Don’t assume they have features found on another version.

Wacom

Wacom Intuos graphics tablets are an option for computer users who want to draw on a separate pen surface.

  • According to Wacom, the Intuos S CTL4100 has a battery-free pen with 4,096 pressure levels.
  • The Intuos S CTL4100 has no screen, so you don’t draw directly on the image displayed on screen.

XPPen

The Deco 01 V2 is a screenless graphics tablet for computer users looking for a larger drawing area.

  • According to XPPen, the Deco 01 V2 has a 10 × 6.25-inch active area and a battery-free pen with 8,192 pressure levels.
  • The active area takes up desk space. For Android use, XPPen lists separate OTG and display requirements.

Joybuy products

These Joybuy products are designed for drawing with a pen on a compatible tablet or using a graphics tablet with a computer. Before buying, check compatibility with your exact device and drawing app.

Wacom Intuos Pro Pen Tablet Small

Wacom Intuos Pro Pen Tablet Small

A graphics tablet for drawing on a computer with a pen. Check that the connection, driver and drawing app are compatible with your setup.

Joybuy
Wacom One Pen Tablet Small S

Wacom One Pen Tablet Small S

An option for drawing on a computer with a graphics tablet. Check in advance that it works with your system and drawing app.

Joybuy
iPad stylus with USB-C charging port, tilt detection and palm rejection

iPad Stylus with USB-C Charging Port

May suit you if you’re looking for a stylus for a compatible iPad model; check support for your exact model.

The product name lists a USB-C charging port, tilt detection, palm rejection and magnetic attachment.

Joybuy
Apple Pencil Pro 2024

Apple Pencil Pro 2024

For drawing directly on a supported iPad. Before buying, check that your exact iPad model is compatible.

Apple says Pencil Pro includes features such as squeeze and barrel roll. Compatibility varies by iPad model.

Joybuy
Apple Pencil USB-C White

Apple Pencil USB-C White

An option for drawing directly on a compatible iPad. Check support for your exact iPad model.

Apple describes this version as tilt-sensitive and rechargeable via USB-C.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can you trace a scan on your iPad with any Apple Pencil?

No. Apple Pencil versions don’t work with every iPad. Apple lists the compatible iPad models for each version and, where applicable, the required iPadOS version. Also check that your drawing app can import the scan.

How do you use a scanned drawing as a guide in Procreate?

Procreate supports importing a file or photo onto the canvas and working with separate layers. Import a supported image file and draw on a new layer, so you can edit the guide and your new lines separately.

Does the pen for a screenless graphics tablet need charging?

According to Wacom and XPPen, the pens for the Intuos S CTL4100 and Deco 01 V2 described here are battery-free. However, check the connection and device compatibility required for the graphics tablet itself.

What can you do if your pen breaks too soon during normal use?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the seller must resolve the issue free of charge if a product doesn’t meet what you could reasonably expect during normal use. This may be done through repair, replacement or a refund; the appropriate solution depends on the circumstances.

Can you return a stylus bought online in the Netherlands?

Online purchases generally come with a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, although exceptions apply. ACM ConsuWijzer explains the conditions. A longer returns period offered by a shop is a separate policy and isn’t the same as the statutory cooling-off period.