Editor working beside a window
You compare recordings from a fixed position where glass and other hard surfaces can affect what you hear. So start by considering the positioning and possible reflections, as Genelec also explains.
Start with positioning: arrange both monitors at equal distances from your listening position, and assess reflections from the window; Genelec describes glass as a reflective surface. Then choose the size, connections and any room settings to suit your desk and audio source, but don’t treat those settings as a substitute for good positioning. Also check whether the package contains one monitor or a pair, and whether the power supply and connections will work for your setup.
You compare recordings from a fixed position where glass and other hard surfaces can affect what you hear. So start by considering the positioning and possible reflections, as Genelec also explains.
You want to assess small differences between takes, such as balance and mid-range frequencies, and are looking for a consistent stereo setup with connections that suit your audio source. Yamaha, PreSonus and KRK product information offers examples of connections and adjustment options to check for each model.
You have limited space for two speakers and need to weigh up their dimensions, your listening distance and how you want to assess bass. Genelec lists the dimensions of the 8010A; also check that two units of any model will fit your workspace.
For anyone comparing recordings beside a window, possible priorities include positioning, a consistent listening setup, space for two monitors and how you want to assess bass. Genelec points out that glass and other hard surfaces reflect sound.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who will find this most important? |
|---|---|---|
| Positioning and window reflections | Check whether both monitors can be placed at equal distances from your listening position, and angle them towards it. Also assess reflections from glass and other hard surfaces. | If I work beside a window, I want to assess the left and right channels from a similar setup. Around 33% of people in this situation prioritise positioning and reflections. |
| Comparing takes consistently | Check that the inputs match the output of your audio interface. Compare recordings using the same monitor settings and listening position. | When small differences between takes matter, I don’t want changing settings to cloud my comparison. Around 27% of people in this situation prioritise comparing takes consistently. |
| Two monitors on a small desk | Measure the available space for both monitors and check the dimensions of the exact model. Also check whether the package contains one monitor or a pair. | If my desk has limited space, I want to know in advance whether two units will fit side by side. Around 20% of people in this situation prioritise available desk space. |
| Assessing bass | Only compare frequency limits when they use the same measurement basis, such as −3 dB or −6 dB. Assess whether you can hear the bass you want to check from your listening position. | If differences in the bass determine my decision, I want to know the measurement conditions behind a stated frequency limit. Around 20% of people in this situation prioritise assessing bass. |
Glass and other hard surfaces can reflect sound. A monitor’s settings won’t automatically eliminate all the effects of the room.
First, see whether you can position both monitors appropriately and assess where reflections are coming from. Treat a model’s room settings as an adjustment option, not a substitute for assessing the room.
Changing the positioning or taking an acoustic approach may require extra time or materials.
Yamaha and Genelec list the HS5 and 8010A respectively as single units. The PreSonus Eris Studio 5 mentioned here is the ‘Single’ version.
Before ordering, check exactly how many monitors are included and what you’ll need for two channels.
You may need a second monitor for a stereo pair, along with suitable connections and a power supply.
Manufacturers may state frequency limits using different measurement bases. Yamaha lists figures for the HS5 at −10 dB and −3 dB; Genelec gives a lower limit of −6 dB for the 8010A.
Only compare figures when they use the same measurement basis, and assess whether the bass you want to check will be audible from your listening position.
The European product information for the HS5 describes an active nearfield monitor with XLR and TRS inputs, plus ROOM CONTROL and HIGH TRIM controls.
The European product page describes the Eris Studio 5 as having a front port and settings for Acoustic Space, low-frequency cut, mid-range and treble.
Genelec describes the 8010A as a compact active monitor with an XLR input and room compensation switches.
According to KRK, the ROKIT 5 Generation Five offers three listening modes and adjustment combinations for room and sound.
Neumann describes the KH 80 DSP A G EU as a compact nearfield option with DSP and desk-positioning features.
Only if you can create a workable listening setup there, preferably a symmetrical one, and assess the effect of glass and other hard surfaces. Glass reflects sound; a room setting doesn’t prove that those reflections will disappear. Also follow the instructions for use and safety guidance for the model you choose.
Point both monitors towards the same listening position and keep them at equal distances from it. ADAM Audio describes an equilateral triangle for stereo setups; Genelec also recommends paying attention to reflections and room compensation. Then compare takes using consistent settings and the same listening position.
An active monitor has its amplifier built in. However, check that the input on each model you choose matches the output of your audio source and that you have the required power supply. A passive monitor requires a suitable separate power amplifier.
Not necessarily: Yamaha lists the HS5 and Genelec the 8010A as individual units; the Eris Studio 5 mentioned here is the ‘Single’ version. For a consumer purchase in the Netherlands, the seller must offer a solution under Dutch government guidance if the product doesn’t meet the terms of the agreement. For many eligible online purchases from a business, a 14-day cooling-off period applies; check the terms for the specific purchase.
For electrical equipment within the scope of Directive 2014/35/EU, EUR-Lex specifies a designed range of 50–1.000 V AC or 75–1.500 V DC. Check the stated power supply and product documentation for the specific monitor; don’t judge whether it’s suitable for your workspace based only on information about another model or market.