Who are these monitors for?

Student processing tape recordings

Wants to compare any remaining hiss and check for possible damage to speech or music. Audacity explains how noise reduction can reduce tape hiss; Genelec points out that speakers can also produce noise of their own.

Student with a small desk

Needs to position two monitors around the listening spot and take desk and wall reflections into account. Genelec describes a stereo setup with the listener at the point of an equilateral triangle.

Student without an audio interface

Wants to connect directly to a computer, so compares USB with analogue connections. ADAM Audio and Kali Audio describe USB-C inputs on their desktop models; also check that the digital processing suits your files.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide how you’ll assess the hiss and any damage caused by noise reduction. Then check whether the connections, placement and package contents suit your desk and audio source.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Tape hiss and self-noise Compare the same passage before and after processing at the same listening level. Also listen with a silent source and, if needed, check the removed residue in your editing software. I want to hear whether any tape hiss remains after noise reduction, without confusing speaker or source noise with the recording. Around 29% of consumers prioritise accurate noise assessment.
Desk placement Measure whether two monitors will fit and whether you can angle them towards your listening spot. Check for placement controls if the model has them. At a small desk, I want to find a usable, comparable position on the left and right, despite reflections from the desk or wall. Around 23% of consumers prioritise suitable placement.
Connection to your audio source Compare the output on your computer or interface with the connections on the exact model. For USB, check the supported processing resolution too. I want to listen from my computer or existing interface without needing an unexpected connection setup. Around 18% of consumers prioritise a direct connection.
Complete stereo setup Check whether the package contains one monitor or a pair, and which cables or other connections you’ll need. Before choosing, I want to know what I’ll need to use two connected speakers. Around 18% of consumers prioritise a complete set.
Listening in shared accommodation Work out when you can listen at a modest volume, and take any house rules or agreements into account. In shared accommodation, I want to fit my listening routine around my housemates, without assuming that listening from a short distance will prevent noise disturbance. Around 12% of consumers prioritise consideration for housemates.

Common pitfalls

  • Comparing a single monitor with a stereo pair

    The package contents determine how many speakers you get: Genelec lists one 8010A per package, while Yamaha specifies the HS3 as a pair.

    Compare what’s in the package with the complete stereo setup you need, not just the product name.

  • Mistaking speaker noise for remaining tape hiss

    An active speaker or the audio source can produce a low level of noise of its own. In a quiet room or at close range, this can affect how you assess the recording.

    First listen with a silent source, then compare the recording before and after processing at the same listening level.

  • Using frequency limits as a complete measure of quality

    Product specifications may give frequency limits at different tolerances, such as −10 dB, −6 dB or −3 dB. On their own, these figures don’t tell you how clearly faint tape hiss will remain audible.

    Check the stated measurement conditions and assess your own material in the intended listening position.

  • Choosing USB without checking the processing resolution

    According to ADAM Audio, the D3V processes audio over USB at 48 kHz/16-bit, so 96 or 192 kHz files won’t play back at their original resolution.

    Before choosing USB for convenience, check that this limitation suits the way you work.

Brands to consider

ADAM Audio

The D3V is an active desktop stereo system for computer use, with USB-C or balanced TRS connections.

  • ADAM Audio lists placement switches and included stands. The manufacturer specifies internal USB processing at 48 kHz/16-bit.
  • That USB resolution matters if you’re assessing files at a higher original resolution. Erin’s Audio Corner’s published acoustic measurements aren’t a direct test of tape-hiss assessment in a student room.

Kali Audio

Kali Audio says the LP-UNF is designed for desktop use and has USB-C, Bluetooth, RCA and balanced TRS inputs.

  • Kali Audio describes settings for different desk and wall positions.
  • Erin’s Audio Corner’s acoustic measurements were carried out using a sample loaned by the manufacturer and aren’t a direct test of tape-hiss removal in a student room.

Yamaha

The HS3 is a compact analogue stereo pair for anyone with a suitable computer output or audio interface.

  • Yamaha specifies combo, RCA and stereo mini-jack inputs, plus ROOM CONTROL and HIGH TRIM.
  • The listed specifications don’t include a USB input. Compare frequency limits at the same tolerance; figures at −10 dB and −3 dB aren’t directly comparable.

Genelec

The 8010A is a compact analogue nearfield monitor, sold individually and designed for use with a suitable XLR output.

  • Genelec describes its compact dimensions and placement controls.
  • The manufacturer lists one monitor per package, so you’ll need two for stereo. Genelec’s general information about low self-noise doesn’t prove that this model is the best for this listening task.

Related products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell whether the hiss is coming from the recording or the monitors?

Compare the recording before and after processing at the same listening level, and also listen separately with a silent source. Genelec explains that speakers can produce a low level of noise of their own; noise can also come from the source. Audacity recommends listening to the removed residue during noise reduction to check for possible damage to the sound you want to keep.

How should I position two monitors on a small desk?

Angle both monitors towards your listening spot and try to position them similarly on the left and right. Genelec describes an equilateral triangle as the ideal stereo setup, but see what actually works in your room and on your desk.

Do I always need an audio interface?

No, not if your monitor has a connection that works directly with your computer. ADAM Audio and Kali Audio say that the D3V and LP-UNF respectively have USB-C; for a model with analogue inputs only, you’ll need a compatible analogue output. ADAM Audio specifies USB processing at 48 kHz/16-bit for the D3V, so check this limitation if you’re assessing files at a higher original resolution.

What warranty rights do I have in the Netherlands?

When you buy as a consumer, you have statutory protection in addition to any manufacturer’s warranty. According to the Dutch government, there’s no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands: what you can expect from a product depends on the product and the circumstances. If a product is faulty, contact the seller.

What product regulations apply to active monitors sold in the Netherlands?

Sellers must ensure that electrical and electronic equipment complies with the applicable European rules. Business.gov.nl states that, for a compliant product, the manufacturer applies the relevant CE marking and draws up an EU declaration of conformity. CE isn’t a mark of audio quality; a model with Bluetooth may also be subject to radio equipment regulations.