Anyone comparing audio takes with colleagues
You want to assess differences in voice or mix, but need to agree listening times and volume with others. Arboportaal notes that even quieter sounds can be disruptive.
If you can arrange listening sessions with colleagues and use a fixed, symmetrical listening position, choose a compact active stereo pair that suits your desk and audio source. If playing through speakers would disturb colleagues, headphones are more practical. Headphones aren’t a direct substitute for assessing stereo playback through speakers, and room settings or product specifications can’t predict how monitors will sound in your office.
You want to assess differences in voice or mix, but need to agree listening times and volume with others. Arboportaal notes that even quieter sounds can be disruptive.
A fixed listening position and enough room to place two speakers evenly are important. Genelec offers advice on monitor placement.
You want to switch between, for example, a computer, audio interface and headphones, so it’s worth checking the connections and what’s included. ADAM Audio, Yamaha and Genelec describe a range of connections and in-box contents.
Choose this when: you can agree listening times with colleagues and position two speakers around one fixed listening spot.
Trade-off: a fixed stereo position makes it easier to listen together, but even quiet playback can disturb colleagues, and the room affects what you hear.
Choose this when: colleagues need to concentrate or speaker playback isn’t suitable at that time.
Trade-off: headphones limit the sound heard by others, but they aren’t a direct substitute for assessing stereo playback through speakers.
Choose this when: your setup, listening needs and noise agreements justify the extra equipment.
Trade-off: extra equipment and more bass won’t automatically make takes easier to compare. Passive monitors also need a suitable external amplifier.
When comparing audio takes in a shared office, the main considerations are avoiding disruption to colleagues, having a repeatable listening position, available desk space and suitable connections.
| Consideration | What to look for when buying | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Avoiding disruption to colleagues | Check the volume control and whether you can switch to headphones; agree suitable times for playback. | I want to play clips without distracting colleagues; around 31% of consumers prioritise avoiding noise disruption for colleagues. |
| Assessing takes under comparable conditions | Check that both speakers can be aimed evenly at one listening position, and keep their position and settings consistent. | I want to tell whether a difference is in the take itself, rather than a change in the listening setup; around 25% of consumers prioritise a fixed, repeatable listening position. |
| Fitting two monitors on your desk | Measure the available width and depth on both sides, and allow for stands and the listening direction. | My desk is small or laid out differently on each side; I want to know whether two speakers will fit. Around 25% of consumers prioritise desk space. |
| Connections and what’s included | Compare your source’s outputs with the monitors’ inputs, and check how many speakers are included and which cables you’ll need. | I switch between a computer and an interface, and want to know whether I’m buying a stereo pair that connects to my equipment; around 19% of consumers prioritise connections and what’s included. |
The maximum level doesn’t tell you whether playback is appropriate in your workplace. Arboportaal notes that even quieter sounds can be disruptive.
Agree listening times with colleagues and use headphones when speaker playback would disturb others.
Speaker placement and reflections in the room affect what you hear from your listening position. An uneven setup can make takes harder to compare.
Measure both sides of your desk and check that the speakers can stay aimed at a fixed listening position.
You may need to adjust your workspace or use extra stands to achieve the placement you want.
Genelec states that the 8010A box contains one monitor, while Yamaha specifies the HS4 as a pair.
Check how many speakers are included in the exact version you’re buying, and which cables and connections you’ll need.
Manufacturers may use different measurement thresholds. Kali Audio gives the LP-UNF’s frequency response using a −10 dB definition, while Genelec specifies a low-frequency limit of −6 dB for the 8010A.
Check the measurement basis and placement conditions before comparing frequency limits. A single figure can’t predict what you’ll hear in your office.
ADAM Audio describes the D3V as a compact active stereo system for desktop use.
Yamaha specifies the HS4 as a compact pair with several analogue inputs.
Genelec describes the 8010A as a small active monitor for spaces where room is limited.
Kali Audio positions the LP-UNF as a stereo system for close-up desktop listening.
IK Multimedia describes the iLoud Micro Monitor Pro as a compact monitor with built-in ARC X room calibration.
Whether speaker playback is suitable depends on your workplace and the arrangements you make with colleagues. Arboportaal points out that disruptive noise can occur even at lower levels, so don’t treat legal exposure limits as recommended office volume levels.
No. According to Arboportaal, these figures relate to daily workplace noise exposure and the obligations that come with it. They aren’t recommended volume settings or permission to play sound for colleagues. Even quieter sounds can be disruptive.
Aim both monitors at the same listening position and try to arrange them symmetrically, as Genelec recommends. Keep your listening position and settings consistent while comparing, and check that your desk, screens and walls allow for this placement.
Not always. ADAM Audio lists USB-C for connecting the D3V to a computer, while Yamaha specifies several analogue inputs for the HS4. However, the external audio interface is needed for the subwoofer setup with the D3V described by ADAM. Check your source’s connections and the exact version you’re buying.
ACM ConsuWijzer states that online purchases generally come with a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, with some exceptions. You’re also entitled to a product that meets the standards you could reasonably expect; the seller must resolve any fault in line with the applicable terms. A manufacturer’s guarantee doesn’t replace this statutory right.