Demo editor assessing the stereo balance
Wants to assess vocals, instruments and panning from a fixed listening position, and can position two speakers on an equal footing.
If space is limited and you want a straightforward setup, start with a compact stereo pair. Two separate nearfield monitors are an option if you can position them symmetrically and your equipment has the right outputs. A larger woofer is not automatically the better choice for stereo editing. Your room and listening position affect how you hear the bass.
Wants to assess vocals, instruments and panning from a fixed listening position, and can position two speakers on an equal footing.
Needs room for a complete stereo pair alongside a computer and other work essentials. The monitors’ dimensions and connections are important considerations.
Wants to edit a demo without causing unnecessary noise, so takes listening volume, usage times and arrangements with housemates or neighbours into account.
A good fit if: you have room for two monitors on your desk, but would struggle to accommodate larger cabinets. The Yamaha HS3 and PreSonus Eris 3.5 2nd Gen are sold as pairs.
Bear in mind: check that the inputs on each model are compatible with your computer or audio interface.
A good fit if: you can position two monitors symmetrically and have suitable outputs.
Bear in mind: check whether the package contains one monitor or a pair, and consider how they’ll fit in your own room.
| Consideration | What should you look for? | Who is this most important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Stereo balance and listening position | Check whether you can point two monitors towards your listening position at the same height and distance. Genelec describes an equilateral triangle as the ideal setup. | If I want to assess vocals, instruments and panning from one fixed position, the left and right monitors need to be positioned similarly. Around 28% of consumers give stereo balance their top priority. |
| Size and impact on your space | Measure the space available for both cabinets, and consider how far they’ll be from the walls and your listening position. | If you have limited desk space, you’ll want to make sure two monitors will fit properly first. Around 22% of consumers give fit their top priority. |
| Quiet use at home | Assess the playback volume in your own space and, if necessary, agree on times when you can use the monitors. | If I work in a shared or quiet home, I want to be able to adjust the volume and listening times to suit others. Around 22% of consumers give limiting disruption at home their top priority. |
| Connecting to your existing equipment | Compare the outputs on your computer or interface with the monitors’ inputs, and check which cables are included. | If you want to get started with your existing equipment, make sure the connections are compatible. Around 17% of consumers give compatibility with their own equipment their top priority. |
| Assessing the bass | Read the stated lower frequency limit alongside the dB tolerance. Don’t compare figures with different tolerances directly, and listen from your own workspace. | If low-frequency elements such as bass guitar, kick drum or keyboards are important to my demo, I want to be able to assess the bass from my listening position. Around 11% of consumers give bass monitoring their top priority. |
The Yamaha HS3 is sold as a pair, while, according to Genelec, the Genelec 8010A package contains one monitor. So comparing prices per package may not give you the full picture of what you need for stereo.
Before choosing, check how many monitors are included and which cables come with the specific offer.
For a stereo pair with monitors sold individually, you may need to buy a second one, as well as suitable connection cables.
Yamaha specifies a lower limit of 70 Hz at −10 dB for the HS3; Genelec lists 67 Hz at −6 dB for the 8010A. The measurement tolerances differ, and your room affects what you hear from your listening position.
Check the dB tolerance for each model and assess the bass from your own listening position.
Power alone doesn’t tell you how disruptive the monitors will be for housemates or neighbours. Positioning also affects what you hear.
First, choose a stereo pair you can position well, then adjust the volume and usage times to suit your living situation.
You may need to adapt your setup to the space available or adjust how the monitors sit on your desk.
The HS3 is a compact stereo pair for makers with limited space and several possible analogue sources.
The Eris 3.5 2nd Gen is a compact stereo pair for a desk setup.
The T5V is a separate 5-inch nearfield monitor for a setup with room for two larger cabinets.
The separately packaged 8010A is a very compact monitor for a setup with suitable analogue XLR outputs.
The 305P MkII is a separate nearfield monitor for a desk or for positioning close to walls.
You need two monitors for stereo editing, positioned evenly and facing your listening position. Check the package contents: Yamaha sells the HS3 as a pair, while Genelec lists one 8010A per package.
Place two monitors at the same height and a similar distance apart, facing your fixed listening position. Genelec describes an equilateral triangle as the ideal stereo setup; check the balance again if you change your desk or setup.
For online consumer purchases, you generally have a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, with some exceptions, according to ACM ConsuWijzer. There is no fixed period for statutory guarantees in the Netherlands: the seller is responsible if, under normal use, a product doesn’t meet the standard you could reasonably expect.
Adjust the volume and times you use the monitors to suit your home and the people around you. For noise issues, the Dutch Government recommends first agreeing arrangements with your neighbours, such as when music can be played.