Who is this choice relevant to?

Mixing in a quiet home studio

You mainly want to assess the placement and balance of recorded backing vocals. Open-back headphones may suit you if there’s no live microphone that needs isolating. (RTINGS.com)

A singer who also records at home

You use the same headphones to record vocals and want to stop their sound from getting into the microphone. Focusrite recommends closed-back headphones to reduce leakage when recording vocals.

Mixing with household noise around

Noise in your home studio can make it harder to assess subtle vocal details. In that case, the seal and passive isolation of a closed-back model may matter; the result also depends on the fit.

What should you look for when buying?

Open-back

Choose this if: you mainly mix recorded vocal layers in a quiet room and don’t need to isolate a live microphone.

Trade-off: according to RTINGS.com, sound leaks out and little ambient noise is blocked.

Closed-back

Choose this if: you also record vocals or household noise makes it harder to assess quieter passages.

Trade-off: a closed-back design alone doesn’t prove that the sound balance or fit will suit your mix.

Semi-open

Choose this if: you want to compare a model such as the AKG K240 MKII, and isolation isn’t a deciding factor.

Trade-off: AKG describes this model as semi-open; don’t assume it provides the same isolation as closed-back headphones.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who should pay particular attention?
Balance of vocal layers Compare open-back models using your own reference tracks and pay attention to the fit. Open-back designs leak sound and block little ambient noise. In a quiet room, I mainly want to hear how the vocal layers sit against each other. Around 36% of consumers prioritise mixing performance.
Monitoring while recording Check whether the model is closed-back and fits well; keep the volume at a sensible level while recording. When recording with a live microphone, I want to stop the backing mix from bleeding audibly into the recording. Around 29% of consumers prioritise monitoring while recording.
Household noise Assess the seal in your own listening environment and see whether you can listen somewhere quieter before turning up the volume. With noise in my home studio, I want to assess subtle vocal details without continually turning up the volume. Around 21% of consumers prioritise isolation from ambient noise.
Fit and maintenance If possible, try the headphones during a typical session and check which parts are replaceable on the exact model. For long sessions, I want a comfortable fit that lasts and to know whether worn parts can be replaced. Around 14% of consumers prioritise comfort and maintenance.

Common buying mistakes

  • Choosing open-back mixing headphones without considering future vocal recording

    Open-back models leak sound. When you’re recording with a live vocal microphone, that sound can get into the recording and make monitoring harder.

    Decide in advance whether you’ll also record in the same room. If so, compare closed-back models too. If leakage turns out to be a problem, you may need a second pair of headphones for recording.

  • Assuming every version of a model is the same

    According to the manufacturer, the beyerdynamic DT 770 PRO is available in 32, 80 and 250 ohm versions. The plug also needs to fit your interface’s headphone output.

    Before buying, check the full model version, connection and specifications of your audio interface. Focusrite lists a 6,35mm TRS headphone output for the fourth-generation Scarlett 2i2; a smaller plug will need an adapter.

    If the plug isn’t compatible, you may need a suitable adapter or a different headphone output.

  • Trying to drown out household noise by continually turning up the volume

    According to the World Health Organization, the amount of listening time considered safe decreases as sound levels rise.

    Where possible, find somewhere quieter to listen, consider a well-fitting closed-back model and keep the volume at a sensible level. The World Health Organization gives an average level of 80 dB as one at which listening for up to 40 hours a week is considered safe.

Brands to compare

beyerdynamic

The open-back DT 900 PRO X is worth comparing for mixing in a quiet room; the closed-back 80-ohm DT 770 PRO suits a workflow that includes monitoring while recording.

  • According to the model specifications, the DT 900 PRO X has a detachable cable and a nominal impedance of 48 ohms.
  • The DT 770 PRO is available in several impedance versions. These specifications don’t prove that its sound balance or output levels will suit your equipment.

Sennheiser

The open-back HD 490 PRO is a model to consider for mixing; the closed-back HD 480 PRO is an alternative if recording and isolation matter.

  • Sennheiser lists two types of replaceable ear pads and a detachable cable for the HD 490 PRO.
  • The open-back HD 490 PRO won’t isolate a recording microphone like a closed-back design. Claims about sound and comfort aren’t independent proof that it’s right for your needs.

Audio-Technica

The closed-back, wired ATH-M50x is worth comparing if you record and listen in the same home studio.

  • Audio-Technica lists a detachable cable and describes the model as providing passive isolation.
  • These model features don’t prove that the ATH-M50x has the right sound balance for every vocal mix.

AKG

The open-back K702 is worth comparing for mixing in a quiet room; the K240 MKII is a semi-open alternative.

  • AKG lists a replaceable cable and ear pads for the K702.
  • The K240 MKII’s semi-open design isn’t the same as the isolation offered by closed-back headphones. Brand claims about sound aren’t independent confirmation of performance.

Joybuy product picks

The Joybuy picks below are over-ear headphones for listening; product information for several models also lists a wired listening option. Check each model’s connection and design to make sure they suit your interface and recording needs. Wired listening alone doesn’t prove mixing accuracy.

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless, black

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless, black

An option to compare if you want to listen both wirelessly and with a wired connection.

The product description lists an included 3,5mm cable and passive use without a battery. The title lists 60 hours of battery life, fast charging and four microphones.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Headphones (2nd Gen), Hazelnut Taupe

Bose QuietComfort Headphones (2nd Gen), Hazelnut Taupe

Worth comparing if you want to include a wired listening option in your choice.

The product description lists wired connectivity and listening when the battery is flat. Check which connection and cable will work with your audio interface.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Bluetooth Headphones, black

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Bluetooth Headphones, black

The product description lists a closed-back design and an audio cable, features to consider if you also record vocals.

The description lists active noise cancellation. A closed-back design alone doesn’t determine whether the sound balance is right for your mix.

View at Joybuy
Sony WH-1000XM5 Wireless Headphones with Noise Cancelling, silver

Sony WH-1000XM5 Wireless Headphones with Noise Cancelling, silver

A wireless over-ear option to compare for your listening needs and home studio setup.

The product description lists Bluetooth, active noise cancellation and the ability to connect to two devices.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I use the same headphones to record and mix backing vocals?

Yes, but bear the design in mind: closed-back headphones generally reduce leakage into the microphone while recording, while open-back models may suit mixing in a quiet room. Check your mix on other playback systems too; neither design guarantees the right sound balance on its own.

Which connection do I need for my audio interface?

Check both your interface’s headphone output and the plug on the exact version of the headphones. Focusrite lists a 6,35mm TRS headphone output for the fourth-generation Scarlett 2i2; a smaller plug will need an adapter. Other interfaces may have a different connection.

How do I look after headphones I use regularly?

Follow the care instructions for the exact model and check which parts can be replaced. Sennheiser lists washable, replaceable ear pads for the HD 490 PRO; don’t assume the same care instructions apply to other models.

How can I avoid listening too loudly during long mixing sessions?

Keep the volume at a sensible level and take breaks. The World Health Organization gives an average level of 80 dB as one at which listening for up to 40 hours a week is considered safe. This isn’t a measurement of your headphones’ output or a guaranteed safe volume setting.

What are my rights when buying online in the Netherlands?

When you buy from a business online, you generally have a 14-day legal cooling-off period after delivery, subject to exceptions and conditions that depend on the purchase. ACM ConsuWijzer also states that a product must do what you could reasonably expect when used normally; if there’s a fault, the seller must offer a solution under the applicable terms.