Who is this for?

Comparing takes alongside colleagues

You’re listening at a shared desk and want to limit both background noise and sound reaching other people. Start with closed-back models and check how the ear cups fit your head. Sound On Sound and Focusrite explain why sound leakage matters when colleagues and microphones are nearby.

Editor in a quiet workspace

You’re mainly comparing subtle differences between takes, and nobody will be disturbed by sound escaping from your headphones. In that case, you could also consider an open-back model. Focusrite discusses open-back models for use in the control room; Sennheiser positions the HD 560S for analytical listening and A/B comparisons.

Using a shared audio setup

Several people use the same workstation, or you switch between a computer and an audio interface. So check the connection, fit and compatibility of replacement cables or ear pads. Audio-Technica, beyerdynamic and Sennheiser list model-specific connections or replacement parts.

What should you look for when comparing takes?

Closed-back, wired over-ear

Choose this when: colleagues are working nearby, background noise is disrupting your comparison or you’re recording with a microphone close by.

Bear in mind: the level of isolation varies by model and fit; a closed-back design alone doesn’t prove that the sound is neutral or that the headphones will be comfortable over long periods.

Open-back over-ear

Choose this when: the room is quiet and sound escaping from your headphones won’t disturb colleagues or a nearby microphone.

Bear in mind: open-back ear cups don’t provide the isolation often needed at a shared desk or near a microphone.

Semi-open

Choose this when: the room and other people using it can accommodate some sound leakage, and you can assess the isolation provided by the specific model.

Bear in mind: semi-open doesn’t guarantee sufficient isolation. Focusrite lists semi-open models as suitable for control room use, but describes closed-back models as useful for limiting leakage around performers and microphones.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Isolation and sound leakage Check that the headphones are closed-back and that the ear pads fit around your ears; when recording, consider whether sound could reach a microphone. If I’m working with colleagues nearby or using a microphone, I want to prevent sound from leaking out. For around 33% of consumers, isolation is the top priority.
Differences between takes Compare the same passages at a consistent volume. Treat descriptions such as “accurate” or “flat” as claims made by the manufacturer in question. If I want to assess subtle differences between takes, I’m looking for a useful reference for my material. Around 27% of consumers give analytical comparison the highest priority.
Connection and drive Check the plug, whether you need a 3,5-to-6,35mm adapter, and the recommendations for your exact interface or computer model. If I want to connect one pair of headphones to my computer and audio interface, the combination needs to be compatible and provide enough volume. This is the top priority for around 20% of consumers.
Fit and maintenance Try the headphones with the people who’ll be using them, and check that replacement cables or ear pads are compatible with the full model number. If several people use the same pair or listen for long periods, I want to check that they fit well and that replacement parts are available. Around 20% of consumers prioritise shared use and maintenance.

Pitfalls to avoid when buying

  • Choosing an open-back model without considering the shared space

    An open-back design can let sound reach colleagues or a microphone. A model being marketed for A/B listening doesn’t tell you whether it’s suitable for your workspace.

    First decide whether sound leakage is acceptable where you work, then compare specific open-back and closed-back models.

  • Using impedance as your only measure of compatibility

    The available drive varies by device, and the volume you hear also depends on the source material and listening environment. Impedance alone therefore doesn’t determine whether a combination is suitable.

    Check the plug and recommendations for your exact interface, then test the volume with your own source material without listening at an unsafe level.

  • Choosing replacement parts based on the brand name alone

    Audio-Technica lists a replacement cable that’s compatible with the ATH-M40x, but not the ATH-M50xBT2. Compatibility can therefore vary by model and version.

    Check the full model number against the manufacturer’s compatibility information before choosing a part.

Brands to consider

These examples relate to specific models and product ranges. A brand mention isn’t a recommendation of every model, nor does it indicate availability.

Audio-Technica

The closed-back ATH-M40x is a model to consider for a desk where you compare takes and monitor recordings.

  • Audio-Technica lists swivelling ear cups and two detachable cables for the ATH-M40x. The manufacturer positions the model for accurate monitoring.
  • This positioning isn’t an independent measurement of neutrality and doesn’t automatically apply to other models from the brand.

beyerdynamic

The closed-back DT 770 PRO X is an option if you’re looking for wired monitoring and a detachable cable.

  • beyerdynamic specifies an impedance of 48 ohms and a detachable cable with a mini-XLR connection for the DT 770 PRO X.
  • The features of the DT 770 PRO X shouldn’t be generalised to the 80 or 250 ohm versions of the DT 770 PRO.

Sennheiser

The closed-back HD 280 PRO and open-back HD 560S suit different conditions at and around a shared desk.

  • Sennheiser lists replaceable ear pads and an adapter for the HD 280 PRO. The brand positions the HD 560S for analytical A/B comparisons.
  • The open-back HD 560S doesn’t provide the physical isolation of the closed-back HD 280 PRO; its positioning for A/B comparisons isn’t an independent performance measurement.

Shure

The closed-back SRH440A is designed for recording, editing and monitoring at a desk.

  • Shure lists a detachable straight cable and a 6,3 mm adapter for the SRH440A.
  • The description of the sound as natural and accurate comes from Shure itself; it doesn’t provide an independent comparison with the other models.

Sony

The wired, closed-back MDR-7506 is a model for monitoring and editing.

  • Sony lists a foldable design, a carry case and an adapter for 3,5mm and 6,3mm connections for the MDR-7506.
  • Sony’s description of neutral, detailed monitoring isn’t an independent performance comparison; check that the design and fit suit shared use.

Products at Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use the same headphones with a laptop and an audio interface?

That depends on the connections and headphone outputs on your devices. Check whether you need a 3,5mm or 6,35mm connection or a suitable adapter, and whether your interface can provide enough volume. Focusrite’s impedance guidelines vary by interface generation and aren’t universal.

How can I use one pair of headphones to compare takes?

Keep the listening settings consistent between takes. If a microphone is active, check whether a click track or other playback is bleeding into the recording. The World Health Organization advises considering both the volume and listening duration; avoid listening at a higher volume for long periods to drown out background noise.

Which parts can I replace if several people use the headphones?

This varies by model: Audio-Technica lists a compatible replacement cable for the ATH-M40x, and Sennheiser lists replaceable ear pads for the HD 280 PRO. Before ordering, check the full model number and confirm that the part is compatible with it.

What warranty applies when a consumer buys in the Netherlands?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, if a product breaks sooner under normal use than you could reasonably expect, the seller must put it right free of charge under the legal guarantee. A manufacturer’s warranty period doesn’t automatically set the limit of that legal guarantee; what you could expect from the product depends on the circumstances.

Can I return headphones bought online in the Netherlands?

ACM ConsuWijzer says that online consumer purchases generally come with a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, subject to exceptions. Check the applicable terms before buying, especially if a seller claims an exception applies.