Editors comparing recordings
You switch between recordings and want to assess the differences without mistaking your headphones for a loudness meter. The European Broadcasting Union describes loudness and true-peak measurements as separate checks.
For critical listening in a quiet room, choose between open-back and closed-back headphones based on your surroundings, fit and audio output. Closed-back models are a better choice if you also record or want to reduce background noise. For a fair comparison, keep the audio output and playback settings the same. Headphones don’t measure loudness or true peak themselves, so check these values separately when needed.
You switch between recordings and want to assess the differences without mistaking your headphones for a loudness meter. The European Broadcasting Union describes loudness and true-peak measurements as separate checks.
You compare recordings, but also want to consider whether sound from your headphones could reach a microphone, as well as noise from your surroundings.
You wear your headphones for extended periods, so you’ll want to consider fit, listening volume and whether any parts can be replaced.
Headphones help you hear differences, but they don’t measure programme loudness or true peak. Keep your playback chain consistent and use targets suited to the intended destination when measuring. EBU R 128 cites −23 LUFS for broadcast programme audio, not as a universal standard for every recording.
| What to consider | What to look for | Who should pay particular attention? |
|---|---|---|
| Comparing recordings | Use the same audio output and playback settings; measure loudness and true peak separately if required for your intended destination. | If you want to compare recordings quickly, it’s important to keep your listening chain consistent. Around 36% of consumers prioritise comparing levels above all else. |
| Isolation | Choose a design based on background noise and whether you’ll be using a microphone while recording. | If you record or work in a shared space, you’ll want to reduce background noise and sound leaking into the microphone. Around 29% of consumers prioritise isolation. |
| Fit and listening time | Try the fit for yourself, check whether the ear pads are replaceable and keep an eye on your listening volume. | For long work sessions, you’ll want a comfortable fit and a manageable volume. Around 21% of consumers prioritise wearing comfort and listening for extended periods. |
| Connection | Check which computer or audio interface provides the audio, which connection is available and whether you can play both recordings through the same output. | If you work with two screens, you’ll want to know which device plays the audio and whether the headphones connect to it. Around 14% of consumers prioritise connecting to their workstation above all else. |
A description of the sound is no substitute for measuring programme loudness or true peak.
Choose headphones that suit your listening environment and check delivery values separately. Also check whether your audio software includes the measurement tools you need.
Sound can escape from open ear cups and be picked up by a microphone; beyerdynamic describes its closed-back models as designed to provide isolation when recording.
Base your choice on the room and the type of recording you make, not just a general preference for open-back models.
Having two screens doesn’t tell you which audio output is available or how the headphones will sound through it.
Check the connections on your computer or audio interface and compare them with the cables and connections supplied with the exact model. You may need a suitable cable or adapter, depending on your setup.
The open-back HD 560S is an option for critical A/B listening in a quiet room.
The DT 900 PRO X is an open-back option for critical listening, while the closed-back DT 700 PRO X is designed for recording and monitoring.
The closed-back ATH-M40x is a wired option for anyone looking to combine monitoring with sound isolation.
The closed-back K371 is an option for monitoring and for anyone who wants to consider cable choice or replaceable parts.
No. Listening can help you notice differences, but for a repeatable check you should also measure programme loudness and true peak using suitable software. Only apply a target value if it’s appropriate for the delivery format: EBU R 128 cites −23 LUFS for programme audio, not as a universal value.
No, the number of screens doesn’t matter. Find out which device plays the audio and connect the headphones to the appropriate output on that device. Keep the playback settings the same when comparing recordings, and check that the cables supplied with your chosen model fit the connection.
Keep the volume and listening time down, and take breaks. The World Health Organization gives the example of a maximum of 40 hours per week at an average of 80 dB, and four hours per week at 90 dB. These are guidelines for sound exposure, not a guaranteed safe volume setting on an unknown computer or audio interface.
When you buy from a business at a distance, you’ll usually have a 14-day cooling-off period, although exceptions and conditions may apply. This is different from making a claim under the statutory guarantee if a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect with normal use. According to the ACM, there is no fixed general two-year period for the statutory guarantee in the Netherlands; the seller is your point of contact if a product is faulty.
The product category alone doesn’t mean this applies to every model. According to the European Commission, a CE mark is required when the applicable harmonised EU rules specify that it is for the particular product. So check the model and the rules that apply to it; a CE mark isn’t an independent performance test.