Start by considering how much space the printer needs when it’s in use, then decide whether you need to print rotas in colour. If you mainly print black-and-white rotas, a monochrome laser MFP may be suitable. If you need colour or regularly scan and copy stacks of documents, a colour MFP with an automatic document feeder may be worth considering. Compare the cost of consumables too, and make sure you have appropriate security in place if your rotas contain personal data.
Who is this printer choice for?
Planner with a small desk
You want to print, scan and copy without the device taking over your workspace. So compare the space needed when paper is being fed in and the scanner is open, rather than looking only at the dimensions of the printer when it’s closed.
Planner printing lots of text-based rotas
You regularly print black-and-white rotas and want to be able to top up the paper easily or print double-sided. Brother lists a 150-sheet input capacity for the DCP-L1640W; check which type of double-sided printing the model supports too.
Planner using colour coding
You use colour to distinguish shifts or regularly work with paper rotas. The Canon and Epson models mentioned offer colour printing and an automatic document feeder; check that the capacity suits the number of sheets you handle.
What should you consider when choosing?
Monochrome laser MFP
Suitable if: you print rotas that don’t need colour coding and also want to scan or copy.
Trade-off: colour isn’t available; double-sided printing on the Brother DCP-L1640W is manual.
Colour inkjet MFP
Suitable if: colour coding is important, or you want to scan or copy stacks of paper rotas using an automatic document feeder.
Trade-off: compare the consumables with your own print volume, and measure the space needed with paper feeding and the scanner in use.
| What to consider |
What to look for |
Who is this important for? |
| Space when in use |
Measure your workspace and allow for paper input, output and an open scanner. |
If I also need my desk for other tasks, I want to know how much space the printer really takes up when it’s in use. Around 33% of consumers say available workspace is their top priority. |
| Black and white or colour |
Print a rota in greyscale and check whether shifts are still easy to distinguish. |
If my rota is still readable without colour, I don’t want to choose a colour feature I don’t need. Around 25% of consumers say black-and-white printing is their top priority. |
| Running costs |
Estimate how many black-and-white and colour pages you print each month, then compare the toner, cartridges or refills you’ll need. |
If I regularly reprint documents, I want to factor in ongoing costs, not just the purchase price. Around 25% of consumers say the cost of repeat printing is their main consideration. |
| Colour and handling stacks of paper |
Decide whether you need colour and whether you actually scan or copy stacks of originals; an ADF doesn’t automatically mean double-sided scanning. |
If I use colour coding or handle several paper rotas at once, I want to choose features that suit the job. Around 17% of consumers say colour or handling multiple sheets is their top priority. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Measuring only the printer when it’s closed
The dimensions Canon gives for the PIXMA TS7750i are with the trays retracted. You need access to the paper while printing, and the scanner also needs space.
Measure the spot where you plan to put the printer and check how much space it needs when the trays and scanner are in use.
-
Assuming double-sided printing is always automatic
Brother lists manual double-sided printing for the DCP-L1640W, while Canon lists automatic double-sided printing on supported paper for the PIXMA TS7750i.
Check separately whether double-sided printing is automatic and whether the printer can scan double-sided documents.
-
Looking only at the purchase price
Toner or ink costs can add up, even if you don’t print much. The Consumentenbond notes that inkjet printers may also use ink for cleaning when used infrequently. The consumables you need vary by model.
Compare the consumables for the number of pages you expect to print, and check for any maintenance parts and subscription terms.
-
Leaving printed rotas unattended
If a rota contains personal data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority recommends taking appropriate measures to protect it against risks such as unauthorised access.
Choose where printouts are delivered and how they’re shared in line with your organisation’s risk assessment.
Relevant brands for this printer choice
Brother
The DCP range includes monochrome laser MFPs for printing, scanning and copying. The DCP-L1640W is designed for small workspaces, while the DCP-L2627DWE offers automatic double-sided printing.
- The DCP-L1640W lists LAN, Wi-Fi and USB connectivity and has a 150-sheet paper input tray.
- Double-sided printing on the DCP-L1640W is manual. Check the space needed for each model separately.
Canon
The PIXMA TS7750i is an A4 colour inkjet MFP with an automatic document feeder.
- Canon lists an ADF that holds up to 35 sheets and automatic double-sided printing on supported paper.
- The stated dimensions are with the trays retracted; measure the space needed when the printer is in use separately.
Epson
The WorkForce WF-2950DWF is a colour inkjet MFP with an ADF. The EcoTank ET-2860 is an alternative with refillable ink tanks.
- Epson lists a 30-page ADF for the WF-2950DWF.
- The ET-2860’s savings and yield figures are manufacturer claims, not guaranteed costs for your print volume.
HP
The LaserJet MFP M140w is a monochrome MFP for printing, copying and scanning when you don’t need colour.
- The black-and-white model is suitable for rotas that don’t need colour coding.
- HP lists dynamic cartridge security, which can block cartridges without a suitable HP chip. Check this before choosing replacement toner.
Joybuy products for printing and document work
These models are relevant for printing rotas and handling documents. Check that each printer’s features and the space it needs when in use are right for your workspace.
No image available
Brother MFC-J6760DW A3 inkjet printer
Worth considering if you print rotas in colour and also want to handle documents. The model name specifies A3; measure the available space before making your choice.
Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One Colour Printer
An option to compare if you’re looking for a colour printer for rotas and documents. The product name lists wireless connectivity, double-sided printing, copying and scanning.
Joybuy
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer
An A4 inkjet printer to compare for printing rotas. Check that its scanning and copying features meet your document needs.
Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One Colour Printer
Worth considering if you print rotas in colour and are looking at a tank printer. The product name lists double-sided printing, copying and scanning.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Do staff rotas need to be printed in colour?
Only if the layout needs colour to make shifts easy to distinguish. If the rota is still easy to read in greyscale, you could consider a monochrome MFP.
How can I make the most of limited desk space?
Measure the spot where the printer will sit, allowing for paper input, output and an open scanner too. The dimensions Canon gives for the PIXMA TS7750i are with the trays retracted.
Which running costs and terms should I check?
Compare the toner, cartridges or bottles suited to the number of pages you expect to print, and check for any maintenance parts and subscription terms. Brother lists a toner cartridge and drum for the DCP-L1640W; HP specifies dynamic cartridge security for the M140w, which can block certain cartridges.
Can I print and share staff rotas that include names?
Not without considering the privacy risks and how the rotas will be shared. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, organisations must decide on appropriate security measures when rotas contain personal data; sharing staff information also requires a lawful basis and a suitable purpose. This is not blanket permission to display or hand out rotas in any way.