Who is this relevant to?

Rota planner with a small desk

You want to fit an A4 printer on your desk without the paper input, output or open trays getting in the way of your workspace. So compare the space it takes up when in use, not just its dimensions when closed. Canon lists the PIXMA TS3750i’s dimensions with the trays retracted; check how much room you’ll need for your setup.

Creator of text-heavy rotas

You regularly print clear monochrome rotas, and a usable paper tray and automatic double-sided printing may be more useful than colour. The Consumers’ Association notes that laser printers produce sharp text; Brother specifies automatic double-sided printing and a 250-sheet paper tray for the HL-L2400DWE.

Planner who uses colour coding

You need colour to distinguish shifts, or you’d like to scan and copy documents as well as print rotas. Weigh these features against running costs and the space needed for paper input. Canon and Epson describe models with printing, scanning and copying functions.

What factors should you consider?

Consideration What to look for when buying Who might prioritise this
Space while printing Allow room for paper input and output; check whether the printer will fit in the intended spot with paper loaded. I have limited desk space and want to use the printer without blocking my workspace. Around 36% of consumers put usable placement space at the top of their list.
Monochrome text Decide whether the rota will still be easy to read without colour, and whether you want automatic double-sided printing. I mainly print text-based rotas and don’t need colour to tell shifts apart. Around 29% of consumers give monochrome printing their highest priority.
Ongoing printing costs Estimate your monthly print volume and compare the relevant replacement consumables on the same usage basis. I print rotas regularly and want to factor in the cost of replacements, not just the purchase price. Around 21% of consumers prioritise costs based on their expected print volume.
Colour and extra features Check whether you need colour, scanning or copying, and whether double-sided printing is automatic. I want to distinguish shifts with colour or scan and copy paper documents as well. Around 14% of consumers put colour or scanning at the top of their list.

Pitfalls to avoid when choosing

  • Measuring the printer only when it’s closed

    The stated dimensions for the Canon PIXMA TS3750i are with the trays retracted, while paper is fed in from the rear. So make sure the printer will also fit when set up for use.

    When you print regularly, toner, ink and other replacement parts can be ongoing expenses; costs depend on the model and how you use it.

    Estimate how many pages you print each month and compare the relevant consumables based on the same usage.

  • Assuming every replacement cartridge will work

    HP says that the dynamic security feature on the LaserJet M110w may block cartridges with a chip that isn’t from HP.

    A cartridge the printer won’t accept can’t be used for printing.

    Check the cartridge requirements for the exact model before choosing replacements.

  • Leaving a staff rota unattended

    A rota may contain personal information about staff. The Dutch Data Protection Authority cites purpose limitation, data minimisation and security among the principles of the GDPR.

    Limit the information on the printout to what’s necessary, and decide who is allowed to view or take it.

Brands to compare

Brother

Brother offers monochrome models for printing A4 rotas.

  • Brother specifies automatic double-sided printing and a 250-sheet paper tray for the HL-L2400DWE.
  • Brother also lists wired Ethernet and a separate toner and drum for the HL-L2445DW.
  • The models mentioned don’t print in colour; these specifications aren’t an independent assessment of reliability or printing costs.

HP

The HP LaserJet M110w is a monochrome model for anyone looking for a printer focused on printing.

  • HP lists a compact design and print speeds of up to 20 pages per minute for the M110w.
  • HP says dynamic security may block cartridges with a chip that isn’t from HP. Check the replacement cartridge requirements for the exact model.

Canon

The Canon PIXMA TS3750i combines colour printing with scanning and copying.

  • Canon lists a rear paper feed and dimensions of approximately 435 × 327 × 145 mm with the trays retracted.
  • Double-sided printing is manual. The stated dimensions don’t show how much space the printer needs with paper loaded.

Epson

The EcoTank ET-2870 is a colour printer with refillable ink tanks, scanning and copying functions.

  • Epson describes the model as suitable for printing, scanning and copying, with refillable ink tanks.
  • Compare costs based on your own print volume. Savings and page-yield claims are manufacturer claims based on the conditions specified by Epson.

Products at Joybuy

This selection includes a portable thermal printer, monochrome A4 printers and colour models with scanning and copying functions. Check that the print format and legibility are suitable for your rota, and measure the space needed for the printer and paper feed.

Mini Bluetooth thermal printer

Mini Bluetooth thermal printer

Could suit short text printouts if a portable thermal printer meets your needs; check beforehand that the print format is suitable for your rota.

The product name mentions Bluetooth, multifunctional use and 10 rolls of thermal paper. The product description warns that thermal paper may turn black through friction.

View at Joybuy
Phomemo A282U portable wireless printer

Phomemo A282U

The product description mentions document printing; check that the print format and legibility are suitable for staff rotas.

The product name describes a portable wireless printer. The description mentions Bluetooth and printing via the Phomemo app.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7305 colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7305

An option if you need colour and also want to scan or copy documents as well as print rotas.

The product name lists colour printing, automatic double-sided printing, scanning and copying.

View at Joybuy
Brother HL-L5210DW wireless monochrome A4 laser printer

Brother HL-L5210DW

A monochrome A4 laser printer to consider if you print rotas without colour and want automatic double-sided printing.

The product name lists wireless monochrome laser printing on A4; the product description mentions Wi-Fi, Ethernet, USB and automatic double-sided printing.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7005

An option if colour rotas and scanning or copying are part of how you use your printer.

The product name lists wireless colour printing, automatic double-sided printing, scanning and copying.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do you need colour for a staff rota?

Only if colour coding makes the information clearer than monochrome. Print a test copy in greyscale before deciding that colour is essential; monochrome laser printers don’t print in colour.

Will a printer with compact dimensions automatically fit under a shelf?

No. Also check the space needed for paper input and access while the printer is in use. The approximately 435 × 327 × 145 mm dimensions Canon lists for the PIXMA TS3750i are with the trays retracted; paper is fed in from the rear.

What should you check after buying and while using a printer?

Check that the printer can connect to your work devices, which replacements are suitable for the model, and what maintenance the manufacturer recommends. Brother lists Wi-Fi and USB for the HL-L2400DWE; chip requirements may affect your cartridge choice for the HP LaserJet M110w.

How do you compare the costs of a printer and an ink tank model?

Compare the purchase price and suitable replacements using the same estimated monthly page count. The Consumers’ Association notes that ink costs can add up for some printers, and that print volume affects the cost comparison. For your own use, the comparison will depend on your print volume and the price of replacements.

Can you print and display a staff rota with people’s names on it?

It depends on the information on the rota and who can see the printout. When processing personal data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority cites principles including purpose limitation, data minimisation and security. Keep the printout to the information that’s necessary, and decide who can access it.