First, check how many players the game allows at the same time on one system and screen. Being able to connect extra controllers doesn’t automatically mean you get more player slots. For up to four players, individual Joy-Cons may be an option in supported Switch games, while a full gamepad gives each player their own controls. For more than four players on one screen, extra equipment alone won’t be enough: for Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, Nintendo UK lists up to eight players in local wireless play using multiple systems, not on a single split screen.
Who should consider their controller options?
Race night organiser
Wants to know in advance how many people can play at once on the available screen and system, and how many extra controllers are needed. Nintendo UK lists up to four players on a split screen for Mario Kart 8 Deluxe; local wireless play using multiple systems supports up to eight.
Switch owner playing with extra players
Wants to use existing Joy-Cons or add controllers without confusing the original Joy-Con with Joy-Con 2. Nintendo states that Joy-Con 2 only works with Switch 2; original Joy-Cons can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be attached to or charged by the system.
Xbox or PS5 host
Wants to organise controllers for a local racing game on their console and bear in mind the game’s player limit. The Xbox and PlayStation pages for Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds each list local multiplayer for two to four players on the relevant console.
What should you look for in controllers for group races?
Start with the exact console and racing game: the number of controllers you can connect isn’t the same as the number of racers on one screen. Nintendo UK lists up to four players on one system for split-screen Mario Kart 8 Deluxe and Mario Kart World on a single Switch 2 system. For Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, Nintendo lists up to eight players in local wireless play using multiple systems.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Compatibility |
Note the console generation and the full controller name, then check that the controller works with both the game and console. Some models may also require a firmware update. |
I want to avoid buying a controller that won’t work with my console, for example when comparing Switch and Switch 2 accessories. Around 36% of consumers give compatibility top priority. |
| Number of player slots |
Check the player limit for the exact game and whether it applies to one system, one screen or multiple systems. Count the controls needed per player, not just the number of controllers in a pack. |
I want everyone to be able to race at once, without buying extra controllers for player slots the game doesn’t offer. Around 29% of consumers prioritise the number of players who can play at the same time. |
| Grip and controls |
Decide whether players want to use an individual Joy-Con or a full gamepad. Also check that any steering wheel accessory fits the right Joy-Con generation. |
I want to know whether the group would prefer to race with an individual controller or a full gamepad. Around 21% of consumers consider their preferred grip and control style the most important factor. |
| Charging and essentials |
Count the controllers you already have and check how they’re charged. Also check whether an accessory includes controllers or is just a grip or steering wheel. |
I want to use my existing controllers and know what else I need to have ready to charge them in time. Around 14% of consumers give charging and additional essentials top priority. |
Common mistakes when buying extra racing controllers
-
Assuming eight connectable controllers means eight players on one screen
For the Mario Kart games mentioned, the player limit on one system or screen is lower than the limit for a local wireless session using multiple systems. Extra controllers won’t let you play with eight racers on one screen if the game has a four-player limit.
First check the player limit for the exact game, then choose the number of controllers you need or the right setup using multiple systems.
Otherwise, extra controllers may not give you any additional player slots.
-
Treating Joy-Con and Joy-Con 2 as interchangeable
Nintendo states that Joy-Con 2 doesn’t work with the original Switch. Original Joy-Cons can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be attached to or charged by the system.
Check your console generation and think about how you’ll charge your existing controllers in advance.
You may need a different controller or a separate charging solution for your setup.
-
Counting a steering wheel accessory as an extra controller
A steering wheel accessory changes the grip, but it isn’t an extra set of controls for another player. Nintendo states that the Joy-Con 2 steering wheel set doesn’t include controllers and is designed for Joy-Con 2 only.
Make sure you have enough working controllers first, then, if you like, choose a steering wheel accessory that fits your Joy-Con generation.
You’ll need to have the Joy-Con 2 that fits the steering wheel set separately.
-
Leaving Bluetooth audio connected when adding a third wireless player
Nintendo states that on Switch 2, no more than two wireless players can connect while Bluetooth audio is connected.
Disconnect Bluetooth audio before connecting a third wireless controller.
Relevant controller brands to consider
Nintendo
Joy-Con, Joy-Con 2 and Switch Pro Controllers are relevant to games on the corresponding Switch generation.
- Nintendo lists individual Joy-Cons as a control option for Mario Kart 8 Deluxe.
- Joy-Con 2 doesn’t work with the original Switch. Original Joy-Cons can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be charged by the system.
PowerA
According to PowerA, the Advantage Wireless Controller is a full gamepad for Switch 2 and other Switch systems listed by the manufacturer.
- PowerA lists motion controls, mappable buttons and a rechargeable battery for this model.
- PowerA states that it doesn’t have HD rumble, an IR camera or amiibo NFC.
8BitDo
According to the manufacturer, the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth is designed for use with Switch and Windows.
- The manufacturer lists compatibility with Switch and Windows.
- According to 8BitDo, a firmware update is required for Switch 2; the stated compatibility alone doesn’t tell you how the controller performs in every racing game.
Microsoft Xbox
The Xbox Wireless Controller is suited to an Xbox or Windows setup; don’t assume it’s compatible with a Nintendo or PlayStation console.
- Microsoft lists Xbox consoles, Windows PCs and Bluetooth for supported devices.
- The number of racers still depends on the game and the play mode you choose.
Sony PlayStation
The DualSense is designed for PS5 players who want to play a local racing game with extra players.
- Sony lists adaptive triggers and haptic feedback as controller features; how noticeable they are depends on the game.
- The PlayStation Store lists one to four local players for the PS5 version of Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds.
Controller options at Joybuy
This selection includes full gamepads and Joy-Con controllers for Switch setups, as well as a DualSense for PS5. Before buying, check that the exact model works with your console and racing game.
Image unavailable
Turtle Beach Rematch Super Mario Jump Wireless Controller
A full wireless gamepad for players looking for a conventional controller for a supported Switch setup.
The product listing mentions 40 hours of battery life, a C button for GameChat and two programmable buttons; the description also mentions shoulder buttons, triggers and a D-pad. The title lists Switch 2 and Switch OLED; check compatibility with your exact console and game.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
PlayStation 5 DualSense Controller, Starlight Blue
A PS5 controller for a local racing session on that console; check how many local players the version of your chosen game supports.
The product listing mentions haptic feedback, adaptive triggers and motion sensors. The PlayStation Store lists one to four local players for the PS5 version of Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, black
A full controller for players who want to use one gamepad per player with a supported Switch game. Nintendo lists one Switch Pro Controller per player for Mario Kart 8 Deluxe.
The product description mentions a built-in battery, motion controls and HD Rumble.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 pair, light blue and light red
A pair of individual controllers for a Switch 2 setup where the game supports Joy-Cons as separate controls. Nintendo states that Joy-Con 2 only works with Switch 2.
The product description lists one left and one right controller, plus two wrist straps. Nintendo lists individual Joy-Cons as a control option for Mario Kart 8 Deluxe.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can I use eight controllers to play Mario Kart with eight people on one Switch screen?
No. The number of controllers you can connect isn’t the same as the player limit on one screen. Nintendo UK lists up to four players in split-screen mode for Mario Kart 8 Deluxe; local wireless play using multiple systems supports up to eight. Mario Kart World supports up to four players on a single Switch 2 system.
Will my original Joy-Cons work with Switch 2, and how do I charge them?
According to Nintendo, original Joy-Cons can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be attached to or charged by the system. You’ll need an original Switch or a suitable licensed charging accessory to charge them.
Do I need to buy a steering wheel for every player?
No, a steering wheel accessory isn’t essential for racing. Mario Kart World also supports steering with a control stick. Nintendo’s Joy-Con 2 steering wheel set is a separate accessory for Joy-Con 2 and doesn’t include a controller.
Why won’t a third wireless controller connect to Switch 2?
Check whether Bluetooth audio is connected. Nintendo states that no more than two wireless players can connect to Switch 2 while Bluetooth audio is connected. Disconnect the audio before connecting a third wireless controller.
Am I automatically entitled to only two years of legal cover for a controller in the Netherlands?
No. According to the Dutch government, there’s no fixed statutory guarantee period in the Netherlands; you’re entitled to expect a product to last a reasonable amount of time. Contact the seller if the product is faulty. An additional manufacturer’s or paid-for warranty doesn’t replace your statutory rights.