Transferring recordings
You want to take a small set of files from the shared workstation and mainly need a suitable connection and a straightforward transfer. Kingston Technology and SanDisk describe USB flash drives as a way to transfer files.
Choose a standard USB flash drive for a small set of recordings, a portable HDD for a large archive, or an SSD if you often copy large files. If people can be identified from the recordings, also consider the access controls and organisational rules that apply. Check the connection, file format and whether removable storage is permitted on the shared workstation.
You want to take a small set of files from the shared workstation and mainly need a suitable connection and a straightforward transfer. Kingston Technology and SanDisk describe USB flash drives as a way to transfer files.
You’re copying recordings in which people can be identified and want to decide what access controls and security are appropriate for the situation or your organisation’s rules. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable audio recordings to be personal data.
You handle a large number of files or are building an archive. In that case, storage capacity, transfer time and keeping a separate copy may matter more than having a compact device to carry around. Samsung and Toshiba describe portable storage options for different types of transfer and archives.
Suitable when: you want to move a small collection of recordings between authorised computers and have a suitable USB port available.
Bear in mind: a compact design doesn’t automatically mean encryption, and the USB generation alone doesn’t tell you how quickly files will be written.
Suitable when: the recordings are confidential and both your organisation’s policy and the shared workstation allow you to unlock the drive.
Bear in mind: according to Kingston, the Kingston IronKey Locker+ 50 has hardware encryption, but requires two consecutive drive letters to be available.
Suitable when: you often copy larger collections or regularly carry the storage device with you.
Bear in mind: quoted top speeds depend on the connection. Any security software must also be usable on the shared workstation.
Suitable when: you mainly want to store a large archive of recordings and don’t always need the fastest transfer speeds.
Bear in mind: the Toshiba Canvio Basics reviewed here is formatted as NTFS for Windows; Toshiba says it needs to be reformatted for use with macOS.
The right choice depends on what you need to solve first: carrying files with you, protecting identifiable voices, making systems work together, having enough archive space or reducing waiting times.
| Consideration | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Easy to carry | Check that the workstation has an authorised USB-A or USB-C port and consider how much free space you need. | If I want to take a small set of recordings with me quickly, I focus on the connection and how easy it is to plug in. For around 27% of consumers who prioritise straightforward transfers, this is their main concern. |
| Protecting recordings | Check whether voices are identifiable, what policy applies and whether the chosen security features work on the workstation. | If my recordings can be linked to individuals, I want to know who can access them and how the storage is protected. For around 27% of consumers who prioritise protecting identifiable voices, this is their main concern. |
| Compatibility | Check the ports, operating system, access policy and file format before moving files or formatting a drive. | If I need to use files on both the shared workstation and another system, I want to know in advance whether the format will work on both. For around 20% of consumers who prioritise compatibility, this is their main concern. |
| Space for an archive | Add up the file sizes of your current recordings, allow for future growth and decide where a second copy will be stored. | If I manage a large or growing archive, having enough space matters more than simply carrying a small storage device. For around 13% of consumers who prioritise archive space, this is their main concern. |
| Copying time | Compare read and write speeds separately, and check which USB connection the workstation has. | If I often copy recordings or copy a lot of them at once, I mainly want to know how long transfers will take on my workstation. For around 13% of consumers who prioritise copying time, this is their main concern. |
Samsung’s quoted maximum sequential speeds for the T7 apply when it’s connected to a suitable USB 3.2 Gen 2 port. A quoted speed doesn’t automatically tell you how fast files will write on the shared workstation.
Check the workstation’s port and compare the read and write specifications for the direction in which you’ll be copying files.
A large transfer may take longer than expected over a slower connection.
According to Toshiba, the Toshiba Canvio Basics reviewed here is formatted as NTFS by default and needs to be reformatted for use with macOS. Formatting erases existing files, as Apple warns.
Check the current file format and make a separate copy of your recordings before formatting the drive.
Without that copy, you could lose existing recordings.
The products described here use different approaches to security. A security feature on a storage device also doesn’t replace access controls on the shared workstation.
Check which files are protected, how unlocking works and what security measures your organisation’s policy requires.
Kingston offers USB flash drives for everyday file transfers, as well as a separate range with hardware encryption.
The Ultra Flair is a USB flash drive for transferring files via USB-A.
The Portable SSD T7 is an option for larger or regular transfers, provided your computer can make use of the connection.
The Canvio Basics is a portable HDD for anyone looking to store an archive of recordings.
This selection includes portable SSDs, USB flash drives and an external HDD for transferring or storing speech recordings. Before buying, check that the connection and any security features are suitable for the shared workstation.
No image available
A portable SSD for anyone who wants to transfer files regularly; check that the connection is suitable for the workstation.
Storage capacity: 1 TB. Quoted speed: up to 1,000 MB/s.
No image available
A compact USB flash drive for a small set of files; check that the workstation has a suitable USB-A port.
Storage capacity: 64 GB. USB 3.0.
The product description mentions password protection using SanDisk software; check whether you’re allowed to use that software on the shared workstation.
No image available
A portable HDD for anyone looking to store a larger archive of recordings; check the connection and file format before use.
Storage capacity: 2 TB. Connection: Micro-USB B. USB 3.2 Gen 1 (3.1 Gen 1).
No image available
An external SSD for larger or regular transfers; check that the workstation’s USB port is suitable.
Storage capacity: 2 TB. USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 (3.1 Gen 2).
The product description lists USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables, as well as hardware-based AES 256-bit encryption.
No image available
A USB flash drive for transferring files from a USB-C workstation; check that the device supports this connection.
Storage capacity: 512 GB. USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 1 (3.1 Gen 1).
That depends on the file format and whether you’re allowed to use the drive. Apple describes ExFAT as an option for a drive larger than 32 GB that will be used with both Windows and Mac. Toshiba lists NTFS as the factory format for the Canvio Basics reviewed here. Formatting erases existing files, so make a copy first.
First check that the copy has finished, then safely eject the USB flash drive or external drive in Windows before disconnecting it. Microsoft recommends doing this to help prevent data loss.
If losing the recordings isn’t acceptable, keep a separate recovery copy. The Dutch Data Protection Authority lists backups as one possible way to restore access to personal data; the measures that are appropriate depend on the risk.
For consumer purchases in the Netherlands, statutory rights are separate from any manufacturer’s warranty. If a product doesn’t meet the standard you could reasonably expect under normal use, ACM ConsuWijzer says the seller is responsible for providing an appropriate remedy free of charge. What’s appropriate depends on the circumstances.
No. The guidance consulted doesn’t set a general requirement to store every speech recording on an encrypted drive. Recordings in which someone can be identified may be personal data. Organisations must choose appropriate security measures based on the risks; encryption is one possible measure, alongside options such as access controls.