Who is this choice relevant to?

Switch group with players coming and going

You want to know whether the game supports individual Joy-Con as controllers for separate players. Nintendo describes this way of playing for compatible software.

PS5 or Xbox player

You’re looking for an extra controller for your console, and you’ll also want to check how many players the game allows locally. PlayStation says that up to four controllers can be used at the same time on PS5; Xbox Support lists a maximum of eight wireless controllers on an Xbox console.

PC player who games from the sofa

You’re comparing full gamepads that work with your PC and game, and checking the connection used if you want to use several wireless controllers. Microsoft warns that using multiple controllers over Bluetooth on a PC can reduce performance.

What to look for in an extra controller

What to consider What to look for Who it matters to
Compatibility with your system and game Check your exact console model and the controller modes supported by the game. I want to know before buying whether the controller works with my system and the game’s local play mode. Around 36% of consumers put compatibility first.
Controls for the number of players Check the game’s local player limit and whether it supports one Joy-Con per player. If several people are playing together on the sofa, I want enough usable controllers for the number of players the game allows. Around 29% of consumers prioritise the number of players.
Grip and controls required Check whether the game can be played with a single controller, and whether a full gamepad would better suit the controls you need. I want to know whether one Joy-Con offers enough control, or whether I’d rather hold a full gamepad. Around 21% of consumers choose mainly based on grip and controls.
Connection and charging Check the cable length and dock requirements, charging options and the connection your set-up needs. When I’m playing from the sofa, I want to know whether the cable, wireless connection and charging method will work with my set-up. Around 14% of consumers prioritise these practical connection and charging considerations.

Things to check before buying

  • Confusing the maximum number of connected controllers with the number of players

    A console’s limit doesn’t determine how many players a specific game allows locally. Nintendo lists a maximum of four local players on one Switch or Switch 2 for Super Mario Bros. Wonder.

    Check the game’s local player limit and supported controller modes before choosing extra controllers.

    If the cable won’t reach your seat or the dock requirement doesn’t suit your set-up, you’ll need a different controller or a different arrangement.

  • Assuming a commercial warranty is your only protection

    ACM ConsuWijzer distinguishes between statutory guarantees and additional commercial cover. An extended warranty product doesn’t replace your statutory rights if a product is faulty.

    Compare the terms of any additional cover with your statutory rights and check exactly what the provider promises.

Relevant brands

Nintendo

Joy-Con for compatible Switch games and Joy-Con 2 for Switch 2, including for players who want to use a controller individually.

  • Nintendo explains how to use a Joy-Con as a standalone controller when the software and play mode support it.
  • Original Joy-Con work wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be attached to it; Joy-Con 2 don’t work with the original Switch. Nintendo outlines these compatibility limits across the different system generations.

PlayStation

DualSense as a full-size extra controller for local games on PS5.

  • PlayStation says that up to four controllers can be used at the same time on a PS5.
  • When used with a PC, some features depend on the game and connection. PlayStation says that haptic feedback on PC requires a USB connection and support from the game.

Xbox

Wireless controllers for Xbox consoles and compatible Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists support for Xbox consoles and Windows PCs. Xbox Support says that up to eight wireless controllers can be connected to a console.
  • Microsoft warns that performance on a PC may be reduced when several controllers are connected over Bluetooth. The standard model uses AA batteries or a separate charging solution.

8BitDo

Ultimate 2C Bluetooth is a version for Switch; Ultimate 2C Wireless is a different version for Windows and Android.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Bluetooth version supports Switch from version 3.0.0 and Switch 2 from version 20.1.1.
  • The required firmware update is important for the stated compatibility with Switch 2. The name Ultimate 2C Wireless doesn’t indicate the same Switch support.

PowerA

A wired Switch gamepad could suit docked play, as long as the cable can reach your seat.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 3 m cable for the model reviewed.
  • PowerA says that this model can only be used with a docked Switch and doesn’t support HD vibration, IR, motion controls or amiibo NFC.

Controllers for playing together

This selection of Joybuy products includes shareable controllers and full gamepads for different Switch systems. They’re for anyone playing together on one screen or looking for an extra controller for one player.

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair in Neon Green and Neon Pink

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con Pair – Neon Green/Neon Pink

This set of left and right Joy-Con is for players who want to use separate controllers with a compatible Switch game.

The Joy-Con can be used as individual controllers when the game and play mode support it. A full grip offers another way to hold the controllers.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 pair in Light Blue and Light Red

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 Pair – Light Blue/Light Red

These left and right Joy-Con 2 are for Nintendo Switch 2 players looking for controllers for local multiplayer.

The set includes two Joy-Con 2 straps. Nintendo says that Joy-Con 2 don’t work with the original Nintendo Switch.

View at Joybuy
Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave wireless Bluetooth controller for Nintendo Switch systems

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave Wireless Controller

This full-size wireless gamepad is an option for one player looking for a controller for a compatible Switch system.

The product name lists a 40-hour battery life, TMR sticks and two programmable buttons. The product description mentions Bluetooth and compatibility with Switch 2, Switch, Switch Lite and Switch OLED.

View at Joybuy
HORI wired Horipad Turbo controller for Switch and Switch 2, Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

HORI Wired Controller Horipad Turbo – Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

This wired controller is designed for one extra player with a compatible Switch set-up; check that the cable will reach your seat.

The product description lists programmable rear buttons, Turbo and a C button. It doesn’t mention HD Rumble, NFC or motion controls.

View at Joybuy
HORI Super Mario Galaxy wireless Horipad Turbo controller for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2

HORI Super Mario Galaxy Horipad Turbo – Harmony Pattern

This full-size wireless gamepad is for one player looking for a controller for a compatible Switch system.

The product name lists up to 10 hours of battery life, button mapping and a C button. The product description mentions Bluetooth and motion sensors.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are two Joy-Con always enough for two players?

No, it depends on the game and the supported play mode. Nintendo describes using each Joy-Con as a separate controller with compatible software. Check the game settings to see which controller modes are available.

How do you set up controllers for Super Mario Bros. Wonder?

For local play, choose a controller type for each player, as Nintendo describes. With a single Joy-Con 2, the player holds it horizontally and presses SL and SR; for original Joy-Con, follow the controller selection shown in the game.

Can you attach original Joy-Con to a Switch 2 and charge them there?

No. Nintendo says original Joy-Con can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be attached to the system. To charge them, you’ll need an original Switch or a compatible licensed accessory.

What are your rights in the Netherlands if a controller bought online develops a fault too soon?

With normal use, you’re entitled to a product that meets the standards you could reasonably expect. ACM ConsuWijzer says the seller must offer an appropriate remedy free of charge if the product is faulty. Online purchases generally also come with a 14-day cooling-off period from delivery, subject to statutory exceptions; a manufacturer’s warranty doesn’t replace your statutory rights.