Joybuy Insights

Choosing high-protein snacks: how to compare protein bars, wafers and granola

When you’re looking for high-protein snacks, you’ll soon come across terms such as “low sugar”, “high protein” and “no added sugar”. But eye-catching claims on the front of a pack don’t tell you everything about its nutritional value, ingredients or serving size. For example, a low-sugar bar may contain a lot of polyols. And a product with “protein” in its name may actually provide relatively little protein per serving.

Use this practical guide to focus on the information that really matters. You’ll find suitable high-protein snacks, protein snacks or post-workout snacks without relying on marketing claims alone.

Three common pitfalls when choosing high-protein snacks

1. Looking only at the protein percentage

A high protein content per 100 g might sound appealing, but serving size determines how much you actually get. A muesli may contain 22 g of protein per 100 g, while a typical serving is much smaller than 100 g. So always compare:

  • the protein content per serving;
  • the weight of one bar or sachet;
  • the total calories per serving.

For example, a 55 or 60 g protein bar may provide around 18 to 21 g of protein. A small serving of wafers often contains less protein, but may be more convenient as a lighter snack.

2. Assuming “low sugar” means a simple recipe

Many low-sugar protein bars use sweeteners and polyols, such as maltitol, xylitol or sorbitol. These ingredients can improve the flavour and texture, but consuming a lot of them may have a laxative effect or cause digestive discomfort in some people. So, as well as checking “sugars”, look for polyols in the nutrition table.

“No added sugar” doesn’t automatically mean a product is low in calories or carbohydrates either. Always check the full table.

3. Overlooking allergen information

Protein snacks often contain milk proteins, whey, soya, nuts, peanuts or gluten. Some bars also contain bovine collagen. So check the allergens highlighted in bold on the label, especially if you have a food allergy or intolerance. Recipes and packaging can change, so always refer to the current packaging.

Which specifications matter?

Protein per serving

For a practical comparison, protein per item is more useful than protein per 100 g alone. According to the product information, a Grenade Carb Killa bar contains 20 g of protein per 60 g bar. Barebells White Chocolate Almond also provides 20 g per bar, but weighs 55 g.

A wafer may be a more appealing size, but provides less protein: the Nutramino Protein Wafer contains 7.8 g per 39 g pack. That may suit you if you’re after a smaller snack, but it’s not comparable to a full-size protein bar.

Sugar, polyols and carbohydrates

If you’re looking for low-carb snacks or low-sugar snacks, compare these three lines:

  1. carbohydrates;
  2. of which sugars;
  3. polyols.

According to the product specifications, Grenade Fudged Up contains 1.7 g of sugar and 15 g of polyols per bar. Grenade Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough contains 1.5 g of sugar and 19 g of polyols per bar. These are verifiable figures, but they don’t automatically make either product suitable for everyone.

Ingredients and when to enjoy them

Individually wrapped bars are handy when you’re out and about. At home or in the office, high-protein muesli or protein granola may make more sense. Pay particular attention to serving size with granola: per 100 g, it may contain more fat and calories than a bar.

A snack with a chocolate coating and sweeteners can be enjoyed between meals. It’s not a substitute for a varied diet. If you’re having it after a workout, the amount of protein per serving matters most, not just the sporty look of the packaging.

Our recommendations for different needs

Suitable for: Budget-conscious beginners
Nutramino Protein Wafer Chocolate

Nutramino Protein Wafer 12x39g Chocolate

Why it suits this profile: The 39 g portion is compact and individually wrapped. With 7.8 g of protein and 0.3 g of sugar per pack, it’s a convenient option for when you’re out and about or between meals.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The nutrition information is given per pack, so you don’t have to rely on a percentage per 100 g alone. Do check the polyols and allergens, though.

Key benefits & highlights

39 g per pack, two crunchy wafers, 7.8 g of protein and 0.3 g of sugar per serving.

Suitable for: Shoppers looking for premium quality
Barebells Protein Bars White Chocolate Almond

Barebells Protein Bars White Chocolate Almond 12 x 55 g

Why it suits this profile: This multipack combines 20 g of protein per bar with a 55 g serving. The white chocolate and almond flavour is ideal if texture and taste are high on your list.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product information lists both sugar and polyols, so you can compare the low-sugar claim with the full nutrition table.

Key benefits & highlights

20 g of protein, 1.3 g of sugar and 4 g of fibre per bar, in a box of 12.

Suitable for: Specific needs & regular users
Grenade Carb Killa Protein Bars Fudged Up

Grenade Carb Killa High Protein Bars Fudged Up 12 x 60 g

Why it suits this profile: This substantial chocolate bar is individually wrapped and, according to the product specifications, contains 20 g of protein per bar. It’s a filling snack for active people to take to work, the gym or on the go.

How this product avoids the pitfall

As well as 1.7 g of sugar, the label lists 15 g of polyols per bar. This shows why it’s important to read the full table for a low-carb product.

Key benefits & highlights

20 g of protein, 1.7 g of sugar and 5.3 g of fibre per bar, with 12 individually wrapped bars per box.

Suitable for: Breakfast and snacking at home
Holie's Crunchy Muesli Protein Chocolate

Holie's Crunchy Muesli Protein Chocolate - 6 x 400 g

Why it suits this profile: This high-protein muesli is made to be enjoyed at home, for example with yoghurt or milk. It contains 22 g of protein, 21 g of fibre and 2.1 g of sugar per 100 g.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The nutrition information is given per 100 g. Weigh your serving if you want to keep an accurate track of calories, carbohydrates or protein.

Key benefits & highlights

22% protein, 21 g of fibre and no added sugar, according to the product information.

Looking for more options?

We’ve put together a complete, up-to-date list of products that meet these strict selection criteria and the applicable European safety requirements.

Frequently asked questions about high-protein snacks

Which high-protein snacks are suitable for when you’re out and about?

Individually wrapped protein bars and wafers are convenient because you don’t need cutlery or any preparation. Check the size, protein per pack and storage instructions. A 39 g wafer is handy for a smaller snack, while 55 to 60 g bars are a better choice if you want more protein per serving.

Are low-sugar protein bars automatically low in carbohydrates?

No. A bar may be low in sugar but still contain relatively high levels of carbohydrates or polyols. So always check the full nutrition table. With bars containing maltitol or other sweeteners, it’s particularly important not to look only at the “of which sugars” line.

How long do high-protein snacks keep?

Check the use-by or best-before date on the packaging. Bars, wafers and granola should generally be stored in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight. Reseal an opened pack properly and follow the manufacturer’s instructions. If the packaging is damaged or the product smells or looks unusual, it’s best not to eat it.