Which scanner is right for you?

Portfolio creator who wants detail

Wants to assess the colour and detail of important holiday slides after scanning. The Dutch Consumers' Association identifies image quality and the time you’re willing to spend as factors to consider when digitising.

Quick slide selector

Wants to look through lots of slides and save a first selection before the review, without spending time editing every image in detail. Bear in mind that the full workflow also includes loading, checking and organising files.

Manager of a mixed collection

May have other film formats or a large slide archive as well as 35mm slides. Epson and reflecta list different formats, holders and magazines for their individual models, so check that they suit your collection.

What should you look for when choosing?

Standalone slide scanner

A good fit if: you want to make a quick first selection before the review and save files directly to a memory card.

Trade-off: the Dutch Consumers' Association points out that basic slide scanners generally offer less detail, colour quality and scope for adjustment than good film scanners. Checking and editing images afterwards also takes time.

Dedicated 35mm film scanner

A good fit if: you want to edit selected slides on a computer or prepare them for use at a larger size.

Trade-off: Plustek lists an optical resolution of 7200 dpi and an infrared channel for the Plustek OpticFilm 8200i SE. These are manufacturer specifications, not the results of an independent performance test. Scanning and editing take extra time.

Flatbed scanner with transparency unit

A good fit if: you want to scan other originals as well as mounted slides. Epson lists 120/220 film among the formats supported by the Perfection V600 Photo.

Trade-off: you’ll need a computer and suitable software. Check software compatibility and make sure the holders fit your originals.

Large collection: magazine scanner or professional scanning service

A good fit if: you have lots of slides and want to minimise manual changes, or you don’t have enough time to scan the collection yourself.

Trade-off: according to reflecta, the DigitDia evolution works with certain 35mm magazines. If you use a professional scanning service, agree in advance which files and corrections you’ll receive and check that the turnaround time suits you.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who should pay particular attention?
Detail and corrections Compare the scanning method and output files; don’t mistake interpolated megapixels for extra captured detail. Also check that the software works with your computer. If I want to include slides in my portfolio, I need to be able to assess detail and correct colours afterwards. Around 36% of consumers making this choice put image quality first.
Turnaround time Check whether a stated time applies to each image or to a complete batch. Allow time for loading, reviewing and transferring files, too. If the review is coming up soon, I want to have a usable first selection ready in time. Around 29% of consumers making this choice prioritise turnaround time.
Format and holder Check which 35mm slides and any other film formats you have, along with mount thickness and magazine type, before choosing a model. If I have a mixed collection, I want to be sure my slides and holders will actually fit. For around 21% of consumers, format compatibility is their top priority.
Scanning without a computer Check the supported card type and capacity, the file format and how you’ll transfer the files to your presentation device. If I don’t want to use a computer where I’m scanning, I need to be able to save files independently and take them with me in time. Around 14% of consumers prefer a computer-free workflow.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking an interpolated output figure for extra detail

    For the KODAK Slide N Scan, KODAK Photo Plus lists a 14 MP sensor and a 22 MP output mode achieved through interpolation. This output figure doesn’t mean the scanner has a 22 MP sensor.

    Compare the sensor information and scanning method with how you plan to use the scans, and assess test scans of a few important slides.

    Important images may need extra editing or a second scan.

  • Assuming a quick scan means the whole collection will be ready quickly

    A stated time per image doesn’t automatically include loading, checking, selecting and organising files.

    Try scanning a representative batch first, then factor the full workflow into your plans for the review.

    Checking for dust and managing files can add time to the selection process.

  • Finding out after buying that your slides or magazines don’t fit

    The reflecta x33-Scan is specified for mounted slides up to 3.2 mm thick. The reflecta DigitDia evolution is designed for specific magazine types; not every mount or magazine will necessarily fit.

    Measure your thickest mounts and note their format and magazine type before choosing a model.

    You may need a different holder or workflow. If your slides don’t fit, you may have to choose another scanning option after all.

Brands worth comparing

Plustek

The OpticFilm range is worth considering if you mainly want to scan 35mm slides using a computer.

  • For the OpticFilm 8200i SE, Plustek lists an optical resolution of 7200 dpi and infrared detection.
  • These are manufacturer specifications, not an independent measurement of scan results. Check which operating systems are supported.

reflecta

The x33-Scan is a standalone option; the DigitDia evolution is designed for compatible slide magazines.

  • According to reflecta, the x33-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card and supports mounted slides up to 3.2 mm thick.
  • The DigitDia evolution has specific magazine requirements. Check the model and holder against your own collection.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed option if you want to scan other originals as well as mounted 35mm slides.

  • Epson lists holders for four mounted 35mm slides per batch and for 120/220 film.
  • Check that the computer-based workflow and software suit what you want to do and the files you need.

Rollei

The DF-S 310 SE is a standalone slide and film scanner for making a first selection.

  • Rollei lists a screen, internal memory and support for SD/SDHC cards up to 32 GB.
  • A stated time per image doesn’t tell you how long the complete selection, checking and editing process will take.

KODAK Photo Plus

The Slide N Scan, with its 5-inch screen, offers a standalone option for the 135, 110 or 126 originals listed by the manufacturer.

  • According to KODAK Photo Plus, the model has a 14 MP sensor and supports SD/SDHC cards up to 32 GB.
  • The 22 MP mode is interpolated; it isn’t a 22 MP sensor. Also check that the supplied holders fit your originals.

Related products on Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does the stated scanning time tell me how long it’ll take to get my portfolio ready?

No. The time per image isn’t the same as the time needed to complete a whole selection. You’ll also need to allow for loading, checking, correcting colours, organising files and reviewing images.

How can I reduce dust in my scans?

Check your slides and scanner before scanning, and handle the originals carefully. Plustek lists an infrared channel for the OpticFilm 8200i SE, but this feature doesn’t replace clean handling and checking.

When is using a professional scanning service an alternative to buying a scanner?

It may be an alternative if you have a large collection or not enough time to scan it yourself. Agree in advance which resolution, files and corrections you’ll receive, and check that the turnaround time suits your review.

What can you do if the scanner doesn’t work properly after you buy it?

In the Netherlands, contact the seller if the product doesn’t meet reasonable expectations. The Dutch Government explains that there’s no fixed statutory guarantee period in the Netherlands. What you can reasonably expect depends, among other things, on the product and the information provided.

Can I show scanned holiday slides in a portfolio?

According to the Dutch Government, making a private copy of other people’s copyright-protected photographs doesn’t automatically give you permission to distribute or publish them. Before showing or publishing such images, check whether you have permission or another legal basis. This rule in itself says nothing about the rights to your own photographs.