Which scanner is right for you?

Working with mixed film formats

If you have film formats other than 35mm slides, compare the exact film types with the holders supplied for each model. Manufacturers such as reflecta, Epson and KODAK list support for different formats; a holder for one type of film will not necessarily fit another.

Creating editable archival scans

If you want to edit your scans later or save them as TIFF files, check which file formats the device and its software can create directly. Epson lists JPEG and TIFF for the Perfection V600 Photo, while reflecta lists JPEG storage on an SD card for the x66-Scan.

Digitising a large slide collection

With a large collection, consider how much handling is involved, how much control you want over the images and how much time you’re willing to spend. The Dutch Consumers’ Association points out that choosing between scanning the images yourself and using a service depends on factors such as the amount of material, the quality you want and the time available.

What should you look for when buying?

Start with the physical formats and the file types you need; then compare the image settings and the amount of work involved in scanning your collection.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Physical film formats Compare film types and dimensions with the specifications for the exact model. Check which holders are included and whether any holder you need is an optional extra. If I have film formats other than 35mm, I want to know whether each one will fit in the scanner; around 31% of consumers prioritise compatibility with physical film formats.
File output Check whether the device can create JPEG, TIFF or both, and whether files are saved to an SD card or via computer software. If I need a specific file type for archiving or editing, I check this before buying; around 25% of consumers prioritise the digital file formats they want.
Image control Compare the scan settings and correction options for your film type. Treat sensor or optical specifications and interpolated output as separate details. If I want to assess details and may need to correct my scans, I look at the available settings and corrections; around 25% of consumers prioritise control over the scan results.
Work involved with a large collection Check how many images fit in a holder and what you’ll need to do to load, check and organise them. If I want to digitise lots of images, I want to know in advance how much manual work the chosen workflow involves; around 19% of consumers prioritise the time and handling required.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ‘suitable for slides’ means it supports every film type

    Scanners and holders are designed for specific formats. For example, reflecta lists a holder for 126 film as an optional extra for the x66-Scan.

    Make a note of the film types and dimensions in your collection, then compare them with the supported formats and holders included with the exact version you’re considering.

  • Assuming a higher megapixel count means more detail is captured

    Sensor resolution and interpolated output are not the same thing. reflecta lists a 14 MP sensor and 22 MP interpolated output for the x66-Scan; these figures alone are not an independent measure of scan quality.

    Compare sensor or optical specifications separately from interpolated output, and check which settings and corrections are available for your film type.

  • Choosing a JPEG scanner when you need TIFF

    reflecta lists JPEG storage on an SD card for the x66-Scan, while Epson also lists TIFF for the Perfection V600 Photo. Converting a JPEG to TIFF will not give you an original TIFF scan.

    Decide which file format you need before buying, then check whether the device or its software can create it directly.

  • Treating a discontinued model as if it were available new

    Epson Netherlands has discontinued the Perfection V600 Photo. This means you may need to pay extra attention to the condition, accessories and software when looking at a specific unit.

    Check the condition of the device and whether it’s complete, and look for downloads compatible with your operating system. Epson advises selecting your operating system manually on its support page.

    With a second-hand unit, it may take extra time to find missing holders or suitable software.

Brands to compare

reflecta

The x33-Scan is designed for standalone JPEG scanning of 35mm film; the x66-Scan also lists support for certain 120 and 127 films.

  • The manufacturer lists JPEG storage on an SD card for the standalone x33-Scan and x66-Scan.
  • For the x66-Scan, reflecta lists a holder for 126 film as an optional extra. Check the exact film type you have and which holders are included with the listing.

Epson

According to Epson Netherlands, the Perfection V600 Photo is a computer-connected flatbed scanner with holders for various film formats and output options including JPEG and TIFF.

  • Epson lists support for 35mm film and 120/220 film, as well as JPEG and TIFF output.
  • Epson Netherlands has discontinued the V600. If you’re considering a unit, check its condition, holders and software compatibility with your computer.

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8200i SE is a computer-connected film scanner for 35mm slides and negatives.

  • Plustek lists an infrared channel and an optical resolution of 7200 dpi for this model.
  • These are manufacturer specifications, not an independent quality assessment. The listed model specifications do not confirm support for medium format.

KODAK Photo Plus

The Mini Digital Film & Slide Scanner is a standalone option for several older film types, with JPEG output.

  • KODAK Photo Plus lists 135, 126 and 110 film, Super 8 and black-and-white negatives as supported formats.
  • The manufacturer lists JPEG files and support for SD cards up to 32 GB; the card is not included. Check which adapter fits your slides.

Rollei

According to Rollei, the PDF-S 240 SE is a standalone multi-scanner for 24 × 36 mm film and printed photos.

  • Rollei lists SD, SDHC and MMC storage, and support for photo sizes up to 13 × 18 cm.
  • The listed specifications do not confirm support for every film format. Check whether the supported film types match your collection.

Products on Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can one scanner handle all my slides and negatives?

Not necessarily: check whether each model’s supported film types and holders match your collection. A scanner for 35mm film will not automatically support 120, 127, 110 or 126 film; for the reflecta x66-Scan, the manufacturer lists the 126 film holder as an optional extra.

Can one scanner create both JPEG and TIFF files directly?

It depends on the model and software. Epson Netherlands lists JPEG and TIFF for the Perfection V600 Photo; reflecta lists JPEG storage on an SD card for the x66-Scan. Check the output options for the exact version before buying.

What should I check when buying an older flatbed scanner?

Check that the device is complete and in suitable condition, that the film holders you need are included, and that software is available for your operating system. Epson has discontinued the Perfection V600 Photo and advises selecting your operating system manually on its support page.

When is it worth considering a scanning service?

Compare scanning the images yourself with using a service if you have a large collection or would rather spend less time cleaning, correcting and organising your scans. The Dutch Consumers’ Association lists the amount of material, the quality you want and the time you’re willing to spend as factors to consider; ask a scanning service in advance about the file format and which edits are included.