Which scanner is right for you?

Studio with large sketchbooks

If you want to digitise pages larger than A4 in one go, compare the page dimensions with the stated scanning area. Canon lists a maximum of 216 × 297 mm for the CanoScan LiDE 400; Plustek specifies 304.8 × 431.8 mm for the OpticPro A320E with Image Express.

Artist with delicate or textured work

For a bound page or one with raised details, the binding, lid clearance and how the page sits on the glass all matter. Canon says the LiDE 400’s Z-lid can accommodate items up to 21 mm thick. Plustek’s claims about the CCD version’s depth of field are manufacturer claims, not an independent comparison of scan results.

Shared studio with A4 work

If you mainly scan A4 and several people share the workspace, consider how the scanner works with a computer and shared files. The Epson Perfection V39II is a USB model with a stand; Brother lists LAN and Wi-Fi for the MFC-J6760DW.

What should you consider when choosing?

First, measure the page you want to place fully on the glass. Then assess the binding and scanning method, and decide whether the studio needs extra network or printing features.

Compact A4 flatbed scanner with USB

Suitable if: your page fits within the stated A4 scanning area, lies mostly flat and you have a computer available next to the scanner.

Trade-off: larger pages require a different scanner or separate scans that need to be stitched together afterwards.

A3 flatbed scanner

Suitable if: you need to capture larger pages without stitching scans together, or a not-quite-flat original needs particular care.

Trade-off: check the exact version, software and space required; Plustek’s claims about texture and colour reproduction are not based on independent measurements.

A3 all-in-one with network connectivity

Suitable if: the studio needs to print or copy as well as scan, and requires LAN or Wi-Fi.

Trade-off: printing involves ink consumption and maintenance; check separately whether the bound book will fit on the glass.

What to consider What to check before buying Who should consider this?
Will the whole page fit on the glass? Measure the page, including the margins you want to capture, and compare it with the scanning area, not the print size. Do you want to capture a page larger than A4 in one scan? Around 29% of consumers make page size their top priority.
Can the book be positioned safely? Check the book’s thickness and binding, as well as the lid design of the exact version; don’t force a delicate binding. If the binding is delicate or the page won’t lie flat, you’ll want to know how the book rests on the glass. Around 23% of consumers put safe positioning first.
What image quality do you need? Check the optical resolution and available image settings; if colour accuracy is critical, make a test scan first. Do lines, colour or paper texture need to come through clearly in the digital file? Around 18% of consumers put image quality ahead of other considerations.
How will studio members share the scanner? Decide which computer will be used, where files will be saved and whether LAN or Wi-Fi is needed. If several studio members need to scan, you’ll want a workflow that works with the studio’s computers and file folders. Around 18% of consumers make shared access their top priority.
What are the running costs? Compare the cost of the exact version, the software required and, for an all-in-one, the printing consumables. Do you mainly want to digitise work and avoid paying for features you won’t use? Around 12% of consumers put total cost first.

Common pitfalls when choosing

  • Assuming an A3 printer proves that a bound A3 page will fit

    Print size, scan size and positioning a bound original on the glass are three different things. Brother says the MFC-J6760DW can scan up to A3, but that alone doesn’t confirm whether a bound sketchbook will fit on the glass.

    Check the scan size, glass area and lid design of the exact version. Don’t assume the automatic document feeder can scan a bound book.

  • Assuming the highest dpi figure means the best reproduction

    Resolution is just one specification and doesn’t, on its own, tell you how colour or an uneven surface will be reproduced. Manufacturers also make claims about sensors and image quality that aren’t based on independent comparisons.

    Choose according to your original and the file you need. For important work, make a test scan and check the settings available on the exact model.

  • Assuming USB automatically provides network access

    A USB scanner connected to a computer works differently from a device with LAN or Wi-Fi features. The connection alone doesn’t mean studio members can access shared files independently.

    Agree who will scan, which computer they’ll use and which folder the files will go into. Choose network features only if they suit the studio’s workflow.

Brands to consider

Canon

The CanoScan LiDE 400 is a standalone A4 flatbed scanner for a workspace with a computer that has a USB connection.

  • Canon lists a maximum scanning area of 216 × 297 mm and a Z-lid that can accommodate items up to 21 mm thick.
  • A3 pages won’t fit entirely within the stated scanning area. Lid clearance doesn’t automatically mean the inner edge of a bound book will lie flat.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is a standalone A4 photo and document scanner, powered via USB and supplied with a built-in stand.

  • Epson mentions ScanSmart, four buttons and the option to store the scanner on its side.
  • Storing it upright doesn’t mean you can scan a bound page upright. The V39 is a different model from the V39II.

Plustek

The OpticPro A320E with Image Express is an A3 flatbed option for larger originals.

  • Plustek specifies a scanning area of 304.8 × 431.8 mm and a CCD sensor for this version.
  • Plustek’s claims about texture and depth of field aren’t independent evidence of better results. Check the exact version and software: specifications may vary between A320E versions.

Brother

The MFC-J6760DW is an A3 all-in-one for a studio that wants to print or copy as well as scan.

  • Brother says it can scan up to A3 and offers LAN and Wi-Fi connections.
  • It isn’t a standalone flatbed scanner. Printing involves ink consumption; check before buying whether your specific sketchbook will fit on the glass.

Related products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can you scan a large sketchbook in sections with an A4 scanner?

Yes, but you’ll need to align and stitch the separate scans together; it’s not the same as capturing the page in one scan on a suitably sized glass bed. Canon lists software for stitching together originals that are larger than the glass. Decide beforehand whether this approach will work with the binding and the result you want.

How do you keep the glass clean when it’s shared?

For the CanoScan LiDE 400, Canon advises unplugging the USB cable first, then cleaning the glass and inside of the lid with a soft, dry cloth. For stubborn dirt, use a well-wrung damp cloth and dry the surface afterwards. Canon warns against rough cloths, solvents and spraying directly onto the scanner; for other models, consult the relevant manual.

What does the statutory guarantee mean when buying in the Netherlands?

For consumer purchases, the product must be of satisfactory quality; the Government of the Netherlands does not specify a fixed statutory guarantee period. If a product is faulty, contact the seller. If the studio buys in a business’s name, check separately which business terms apply.

Can your studio share scans of someone else’s sketchbook?

Not automatically: the Government of the Netherlands says that, in principle, copyrighted work belonging to someone else may only be used with the creator’s permission. A copy for personal use must not be distributed or made public. If an organisation also processes or shares personal data, the relevant GDPR requirements apply too.