Who is this choice relevant to?

Manager of bound scores

You want to capture books and fragile scores without pressing them completely flat. The scanning method and correction around the spine are important factors in your choice.

Volunteer handling lots of loose parts

You regularly process piles of loose sheet music and want to check whether the largest sheet fits in a single capture and whether the process is practical to keep up.

Manager of the society’s digital archive

You want to organise scans and make them useful for members. As well as legibility, consider the rights to the material and the difference between text recognition and music notation recognition.

What should you look for when choosing?

First decide whether you’ll mainly be scanning bound scores or loose sheets. Then check the largest format you need, the digital output you want and the rights for your society’s intended use.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most relevant to?
Bound or fragile scores Compare the scanning method and curvature correction; make a test scan of a representative double-page spread. If I want to capture bound or fragile scores without pressing them flat, I’ll focus on the spine and legibility; around 28% of consumers say scanning bound music is their top priority.
Rights and access Before scanning, identify which works are protected, who will have access and what permission or licence applies to that use. If I want to use a digital archive with members lawfully, I’ll first want to know what’s permitted for our repertoire and access; around 22% of consumers say rights and access are their top priority.
Processing lots of pages Test a complete score, including page order and export; the stated scan time per page isn’t the same as the time needed for the entire workflow. If volunteers need to process a large pile, I’ll want to know how long positioning, checking and organising take; around 22% of consumers put the processing of large numbers of pages first.
Large loose sheets Measure the largest sheet and check both the maximum scan size and the resolution at that size. When my parts are large and loose, I’d prefer to capture each one in full in a single scan; around 17% of consumers choose format as their main consideration.
Editable music notation Decide whether you need images or PDFs, or OMR output for music notation; assess the conversion using your own scores. If I want to edit or play back the notes after scanning, I’ll need more than a legible scan or text OCR; around 11% of consumers put editable music notation first.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming an A3 document camera is suitable for thick books

    A device designed for flat, loose pages isn’t automatically suitable for bound scores. Capturing a curved page may require some post-processing.

    Before buying, place both a large loose sheet and a representative bound page under the device you’re considering, then assess the scan.

  • Confusing text OCR with music note recognition

    Searchable text or a Word file doesn’t prove that the scanner converts notes into editable music notation.

    Choose according to the output you need: an image-based PDF for reading, or a separately assessed OMR workflow for recognising notes.

  • Assuming purchased sheet music can be shared digitally without restriction

    Owning paper copies doesn’t automatically give you permission to copy, archive or share protected sheet music with your society’s members.

    First identify the repertoire, rights holders, recipients and intended access. Arrange permission or an applicable licence if necessary.

    An applicable licence may be a separate cost; the terms depend on the scheme and how the material is used.

Brands to consider

CZUR

The ET series is designed for bound books, while the Shine 800 A3 Pro is intended mainly for flat, loose pages.

  • CZUR describes the ET series as offering curved-page correction. Check a test scan of your own scores and the size supported by the specific model.
  • CZUR lists a resolution of 205 dpi for the Shine 800 A3 Pro when scanning A3. This doesn’t necessarily make it equivalent to an ET model for thick books.

IRIS

The IRIScan Desk 6 Pro is an overhead option supporting up to A3, for a mix of documents and scores.

  • IRIS lists output formats such as image PDFs and searchable PDFs.
  • The stated text OCR capability doesn’t prove that the scanner recognises music notes. The stated speed per page is a manufacturer claim, not the time needed for the complete scanning workflow.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed scanner for smaller loose pieces and occasional scanning.

  • Epson specifies A4 and 4800 dpi for the Perfection V39II.
  • A full A3 sheet won’t fit on the A4 scanning surface. Check that your scores’ dimensions suit the workflow you have in mind.

Plustek

The OpticBook 4800 offers a flatbed design with a book-edge feature for bound material up to about A4 size.

  • Plustek specifies a 2 mm book edge.
  • Check the model version and availability in your area before buying; the product information behind this specification comes from the manufacturer’s US site.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can our society scan protected sheet music and give the files to members?

Not simply because the society owns the paper copies. Auteursrecht.nl says that permission from the rights holders is needed to make copies of sheet music for a whole choir. FEMU describes licences for certain types of use on behalf of affiliated rights holders; check that the licence covers your repertoire and intended access.

Does a FEMU licence automatically replace the need to buy original parts?

Don’t assume that it does. The KNMO explains that, under its society scheme, the society buys an original copy for each member and then arranges a licence for additional copying. The amounts quoted by the KNMO for 2022 and 2023 are historical rates, not current prices.

How can I check the scanner setup before a large scanning project?

First scan a bound double-page spread and a sheet in the largest format your society uses. Check the spine, small notes, reflections, page order and the exported PDF on the device members are permitted to use for reading.

Can OCR make the notes on my score editable?

An OCR claim alone doesn’t show that it can. OMR is designed to recognise printed music notation; Audiveris describes OMR as technology that converts notation from scans or photos into a digital format. Check the output you need and assess the results using your own scores.

What additional costs should the society allow for?

As well as the scanner, allow for any rights or licences and software needed for your chosen workflow. Check the current terms and costs for your intended use; these depend on the scheme and the features you need.