Who is this guide for?

Player with an existing console

You’re looking for a second controller that works with your console and version of the game. Sony and Microsoft list compatibility by platform; for DUALSHOCK 4 on PS5, Sony also distinguishes between supported PS4 games and PS5 games.

Player in the seat beside you

You want to join in without a cable running between your seats, or you’d prefer a wired controller if you can route the cable safely from the system. GameSir describes the G7 SE as a wired controller.

Switch player with Joy-Cons

You want to check whether separate Joy-Cons will do the job before buying a complete extra controller. EA describes local play using Joy-Cons on one Nintendo Switch.

What should you look for when choosing?

First check your console and game version, then make sure the local game mode supports two players on one system. Next, choose between a wireless controller and a cable that can safely reach the second seat.

What to consider What to check Who should pay particular attention?
Console and game version Make a note of the exact system, game version and full controller model name. Check that the combination is supported. If I buy a controller for a different console or game version, the other player may not be able to join in. That’s why around 36% of consumers put compatibility first.
Local game mode Check that both players can use their own controller on the same system; game modes that use two consoles are different. I want to know before buying that we can play in the same match together. Around 29% of consumers give local two-player controls their top priority.
Connection from the second seat For wired play, check that you can route the cable safely. For wireless play, check the model’s supported connection and power options. If I’m playing from the seat beside someone, I don’t want a cable running between us or pulled taut. For around 21% of consumers, the connection from that seat is the deciding factor.
Do you need an extra controller? Try the controllers you already have first, and check which controls and accessories work with your system and game mode. I want to know whether my existing controllers will do the job before buying anything else. Around 14% of consumers put avoiding an unnecessary purchase first.

Buying pitfalls

  • Choosing a PS4 controller for a PS5 game

    Sony confirms that DUALSHOCK 4 can be used on PS5 with supported PS4 games. That doesn’t automatically mean the same controller works with the PS5 version of a football game.

    Before buying, check which version of the game you’re playing and which controllers it supports.

  • Buying an extra Switch controller without trying the Joy-Cons

    EA describes local FC play on one Switch using separate Joy-Cons, without any extra equipment.

    First, try selecting players and teams with the controllers you already have.

  • Assuming Ultimate 2C versions are interchangeable

    According to 8BitDo, the Ultimate 2C Wireless is designed for platforms including Windows, while the separate Bluetooth version supports Switch. The similar names don’t mean the versions support the same platforms.

    Check the full version name and platform; for Switch 2, also check the stated firmware requirement.

  • Choosing a wired controller without checking the cable route

    According to GameSir, the G7 SE connects via USB-C and requires a cable. So the cable needs to reach from the system to the second seat.

    Plan the route in advance and check that the cable won’t be pulled taut or create a trip hazard.

Brands to compare

Sony PlayStation

DualSense is a documented wireless option for an extra PS5 controller.

  • PlayStation Support explains how to connect an extra DualSense to a PS5.
  • Sony lists DUALSHOCK 4 for supported PS4 games on PS5; check support for your game version separately.

Microsoft Xbox

According to Microsoft, the Xbox Wireless Controller is designed for Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth and button mapping for this product range.
  • The platform listing alone doesn’t confirm that your football game supports local multiplayer for two players.

Nintendo

Joy-Cons and Pro Controllers are relevant if you play on a Nintendo Switch or Switch 2.

  • EA describes local FC play on one Switch using separate Joy-Cons or a Pro Controller.
  • Nintendo says that original Joy-Cons work wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be attached to it; they need an original Switch system or a suitable accessory to charge.

GameSir

GameSir describes the G7 SE as a wired option for Xbox and Windows.

  • GameSir lists Hall Effect sticks and a wired USB-C connection for the G7 SE.
  • Bear in mind the cable route from the second seat; a manufacturer’s claim about stick drift isn’t an independently measured lifespan.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C comes in separate versions for different platforms.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Wireless version supports Windows and Android; for Windows, the manufacturer lists a 2.4GHz adapter or a wired connection.
  • The Bluetooth version is the one listed for Switch. For Switch 2, check the firmware requirement and don’t confuse the two versions.

Controllers on Joybuy

These models are designed for use with Xbox or Windows, Nintendo Switch or Switch 2, and PS5. For your console, also check that the specific football game and local game mode are supported.

Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

A wireless controller for an Xbox or Windows PC setup; check whether your football game supports local multiplayer for two players on the same system.

Microsoft lists Xbox consoles and Windows PCs as supported platforms for this controller range.

Joybuy
GameSir G7 SE Dynamic Blue

GameSir G7 SE Dynamic Blue

A wired option for an Xbox or Windows setup, if you can safely route the cable to the second seat.

GameSir lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11 as supported platforms, with a wired USB-C connection and Hall Effect sticks.

Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller Black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller Black

A Pro Controller for use with Nintendo Switch. EA lists a Pro Controller as an option for local FC play on one Switch.

Check that your game version and local game mode support two players on the same system.

Joybuy
Sony PlayStation 5 DualSense Wireless Controller White

Sony PlayStation 5 DualSense Wireless Controller White

A wireless DualSense for a PS5 setup; check whether your football game has a local two-player mode on PS5.

PlayStation Support explains how to pair an extra DualSense with a PS5.

Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller Black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller Black

A Pro Controller for a Switch 2 setup; check that your football game and local game mode are supported on this system.

Nintendo lists a C Button, mappable GL and GR buttons, and a USB charging cable.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I always need a second controller for FC on one Nintendo Switch?

No, not always. EA describes local 1v1 or co-operative play using separate Joy-Cons, without any extra equipment. Check the controls for the specific game and mode you’re playing.

Is Local Seasons the same as playing together on one console?

No. EA describes Local Seasons as a game mode using two Switch systems with the same FC title. Playing on one Switch with multiple controllers is a separate option.

How do I connect a second DualSense to the PS5?

PlayStation Support recommends pairing it first using a USB cable. If a controller is already paired, you can pair another DualSense wirelessly by going to Settings, Accessories, General and Bluetooth Accessories.

What should I know about charging Joy-Cons on Switch 2?

According to Nintendo, original Switch Joy-Cons work wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be attached to it. You’ll need an original Switch system or a suitable charging accessory to charge them.

Do I need an online membership to play locally on one system?

The Nintendo Switch Online membership mentioned by EA is for playing online with other Switch players. The multiplayer mode EA describes on the same Switch is a different way to play; for other games and platforms, check the requirements for that specific game mode.