Who needs a second controller?

Switch players gaming as a duo

They want to know whether the Joy-Cons they already own will work with their local co-op game, or whether player two needs a full controller. Nintendo Netherlands says that individual Joy-Cons can be used as controllers, depending on the software and play style.

Console duos playing from the sofa

They’re looking for a suitable second controller for PS5 or Xbox and want to play from a seat to the side. Sony explains how to pair an additional PS5 controller, while Microsoft lists support for Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

PC duos sharing one screen

They need to check whether the game supports two input devices and whether the chosen connection works with their PC. Sony and 8BitDo list different connection options and platform support for each controller and version.

What should you look for?

First, check the game’s co-op mode and compatibility with your system. Then work out whether a controller you already own will do the job, and whether a wireless or wired setup suits the side seat.

What to consider What should you check? Who should pay extra attention?
Compatibility Check whether the game supports local co-op, how many controllers you need and whether the exact model works with your console or PC. I want to be sure player two can join in independently in the game we choose. Around 36% of consumers say game and system compatibility is their top priority.
Freedom to move If you’re choosing a wired controller, check that the cable can safely reach the side seat. For wireless play, check which connection is recommended for your system. If I’m sitting next to the sofa, I don’t want a cable running across a walkway. Around 29% of consumers put freedom to move from the second seat first.
Controls and comfort Compare the button layout with what the game requires, and check whether it supports playing with a Joy-Con. For longer adventures, I want a layout and grip that feel comfortable for player two. Around 21% of consumers say controls and comfort are their top priority.
Additional requirements Check the power requirements and accessories included with the version, as well as which usable controllers you already own. I want to avoid buying a second controller that needs unnecessary accessories or upkeep. Around 14% of consumers focus mainly on additional costs and requirements.

Common mistakes when buying a second controller

  • Assuming that two paired controllers automatically mean two players

    The game needs to support local co-op and the chosen controller setup. Sony’s PS5 second controller support feature is specifically designed to let two controllers operate as one player.

    Check the game’s multiplayer information and pair a separate controller for player two when playing co-op.

  • Choosing a controller based only on its series name

    8BitDo lists different platforms and connections for the Ultimate 2C Wireless and Ultimate 2C Bluetooth. So, despite the shared series name, the two versions aren’t interchangeable.

    Check the full model name and compatibility details for the exact version.

  • Forgetting how the controller is powered or whether it can reach your seat

    A wireless Xbox controller uses AA batteries or a suitable charging solution. With a wired controller, your seat is limited by the cable’s reach, and the cable must not create a tripping hazard.

    Check what’s included, measure the route to your seat and choose the power option that suits your setup.

  • Assuming paid extended cover is your only protection

    According to the Government of the Netherlands, there is no fixed statutory warranty period of exactly two years in the Netherlands. Your statutory rights apply alongside any manufacturer’s or seller’s warranty; if a product is faulty, contact the seller.

    Read the terms of any additional cover and compare them with your statutory rights.

Brands worth comparing

Nintendo

Nintendo describes Joy-Cons for supported play styles, as well as separate Switch Pro Controllers for a full controller setup.

  • Nintendo says a Joy-Con can be used as an individual controller, depending on the software and play style. According to Nintendo, the original Switch Pro Controller is compatible with Switch 2.
  • Whether a single Joy-Con is enough depends on the game. Original Joy-Cons can’t be attached to Switch 2 and need a suitable charging option; the Switch 2 Pro Controller is a separate model for Switch 2.

PlayStation

Sony describes DualSense as an additional controller for individual players on PS5, and as an option for supported PC games.

  • Sony explains how to pair a second DualSense wirelessly with a PS5.
  • The built-in battery needs to be charged. On PC, features depend on the game and connection; Sony says haptic feedback on PC requires a USB connection.

Xbox

Microsoft describes wireless controllers for supported Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth and button mapping as features of the Xbox Wireless Controller.
  • The controller uses AA batteries or a suitable separate charging solution. Xbox says Bluetooth reliability can vary on PC.

PowerA

PowerA describes the Enhanced Wired Controller as a wired option for a second player on supported Xbox systems and Windows.

  • According to PowerA, this model has a detachable 3 m USB cable and two mappable buttons.
  • Wired play requires a safe cable route that reaches your seat. The listed specifications apply to this model.

8BitDo

8BitDo lists different platforms and connections for the Ultimate 2C Wireless and Ultimate 2C Bluetooth.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Ultimate 2C Wireless is designed for Windows via 2.4 GHz or USB. The manufacturer says the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth is intended for Switch and Switch 2, subject to the software requirements listed.
  • The similar model names don’t mean the platform support or connection is the same. Check the exact version before buying.

Controllers for local co-op

This selection includes controllers for Nintendo Switch systems, Xbox systems, PC and PS5. Before ordering, check that both the exact version and the game you’ve chosen are suitable for player two.

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave Wireless Controller (Bluetooth) RGB

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave Wireless Controller (Bluetooth) RGB

A wireless controller for a separate player on supported Nintendo Switch systems.

The product name lists TMR sticks, two programmable buttons, four RGB modes and up to 40 hours of battery life. The charging cable isn’t included.

View at Joybuy
HORI Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo, Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

HORI Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo, Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

A wired controller for anyone with a fixed cable connection that can reach the second seat.

The product information lists support for Switch, Switch OLED and Switch 2. The USB cable isn’t included, so check what you’ll need to connect it.

View at Joybuy
Xbox Wireless Controller, Heart Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller, Heart Breaker Special Edition

A wireless controller for a second player on the Xbox systems and PC listed.

The product name lists Xbox Series and PC. The controller uses AA batteries; the product description says two AA batteries are included.

View at Joybuy
KONIX Nintendo Switch JoyPad Controller Pair, blue and red

KONIX Nintendo Switch JoyPad Controller Pair, blue and red

A pair of controllers for two players who each need their own controller.

The product name lists compatibility with Nintendo Switch, Switch OLED and Switch 2, up to 8 hours of battery life and vibration.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller, Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller, Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

A wireless DualSense for a separate player on PS5.

The product name also lists PC, Mac and mobile. The built-in battery needs to be charged; the USB cable isn’t included.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do you always need two new controllers for a local co-op adventure?

No. First, check which controllers you already own and what the game supports. Nintendo says Joy-Cons can be used individually, depending on the software and play style; Nintendo’s It Takes Two page says each player needs a compatible controller.

How do you pair a second DualSense with a PS5?

Sony explains that you can pair it via USB or, if a controller is already paired, wirelessly via Settings > Accessories > General > Bluetooth Accessories. On the second controller, press and hold the create button and PS button, then select the controller using the first one.

Do you need Friend’s Pass to play It Takes Two together on the same sofa?

No. According to EA, couch co-op can be played offline. Friend’s Pass is a separate way for someone without their own full game to join in; it isn’t required for two players on the same system.

What can you expect if a controller bought online in the Netherlands is faulty?

According to the Government of the Netherlands, you’re entitled to a product that works properly, and there is no fixed statutory warranty period of exactly two years in the Netherlands. If a product is faulty, contact the seller. For online purchases from a business, you’ll also often have a 14-day cancellation period, subject to statutory exceptions.