Which scanning option is right for you?

Archivist handling fragile reports

You want to place old, bound or fragile items individually and check that every page has been captured in full. The National Archives includes checking for skipped pages as part of digitisation.

Volunteer with piles of loose pages

You have lots of loose sheets to process and are weighing up the convenience of a document feeder against the option to scan unusual or fragile items on the glass.

Archivist handling mixed sizes

Your collection may include pages or spreads larger than A4. Measure the originals before deciding whether you need a larger scanning area.

What should you consider when choosing?

Compact A4 flatbed

Choose this option if: you mainly scan loose A4 pages or prefer to place reports on the glass one at a time.

The trade-off: you’ll need to place and turn each page yourself; an A4 scanning area won’t capture a larger page or spread in one go.

Flatbed with document feeder

Choose this option if: you have lots of suitable loose sheets and also want a glass bed for exceptions.

The trade-off: fragile or bound items need to be placed on the glass individually; preparation and checking are still necessary.

Flatbed with a larger scanning area

Choose this option if: a measured page or open spread is larger than A4 and fits within the scanning area of the model you choose.

The trade-off: a larger scanning area offers no benefit if your collection contains only A4 originals.

Consideration What to check before buying Who is this important for?
Fragile or bound reports Check that the model has a glass bed and that the original fits on it flat and in full. I want to place fragile or bound reports one at a time and check them. Around 36% of consumers give the careful handling of originals top priority.
Lots of loose pages Check that the scanner has both a flatbed and an automatic document feeder; compare the features of each scanning option separately. When I have a pile of loose sheets, I want to spend less time placing pages by hand, while still being able to scan exceptions separately. Around 29% of consumers prioritise processing loose sheets.
Finding files and managing access Test your preferred PDF or OCR workflow with your own reports, and check scans for legibility and completeness. If several volunteers need to find files, I want a clear filing system and manageable access. Around 21% of consumers give easy retrieval and controlled access top priority.
Pages larger than A4 Measure the width and height of the largest page or spread and compare them with the scanning area of the exact model. I want to capture a large original in one scan if it fits within the scanning area. Around 14% of consumers give a larger scanning area top priority.

Things to consider when scanning

  • Putting every report through the document feeder

    A feeder is designed for suitable loose sheets; bound or fragile items need a different scanning option. The National Archives also highlights the physical condition of archival material as a consideration when digitising.

    Sort the collection beforehand into sturdy loose sheets and items you want to place on the glass individually.

  • Assuming a high dpi figure means a complete, searchable archive

    Resolution is a scanner specification, while filing, text recognition and checking are separate steps. The National Archives describes arranging and making material accessible as part of digital archiving.

    Make a test scan of a representative report and check the text, page order and file name.

    Also set aside time for filing, checking text recognition and looking for missing pages.

  • Assuming every original will fit on A4

    An A4 scanning area can’t capture a larger full page or spread in one go.

    Measure your largest originals in both directions before choosing a scanning area.

  • Automatically saving scans to a shared folder

    A scanning or sharing option doesn’t remove the need to assess personal data and put suitable security in place.

    Decide which reports the group is allowed to process and who can view the digital files before setting up sharing.

    For shared access, you may need to arrange permissions and configure the storage location in advance.

Scanner brands to consider

Canon

The CanoScan LiDE 400 is a compact A4 flatbed option for scanning individual documents.

  • Canon lists a 216 × 297 mm scanning area, five scan buttons including PDF buttons, and USB power for the LiDE 400. Under the specified conditions, Canon gives an approximate scan time of 8 seconds for an A4 colour scan at 300 dpi.
  • The A4 flatbed doesn’t have an automatic document feeder. The stated scan time doesn’t measure the complete workflow, including placing, checking and archiving documents.

Epson

Epson offers both compact A4 flatbeds and models that combine a glass bed with an automatic document feeder.

  • Epson lists a built-in stand and text enhancement features for the Perfection V39II.
  • For the WorkForce DS-1730, Epson quotes 1200 dpi from the glass bed and 600 dpi via the document feeder.
  • These resolutions relate to different scanning options, so they aren’t a direct comparison of scan results. The feeder speed doesn’t automatically include preparation and quality checks.

HP

According to HP, the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed with an automatic two-sided document feeder.

  • HP lists a 60-page document feeder, a maximum of 1200 dpi for the flatbed and a maximum of 600 dpi for the feeder.
  • The quoted feeder speed doesn’t tell you how much time is needed for sorting, checking and archiving.

Plustek

Plustek positions the OpticSlim 1180 as a large-format flatbed option for items such as larger documents and book spreads.

  • Plustek describes large-format scanning features and buttons for tasks including OCR and PDF.
  • Test text recognition with your own reports and check that the scanning area of the exact model is large enough for your originals.

Joybuy products for your scanning needs

These products combine a flatbed for items you want to scan individually with an automatic document feeder for stacks of suitable loose pages.

Canon imageFORMULA DR-F120 flatbed and ADF scanner, A4, black

Canon imageFORMULA DR-F120, A4

The combination of a flatbed and an automatic document feeder gives you a separate scanning option for fragile or bound items, plus a feeder for suitable loose sheets.

Specifications: 600 × 600 dpi; 50-sheet document feeder; duplex scanning at up to 20 pages per minute; output to editable PDF.

View at Joybuy
Epson WorkForce DS-1660W flatbed scanner with automatic document feeder, A4, black and white

Epson WorkForce DS-1660W, A4

The flatbed is designed for documents placed on it individually; the automatic feeder also gives you an option for suitable loose pages.

Specifications: 1200 × 1200 dpi; duplex scanning at up to 25 pages per minute; USB and wireless connectivity; PDF files.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can the group keep school reports indefinitely or share them publicly?

Not without first assessing their contents, the purpose and who will have access. If reports contain personal data, identify an appropriate GDPR lawful basis before processing them and ensure suitable security. The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that the GDPR doesn’t set a specific general retention period for personal data; the group should therefore document how long it will keep the files. Rules for public-sector archives don’t automatically create a retention obligation for a private group. Scanning and sharing publicly are also two different actions.

How can you avoid missing pages or files that are hard to find?

Set up a filing system and naming convention in advance, check scans for image quality and missing pages, and test any text recognition with your own originals. The National Archives describes arranging and making material accessible as part of digital archiving, and also checks for skipped pages during digitisation.

What should you check before installing it on a shared computer?

Check that a suitable driver is available for the operating system, what connection is required and who will have access to the storage location. Canon lists USB-C for the LiDE 400; HP lists a USB connection for the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1. Security measures should be appropriate to the personal data and the risks involved.