For a reading list that consists mostly of black text and only needs printing occasionally, compare a mono laser printer with a scanner with a colour inkjet. Remember to factor in both the printer and its consumables. A cartridge inkjet is a better fit if you also need colour, while an ink-tank printer is worth considering if your household will continue printing regularly after the project. Also check scanning, double-sided printing and document feeding as separate features.
Who is this buying guide for?
Occasional text printing
You print a reading list and not much else, usually in black and white. You mainly want to keep running costs under control and be able to scan when needed. The Dutch Consumers' Association describes toner as an alternative to liquid ink, which can dry out when used infrequently.
Family with colourful schoolwork
You also use the printer for colour documents and want to check whether automatic double-sided printing or a document feeder would suit your needs.
Regular home printing
You’ll continue printing regularly after the school project, so you’re comparing the cost and convenience of refillable ink bottles with cartridge printers.
What should you look for when choosing?
Mono laser all-in-one
A good fit if: your reading lists consist almost entirely of black text and you also want to scan or copy.
Bear in mind: you won’t be able to print in colour; compare the toner and any separate drum individually.
Colour inkjet with cartridges
A good fit if: you print colour school documents as well as reading lists.
Bear in mind: compare the compatible cartridges and remember that an inkjet may use ink for maintenance if it isn’t used often.
Colour inkjet with ink tanks
A good fit if: your household will continue printing in colour regularly after the project.
Bear in mind: the higher upfront cost is harder to justify for a small number of prints. Manufacturer yield claims depend on the conditions of use.
Colour printer with document feeder
A good fit if: you want to scan or copy several separate sheets of paper.
Bear in mind: having a document feeder and automatic double-sided printing doesn’t in itself mean the printer can scan both sides of a page.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this most important for? |
| Black text when printing infrequently |
Check whether you need colour and compare the printer with its compatible toner or cartridges. |
If I only print a reading list now and then, I want a simple solution for black text. Around 36% of consumers say occasional printing and black text are their main purchasing concerns. |
| Colour and double-sided printing |
Check whether you need colour, whether A4 pages are printed automatically on both sides and which cartridges the model uses. |
If I also print colourful schoolwork, I want to know which features I need. Around 29% of consumers say using colour for other purposes is their main purchasing concern. |
| Refill costs for regular printing |
Estimate how much you print and compare the compatible refills for the models you’re considering. |
If printing will continue regularly at home after the project, I want to factor in the cost of refills. Around 21% of consumers say regular printing and refill costs are their main purchasing concerns. |
| Handling several sheets of paper |
Check whether a flatbed scanner is sufficient, how many sheets the feeder can hold and whether double-sided scanning is listed separately. |
If I want to scan or copy several separate paper sources for a project, I want to know whether a feeder will make it easier. Around 14% of consumers say handling several separate sheets is their main purchasing concern. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Looking only at the upfront cost
The printer isn’t the only factor affecting running costs. Toner, cartridges and any other consumables also determine what you’ll need for your printing.
Compare the printer and its compatible refills based on how many pages you expect to print. Brother lists toner and a separate drum for the DCP-L2627DWE.
For this Brother model, bear in mind that two consumables are listed separately: toner and a drum.
-
Choosing an ink-tank printer for a short-term project
A higher upfront cost is harder to justify if you’ll hardly print anything after the reading list. Inkjet printers may also use ink for maintenance when they’re used infrequently.
Think about how much your whole household is likely to print after the school project, not just the reading list.
-
Confusing a document feeder with double-sided scanning
According to Canon, the PIXMA TS7750i has a document feeder that holds up to 35 single-sided sheets. This is different from automatic double-sided printing and doesn’t mean that double-sided scanning is available.
Check for double-sided scanning as a separate feature if you need to handle paper sources with text on both sides.
-
Assuming HP+ and Instant Ink are the same commitment
HP describes HP+ and the Instant Ink subscription as separate services. However, according to HP, activating HP+ means you’ll need an account, a continuous internet connection and original HP ink for the life of the printer.
Before activating either service, read its terms separately and consider whether it suits your printing habits.
Brands to consider
Brother
The Brother DCP-L2627DWE is a mono laser all-in-one for people who mainly print text documents.
- Brother Netherlands lists A4 printing, scanning, automatic double-sided printing and Wi-Fi for this model.
- It doesn’t print in colour; compare the toner and the separately listed drum.
Canon
The PIXMA TS7750i is a colour inkjet all-in-one for school documents where colour or feeding several separate sheets could be useful.
- Canon specifies automatic double-sided A4 printing and an ADF that holds up to 35 single-sided sheets.
- The model uses two FINE cartridges. The stated ADF capacity doesn’t mean the printer can scan both sides of a page.
Epson
The EcoTank ET-2950 is a colour printer with refillable ink tanks for households that continue printing regularly after the project.
- Epson lists printing, scanning, copying and double-sided printing for this model.
- Epson’s savings and page-yield figures depend on the conditions of use and don’t guarantee the results you’ll get from a short reading list.
HP
The HP ENVY 6120e is a colour all-in-one for occasional, varied use at home.
- HP lists mobile printing and automatic double-sided printing for this model.
- According to HP, activating HP+ means additional account, internet and original ink requirements apply. HP+ isn’t the same as a mandatory Instant Ink subscription.
Joybuy printers
This Joybuy selection includes all-in-one printers with printing, scanning and copying functions. For each model, check that the paper size, colour, double-sided printing and document feeder suit your schoolwork.
No image available
Brother MFC-J6760DW A3 inkjet printer
The scanning and copying functions, along with the document feeder, can come in handy if you need to handle paper project sources.
The product information lists automatic double-sided printing and an automatic document feeder that holds 50 sheets.
The product name lists 1200 × 4800 dpi, 31 ppm and Wi-Fi.
View at Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7305
This model could be a good fit if you print regularly after the project and need to handle several separate sheets.
The product information lists refillable ink bottles, automatic double-sided printing and a document feeder that holds 35 sheets.
The product name lists printing, scanning and copying.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S
The scanning and copying functions could be useful if you need to handle paper school documents as well as the reading list.
The product information lists printing, scanning and copying on paper up to A4, a 60-sheet paper tray and two cartridges.
The product name lists 4800 × 600 dpi.
View at Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005
This model could be a good fit if you want to scan or copy as well as print, and print in colour regularly.
The product name lists automatic double-sided printing and scanning and copying functions.
The product information lists refillable ink bottles and wireless connectivity.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Do you need a colour printer for a reading list?
Not if you only want to print black text. In that case, also compare a mono laser all-in-one. Colour matters when other schoolwork actually needs to be printed in colour.
Which printer is right for occasional printing?
If you don’t print often, compare a mono laser printer with an inkjet based on whether you need colour, scanning and copying. The Dutch Consumers' Association points out that liquid ink can dry out when used infrequently. Also factor compatible consumables into your decision.
Is an ink-tank printer a good choice for one short reading list?
It’s harder to justify the higher upfront cost based on one short project alone. An ink-tank printer could be a better fit if your household will continue printing regularly after the project. Manufacturer savings claims depend on the conditions of use.
Does automatic double-sided printing mean a printer can also scan both sides?
No, they’re different features. Canon specifies automatic double-sided A4 printing and a feeder for up to 35 single-sided sheets for the PIXMA TS7750i. Check separately for double-sided scanning if you need it.