Who is a NAS suitable for?

Student working on a single project

You mainly copy recordings for your own work and want to know whether an external drive will do before setting up a NAS. ID.nl explains the difference: an external drive is usually connected to one computer, while a NAS can make files available over a network.

Project group sharing files

You want to access the same files from several devices, with permissions that reflect what you’re allowed to share. Synology describes managing files through Synology Drive from different types of devices; technical access doesn’t determine whether sharing is permitted.

Recording archive manager

You keep several recordings or versions and want to address drive failure, deletion and recovery separately. VeiligInternetten lists external storage as one possible place to keep a backup. You should also check that you can actually restore your files.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start by asking whether one user on one computer can manage with a standalone copy, or whether the project group needs central network access.

Consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
Restoring recordings Make a separate, up-to-date copy and check that you can restore files. Mirroring is no substitute for a backup like this. If I want to recover my project files after they’ve been deleted or damaged, recovery comes first. Around 33% of consumers put recovery ahead of other considerations.
Controlled sharing Check access from the group’s devices and set user permissions according to what you’re allowed to share. If several group members need the same recordings, I want to be able to control who can access them. Around 25% of consumers give controlled sharing top priority.
Easy copying Check that the storage is compatible with your computer. With a NAS, also check which drives and setup are required. For a single project on one computer, I don’t want to deal with more network management than necessary. Around 25% of consumers prioritise ease of purchase and use.
Source files and storage space Estimate the size of your recordings and versions; check the usable capacity and how you want to transfer them. If I want to keep a lot of source material or several versions, the storage needs to meet those requirements. Around 17% of consumers put file transfer and storage space at the top of their list.

Buying pitfalls

  • Assuming mirroring is the only backup you need

    A mirrored setup can keep files available if one drive fails, but it won’t protect them if they’re deleted or damaged, for example.

    Keep an up-to-date copy in a separate location and test that you can restore a file.

    Allow for a separate backup destination and time to check that recovery works.

  • Buying a NAS enclosure without checking the drives

    The number of drive bays and supported drive types vary by model. An enclosure won’t automatically provide the storage setup your project needs.

    Before ordering, check what’s included in the box, which drives are compatible and the usable capacity of the exact model.

    You may need to buy compatible internal drives separately; mirroring requires two drives.

  • Confusing the ability to share files with permission to do so

    Sharing a folder on a NAS doesn’t change the rights to music or recordings. Privacy requirements may also apply to footage in which people can be recognised.

    First establish what you’re allowed to copy and who you can share it with, then restrict access to that group.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DS223j is a two-bay model for project files and PC folder backups.

  • Synology describes sharing, syncing and scheduled PC folder backups through Synology Drive for the DS223j.
  • According to the installation guide, a drive containing existing data will be formatted. Check drive compatibility and keep a separate backup.

QNAP

The TS-233 and TS-216G are two-bay models with different network and memory configurations.

  • The TS-233 has two drive bays, a gigabit network port and a USB 3.2 Gen 1 port. The TS-216G is worth comparing if you specifically need 2.5GbE.
  • According to QNAP, the TS-233 has 2 GB of non-expandable memory and the TS-216G has 4 GB of non-expandable memory. Ports alone don’t determine the transfer speeds your network can achieve.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-bay model for 3.5-inch SATA hard drives.

  • ASUSTOR lists RAID 1 and SMB support for file sharing on this model.
  • According to ASUSTOR, the model has 1 GB of non-expandable memory and supports only 3.5-inch SATA HDDs as internal drives. Manufacturer specifications aren’t an independent real-world test.

NAS products on Joybuy

These Joybuy products are NAS models for central management and sharing project files. When choosing, check which drives and storage configuration will suit the size of your recordings.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

This NAS may suit central management and sharing project files. First check which storage configuration is right for your recordings.

Hard drives are not included.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

This NAS model may suit central management and sharing project files. First work out how much usable storage your project needs.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

This NAS model may suit central management and sharing project files. Check the storage configuration you need before ordering.

This version is supplied without hard drives.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I copy a concert recording for my school project and share it on a NAS?

Making a copy for your own use is different from distributing it. According to the Rijksoverheid, a private copy of protected material must not be distributed or made publicly available. There are exceptions for use in education, subject to certain conditions. This doesn’t automatically mean that you can share a full concert recording through a shared NAS folder or public link. Check the source, rights and intended recipients before sharing.

How can I stop the setup process from deleting my original recordings?

Keep the originals somewhere other than the NAS before setting it up. Synology warns that, for the DS223j, an installed drive containing existing data will be formatted. Read the setup instructions for your chosen model and check that the files open after copying them.

Is RAID 1 enough as a backup?

No. Mirroring isn’t a substitute for keeping a separate copy of your project files. It can keep files available if one drive fails, but it doesn’t provide separate protection against deletion or damage, for example. Keep an up-to-date backup in another location and check that you can restore your files.

What if pupils can be recognised in the concert video?

Before publishing, check who can be recognised and how the footage will be used. The Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens explains that consent and security are required when a school records and publishes footage in which pupils can be recognised. For pupils under 16, the AP specifies parental consent. This guidance on school publications doesn’t automatically apply to every private audio recording.

Do my rights expire after a two-year manufacturer’s warranty?

No. A manufacturer’s or seller’s warranty isn’t the same as your statutory rights. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that a product must meet the standards you could reasonably expect when used normally, and that you should contact the seller if it’s faulty. There isn’t one fixed statutory warranty period of two years for every NAS.