For a careful selection of 35mm portraits, a dedicated film scanner is a better fit if detail and control over your files matter. If your collection includes 120 film, you’ll need a scanner with suitable film holders. A standalone scanner can make it easier to review images quickly without a computer, but according to the Consumentenbond, this route generally delivers lower image quality than a good film scanner. Remember to allow time for checking and editing, too.
Which scanning route is right for you?
If you’re selecting 35mm portraits
If you only want to assess a small number of 35mm images closely, detail and control over your files are important factors. The Consumentenbond identifies image quality, the amount of material and the time available as considerations when choosing how to digitise your images.
If you have different film formats
If you have 120 film as well as 35mm, check that both the scanner and the supplied holders support both formats. The Epson Perfection V600 Photo specifications list holders for 35mm and 120/220 film.
If you want to make a quick first selection
If you have a lot of images to review, or want to make an initial selection without a computer, a standalone scanner or automatic film feed could suit your workflow. The Consumentenbond points out that a quick scanning route generally offers lower image quality than a good film scanner.
What should you look for when choosing?
Start with the film format. Then weigh the level of control you want over your files against the time available for scanning and whether you need to make selections without a computer.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who should give this more weight? |
| Detail and tonal range |
Compare the scanning method and editing options for the exact model. If possible, assess a test file at the intended viewing size. |
If I want to assess a small selection of 35mm portraits closely, I want to stay in control of the scan and editing. Around 36% of consumers put detail first when making this choice. |
| Film format |
Check the format of your negatives and whether the scanner has the right scanning area and film holder. |
If I have both 35mm and 120 negatives, I don’t want to find out halfway through that one format won’t fit in the scanner. Around 29% of consumers give format compatibility top priority. |
| Feed and planning |
Check whether the feed is manual or automatic, and set aside time for test scans and a final check. |
If I have a lot of images to review before my portfolio review, I want to minimise handling each strip and leave time to check the files. Around 21% of consumers put feed speed first. |
| Ease of use and effort |
Check whether you need a computer, which storage medium is used and whether scanning the images yourself is realistic before your deadline. |
If I want to look through portraits without a computer, a standalone workflow is worth considering. If you’re having the images digitised, agree in advance on the files and processing you need. Around 14% of consumers put computer-free pre-selection first. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming a high megapixel or dpi figure proves you’ll get better portrait scans
A manufacturer’s stated figure is not the same as an independent comparison of image quality. The KODAK Slide N Scan tested has 22 MP interpolation on a 14 MP sensor.
Compare the scanning method and, if possible, assess a test file at the size at which you plan to view the portrait.
Allow extra time in case you need to rescan or correct an image.
-
Choosing a scanner before checking your film format
The Plustek OpticFilm 8300i SE and reflecta RPS 10S are designed for 35mm film; the Epson Perfection V600 Photo also specifies holders for 120/220 film.
Check your originals and the holder you need before choosing a model.
If your originals don’t fit the scanner you choose, you’ll need a different scanning solution.
-
Treating a discontinued model as a newly available package
Epson lists the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued. The usability and completeness of any available unit will depend partly on its condition and the parts included.
For the specific unit you’re considering, check that it includes the holders you need and that the software works with your computer.
Missing holders or incompatible software could mean extra work or delays.
-
Assuming infrared correction works for every type of black-and-white film
SilverFast says that infrared light cannot pass through the silver-based emulsion of conventional black-and-white film, so this correction method isn’t a reliable solution for it.
Check whether your originals are colour film or conventional black-and-white film, then choose your correction workflow accordingly.
Even with infrared support, manual editing may still be necessary.
Brands and models to consider
Plustek
According to Plustek’s specifications, the OpticFilm 8300i SE is designed for a computer-based workflow with 35mm film.
- Plustek lists an infrared channel and SilverFast SE Plus 9 software included in the box.
- The scanning area is limited to 35mm. According to SilverFast, infrared correction isn’t suitable for conventional silver-based black-and-white film.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed model for which Epson specifies holders for 35mm and 120/220 film.
- Epson lists film holders for both formats and DIGITAL ICE.
- Epson lists this model as discontinued. If you’re considering an available unit, check the holders included, its condition and software compatibility.
reflecta
According to reflecta, the RPS 10S is designed to automatically feed compatible 35mm film strips.
- reflecta specifies automatic transport for strips containing 3 to 40 images, as well as infrared-assisted dust correction.
- The maximum scanning area is 24,3 × 36,5 mm. Automatic feeding doesn’t replace checking each portrait.
KODAK
According to the product information, the 5-inch-screen version of the Slide N Scan reviewed is designed for making an initial selection from supported film formats without a computer.
- KODAK lists a 14 MP sensor, SD storage and adapters for 135, 110 and 126 film.
- The stated 22 MP is interpolated, not the sensor resolution. The specifications reviewed don’t list support for 120 film.
Joybuy product
The product listed below is an A4 flatbed scanner. This model is only a candidate for scanning old negatives if the specific version supports film. Check which holders or transparency unit you’ll need, too.
No image available
Epson WorkForce DS-1660W Flatbed Scanner, 1200 x 1200 DPI, A4, Black, White
This model is only suitable for old portrait negatives if the version on offer supports film negatives. Check which film holders and transparency unit you’ll need, too.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can an infrared scanner automatically remove dust from old black-and-white portraits?
Don’t rely on this for conventional silver-based black-and-white film: according to SilverFast, the silver-based emulsion blocks infrared light. You may need to use another correction method or edit the images manually.
What should I do if old negatives are wet or stuck together?
Don’t pull the negatives apart or touch the image surface. The National Archives advises seeking professional help as soon as possible if photographic material is damaged.
Is scanning your own images always cheaper than having them digitised?
Not necessarily. For your number of images, compare the cost of buying or hiring a scanner and the time needed for scanning and editing with a per-image quote. Ask the service provider about resolution, file format, how they’ll handle your originals and what corrections are included.
Can I publish scanned portraits in my portfolio?
Not automatically: buying a scanner doesn’t give you the right to publish the images. According to the Dutch government, you may make a private copy of someone else’s copyright-protected photograph for your own use, but you can’t simply share or publish it. The GDPR may also apply when you publish images of identifiable people professionally; the Dutch Data Protection Authority states that you need an applicable legal basis. Check the rights relating to the specific images before publishing them.