Which scanner is right for you?

Photographer with 35 mm landscape negatives

You want to assess fine detail and tonal differences on a computer, and you’re prepared to spend time setting up scans and editing them afterwards. Consumentenbond identifies the amount of material, the quality you want and the time available as factors to consider.

Photographer with 120 film

You scan medium format as well as 35 mm, so check that the scanning bed and film holder support the full negative. Epson specifies holders for 120/220 film up to 6 × 22 cm for the Perfection V600 Photo.

Photographer with lots of negatives

You want to spend less time loading each negative individually, so compare the film holder and any automatic feed options. Consumentenbond highlights the time required as a factor, while reflecta describes the RPS 10S as having an automatic feed.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start with the film format and holder. Then weigh how much control you want over the image against the time needed to load and operate the scanner.

Dedicated 35 mm film scanner

A good fit if: you want to review and edit 35 mm landscape negatives on a computer.

Consider: the stated resolution isn’t an independent measure of visible detail. Check the software requirements and scanning area too.

Flatbed scanner with transparency unit

A good fit if: you want to scan 120 film or printed photos as well as 35 mm. Epson lists holders for 120/220 film up to 6 × 22 cm for the V600 Photo.

Consider: Epson Netherlands states that the V600 Photo has been discontinued. If you find one for sale, check its condition, holders and software compatibility.

35 mm scanner with automatic feed

A good fit if: you have lots of compatible 35 mm images and want to load fewer individually. reflecta specifies an automatic feed of 3 to 40 images for the RPS 10S.

Consider: automatic feed reduces manual loading, but you’ll still need to check and possibly correct your scans. This option is for 35 mm film.

Standalone negative scanner

A good fit if: you want to view compatible 135, 110 or 126 negatives easily and save them directly to an SD card.

Consider: according to Consumentenbond, a basic scanner generally offers lower image quality than a good film scanner. The EU version of the Kodak Slide N Scan requires an SD card, which isn’t included.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Detail and editing Compare sample scans of your film type and check the output formats and software. Treat dpi as a device specification, not an independent measure of detail. If I want to assess fine textures and tonal differences in landscapes on a computer, I look for control over scanning and editing. Around 36% of consumers rank detail and scope for editing as their top priority.
Film format and holders Check that the scanning bed supports the full format and that the appropriate holder is included with the item for sale. If you scan both 35 mm and 120 film, you’ll want to make sure the whole negative fits on the scanning bed. Around 29% of consumers give format compatibility and holders top priority.
Loading and control Check which strip lengths and loading methods the model supports. Also allow time for loading, removing dust, checking and saving your scans. With a large collection of compatible 35 mm images, less manual loading can save time without removing the need to check your files. Loading time is the top consideration for around 21% of consumers.
Operation and storage Check the supported film types, memory card requirements, included accessories and a sample file on your computer. If you’d rather not use scanning software, saving directly to an SD card may matter more than having extensive scan settings. Easy operation is the top priority for around 14% of consumers.

Common buying mistakes

  • Choosing based only on the highest dpi or megapixel figure

    A stated resolution alone doesn’t tell you how much usable detail you’ll get from a scan of a landscape negative. Kodak also distinguishes between sensor resolution and interpolation.

    Compare sample files from your film type and check whether the resolution is optical, hardware-based or interpolated.

  • Buying a standard document scanner or 35 mm scanner for 120 negatives

    A document feeder or a scanning bed designed only for 35 mm doesn’t guarantee that it can scan a full 120 negative.

    Before buying, check support for transparent film, the exact format and whether the holder is included with the item for sale.

  • Assuming the stated scan time is the total time for the project

    The total time also includes loading, removing dust, checking files and saving them. Automatic feed doesn’t replace all these tasks.

    Try a few representative negatives first, then decide whether manual loading, automatic feed or using a scanning service suits your collection.

  • Assuming a discontinued model or standalone scanner is ready to use as supplied

    Epson Netherlands states that the V600 Photo has been discontinued. According to the EU product information, the Kodak Slide N Scan needs an SD card, which isn’t included.

    Check the condition, contents, holders and software compatibility of the specific item for sale. If you’re saving scans directly to a card, also consider how you’ll transfer and store the files.

Brands to consider

Plustek

According to Plustek, the OpticFilm 8300i SE is designed for scanning 35 mm film at a computer workstation.

  • Plustek specifies a hardware resolution of 7,200 dpi, an infrared channel and SilverFast SE Plus 9.
  • The stated scanning area of 36.8 × 25.4 mm is for 35 mm film. Check the software requirements for your computer; these specifications aren’t an independent performance measure.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed option for photos, 35 mm and 120/220 film.

  • Epson specifies film holders for, among other things, two six-frame 35 mm strips and 120/220 film up to 6 × 22 cm.
  • Epson Netherlands states that the model has been discontinued. If you find one for sale, check its condition, included holders and software.

reflecta

According to reflecta, the RPS 10S is designed for processing compatible 35 mm images using a computer.

  • reflecta describes automatic film feed for strips of 3 to 40 images, as well as infrared correction.
  • The manufacturer states that a colour scan at 10,000 dpi and 48 bit takes around three minutes. This isn’t the total project time or an independent speed measurement; checking and editing aren’t included.

Kodak Photo Plus

The EU version of the Slide N Scan is a standalone option for compatible 135, 110 and 126 negatives.

  • Kodak Photo Plus lists a 5-inch screen, a 14 MP sensor and SD/SDHC storage up to 32 GB.
  • According to the EU product information, an SD card is required but not included. The stated 22 MP is interpolated, not additional sensor resolution.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I scan a 120 landscape negative with any 35 mm film scanner?

No, not as a full image if the scanner’s stated scanning area is only for 35 mm film. For another model, check both the scanning area and whether a 120 holder is included. Epson specifies support for this format with the Perfection V600 Photo.

How should I handle fragile negatives while scanning?

Where possible, handle negatives by the edges or by their sleeve. The Library of Congress advises taking care when handling photographic materials.

What extra items should I check before buying a scanner?

Check whether the right film holders, software and storage media are included. The Kodak Slide N Scan, for example, requires a separate SD card. For a second-hand or discontinued model, its condition and software compatibility are important too.

What statutory guarantee applies to a purchase in the Netherlands?

There is no fixed statutory guarantee period in the Netherlands. The Government of the Netherlands states that if a product is faulty, the seller must provide a solution, depending on the circumstances.

Can I share scans featuring identifiable people publicly?

The exception for personal or household use doesn’t apply when images featuring identifiable people are shared more widely. In that case, the Dutch Data Protection Authority advises taking the applicable GDPR rules into account.